Ave Maria (2015) Poster

(I) (2015)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Quietly amusing, questionably Oscar worthy
StevePulaski24 February 2016
France's Oscar-nominated short film Ave Maria is a screwball comedy of sorts, with its main idea revolving around religious tolerance and a desire for conflicting theologians to come together and realize the common good of reaching a goal. Revolving around a group of Israelis that break down in Palestine, Ave Maria depicts contemporary Israel/Palestine relations by having the gang of individuals look for assistance from five nuns.

As one can predict, comedic circumstances do ensue, particularly when the Palestinians are hesitant to even let the Israelis use their telephone. However, once they realize that they can do more by helping the innocent people of Israel rather than further hurting or tormenting them, some cooperation begins to occur. The unsubtle themes of Ave Maria almost effectively undermine the entire film, despite its mildly amusing comedic setup and its strong, albeit flaccid, core theme that emphasizes togetherness rather than further separation. The entire short is quietly entertaining, but questionably Oscar worthy.
2 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Quiet, cute, and humourous
GregTheStopSign955 May 2024
Although it did elicit at least one actual laugh from me, and a number of quiet chuckles, I wouldn't say this short is overly funny though it IS amusing.

It's a cute little short about a family of Israeli settlers whose car breaks down outside a convent of 5 nuns who have taken a vow of silence, inadvertently crashing into the nuns' statue of the Virgin Mary, and the lengths they all go to uphold their religious beliefs (the Sabbath has just taken effect so the father can't operate a telephone, amongst other things, while the nuns have to weigh the responsibility of their vow of silence against the family's need for their help.

Whilst it's not overly memorable, nor is it entirely forgettable as the characters are all well written and well acted.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Slight but very enjoyable and well made.
planktonrules30 January 2016
This film was made in the Palestinian territory and is a comedy about three Jewish people who become stranded there when they smash into a statue of the Virgin Mary at a small nunnery. The problem is that the nuns have taken a vow of silence and the Jewish folks are very observant...so strict as Jews that they cannot use telephones to call for help! What are they to do?

I enjoyed this film and it made me smile. I found the ending a bit predictable but a finely acted and clever short. While I don't think it's the very best of these shorts, it is unusual and sometimes happy films have an edge in winning simply because Academy voters seem to prefer nice shorts as opposed to down-beat ones...and three are very, very downbeat.

Whether or not this one wins, I'll update this review about this. If I were a betting man, I'd put my money on this short--though as I said I don't think it's the very best of the lot.

UPDATE: "Stutterer" took the Oscar for Best Live Action Short.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Decent Comedy
Michael_Elliott26 February 2016
Ave Maria (2015)

** 1/2 (out of 4)

Oscar-nominated comedy about a group of nuns living in the West Bank and three Jewish folks who end up on their door step after a car wreck.

This French comedy certainly isn't any sort of masterpiece but if you enjoy watching shorts then there's certainly enough here to keep you entertained. I think director Basil Khalil does a good job in structuring the story and getting it across. I also thought the short was extremely well-made and there's no doubt that the performances were fine. Did the subject make me laugh as much as I should have? Probably not but it's still worth watching.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
The longer it goes, the more forgettable it becomes
Horst_In_Translation7 March 2017
Warning: Spoilers
"Ave Maria" is a 15-minute live action short film written and directed by Basil Khalil. As this one managed to score an Oscar nomination, it is certainly the filmmaker's most known work by now. But I hope it is not his best because this would mean that his entire body of work is pretty forgettable. This is the story of an Israeli couple (and the man's mother) and what happens if their car stops working while they are in front of a church where a quintet of nuns is currently adhering to a vow of silence. And the fact that it's Sabbath time as well is not helping either as it makes the already difficult task to get a taxi almost impossible. I think the film started in a solid manner overall and it was an okay introduction to the story, even if the nun characters almost all felt interchangeable and the one that did not was given a pretty ridiculous story line eventually with her strong mechanic skills. But while the final solution in this film is pretty interesting and also somewhat funny, this film is pure religion bait with an ultimately not very convincing story that lacks memorable moments and realism. No surprise though the Academy likes stuff like this as it is about collaboration in the most unusual (religious) scenario. The weakest moment of it is probably when pretty early on that statue loses its head as it was obviously done so much for a mix of shock and comedy, but it felt very desperate to me in its attempt to be funny. I guess I can be glad it did not take home the award over the superior "Stutterer". I don't recommend watching "Ave Maria" and I hope Khalil can improve with his next projects.
2 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed