The Neighbor (2017) Poster

(II) (2017)

User Reviews

Review this title
175 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
Slow, no traction indie flick.
OllieSuave-0076 July 2021
From the looks of the movie poster, I thought it would be an exciting thriller with enough mystery and suspense to give you an edge-of-your-seat experience. Instead, what we got was a mediocre movie about a man named Mike (William Fichtner), who likes to garden, finding himself getting smitten with a younger woman who moves in next door with her hot-tempered boyfriend.

Fichtner portrayed his Mike character to be very shy, meek, and mild; however, the results was painfully awkward. You actually feel uncomfortable to be in Fichtner's shoes and you cannot really tell if it was just bad acting or if that is how the character was supposed to be.

While there are some mysterious moments in the movie, including the suspicions of abuse in the hands of the young woman's boyfriend, much of the movie gives you the run around, hinting at excitement and traction but resulting in anti-climatic deliveries. And, much of the supporting characters weren't sympathetic. Mike's wife (Jean Louisa Kelly) was an unforgiving annoying little thing and his son (Colin Woodell) served no purpose in the movie. Mike's friend Brian (Erich Anderson) was an irritating jerk who cusses like a sailor, trying too hard insert some macho-ness in the movie.

Overall, the film is slow with no traction.

Grade D.
15 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Mature and reflective
Leofwine_draca22 July 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Despite a predominance of bad reviews on this site, I found myself warming to THE NEIGHBOUR quite a bit. It looks from the start like it's going to play out as the usual cliched psycho thriller but it turns out to be something a lot more mature and reflective, a character study of various lonely and afflicted personalities who come crashing together in a darkly realistic plot. William Fichtner is the main draw here, acting in almost every scene, and his quiet intensity counts for a lot. This slow builder features harsh realism and an inevitable climax and a story that keeps you gripped along the way.
18 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
William Fitchner 10 out of 10 stars
miescapee17 February 2020
At the bottom it's asking me if I am revealing any spoilers? Let me tell you I really wish I had a spoiler to reveal, like in ending. I was pleasantly surprised by William Fitchners character. He is usually the rogue FBI guy or the bad guy etc. etc. but in this movie he was very mild mannered very shy very meek I have never seen this side to him before. I loved this part for him and he played it beautifully. What I didn't like was not knowing what happened after he sat down and looked at his tomato. I didn't know If he was suicidal I didn't know if he was going to go back to the house and say hey I was defending myself or if his wife was going to come in and be the wife that she is or the Alex blah blah blah or if The car salesman was going to possibly show up in a skirt with a wig because you know he can pull that off really well. I'm just angry because I'm sick and tired of movies that don't have an ending to them or an ending that makes any sense William Fechner, You are awesome you played your part beautifully it was really nice to see you as a good guy🐾💕
23 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
mind numbing slow delusional nonsense
prexactly29 March 2018
Warning: Spoilers
I can't believe I watched this whole thing. If want to watch a frustrating mind numbing slow film about absolutely nothing, then try this. I cannot figure out what the director was trying to achieve here. Nothing makes any sense. Right when you think you've figured out what's going on, and the long (long..., long...) awaited plot is about to unfold.... nope, think again... nothing is going to happen. NOTHING! I mean absolutely nothing! *spoiler alert* The whole movie is about a delusional middle aged man starring at his young neighbor. That's it! nothing else! 80% of the movie is this crazy guy starring at his neighbor... and no, nothing ever happens, until the very end, and then it gets even more ridiculous. Unbelievable nonsense. Please... don't bother. My best guess is that this is about a middle aged man experiencing the onset of dementia, staggering around appearing drunk, starring at nothing, starring at the walls (I actually wondered if he was blind) or his neighbor, unable to complete thoughts or make any logical decisions.
70 out of 103 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Honest Review
Foutainoflife10 December 2018
This film is about a middle-aged man living a mundane life until a couple move into the house next door.

Let me start this by saying that this isn't awful but it's not great either. Our main character is, in my opinion, a strange duck. He comes off as awkward and sorta creepy but that may have been intentional for the emphasis about how stagnant his life is. He's a bit pervy too. He's constantly eavesdropping, gawking at and inserting himself into positions that provide an opportunity to interact with his female neighbor. He also wants to be heroic but when he has the chance he fails to speak his mind.

I'm probably not gonna watch this again. The movie had a slow pace and it was less than thrilling. I didn't care for the way it ended. The acting, camera work and storyline were decent but it is a low budget movie. If you want to kill some time, check it out. If you are looking for dark thrills, you should look elsewhere.
16 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
As slow as a turtle, but your memory'll forget this one happily very fast!
joshistirgendwieschwul27 January 2018
My only connection with this film was the beloved William Fichtner, Master of Supporting Actors. But even his presence here couldn't save this mistake. All ingredients of The Neighbore are one big laugh to all movie fans. Story, cast and plot are far below zero, it's a shame and a complete waste of money to realize such boring movies. Nothing happens in 90 minutes, so the best thing is to use this flick as a sleep maker in case you are suffering from insomnia. And whenever you notice some relation problems, you're right, it's all about that. But instead of councelling sessions for the neighbors, writers, director and their main crew should go in therapy before making another attempt to enjoy us, movie fans. I was just waiting 90 minutes for something to happen but there's nothing to mention here other than this advice: avoid watching this so-called thriller/drama; nothing to thrill and the only drama happens inside yourself, left behind in boredom with a touch of bitterness.
51 out of 74 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Modern
leavymusic-227 July 2020
Modern audience wants violence, twists and more, with this You don't get that So many reviews give it a 1 ! Really unfair, yes it's a slow moving film but its still quite deep or sleep to the rest.. The acting is good and you can see where it's going, the people who knock it are probably better off with Marvel films ! Cause this sensitive story doesn't carry any weapons, just a slice of thought. Ok, it's not a Oscar winner but it holds a lot truths about people growing older, and it's much closer to true life than robot-Men blasting around the universe.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
The trailer tells you the story from front to end and nothing more
ganitawalia5 June 2018
Worst worst worst movie ever!! I LOVE William F but they did him so dirty in this movie. No story line and the trailer tells u every single thing you need to know. Watch the trailer and you've basically watched the movie
34 out of 51 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Absolutely boring and waste of time.
sfwain4 February 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Well it was listed as Drama/Thriller and I kept watching surely something thrilling would happen but it never did. Seriously horrible! Spoiler here: Young couple moves in next to older couple, old guy is always checking out the wife and then starts fantasizing about her. He helps her with garden in her yard & one day the kiss. He foes home & his wife not knowing they kissed tells him to move out. Young couple wife fights with her hubby periodically through movie. At the end hubby comes back to his house trying to get wife back but she says no & leaves the house to go to work. Young couple next door start to fight & he goes over and hits the husband in head with golf club who falls to ground bleeding. His Young wife asks old guy to leave so he goes home and they show him just sitting there and then movie ends. I'll never get those 2 hrs of my life back.
12 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Painful, uncomfortable, cringingly slow yet strangely interesting!
richardstirling18 September 2020
This is a unique film in that it is painfully slow and really uncomfortable. Never have I had to pause a film so many times just to recompose myself from the deep discomfort and embarrassment caused by the lead character.

I can't say I enjoyed it but it is unique and although it is incredibly slow it does keep you interested.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Enjoyed it up until an hour then I dont know what happened
Brooklynsmagicmike30 March 2020
Warning: Spoilers
This movie is slow burn dram. Its story is not all that far-fetched either about an older man in a hapless marriage who becomes Obsessed with the girl next door.

The issue with this movie is once it finally picks up (Him and the girl spend time together and end up kissing) THAT is it. Out of nowhere the movie just dies and falls flat. They never rehash or talk about it again, and his wife who doesn't even find it out happens randomly breaks up with just cause? It made ZERO sense.

Also the ending was pitiful. So he sees the girl getting abused by her husband intervenes in which the husband attacks him first several times and he retaliates accidentally killing him and she kicks him out? Then the movie literally just ends with him walking back to his backyard.

Three words WASTE OF TIME
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Tragedy on Meadowpark Drive
lavatch23 March 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Mike is a good guy. He is a passive, nondescript, laid-back writer of technical manuals, working out of his home. He is a family man, a gardener, and a good cook. But his voyeuristic impulses lead him to become enmeshed in a drama of spousal abuse next door. Is Mike being a good neighbor? Or is he driven by his baser male instincts in the intervention? This modest domestic tragedy might best be called "The Tragedy on Meadowpark Drive."

It is clear that the filmmakers were writing a morality play with characters representing individual human traits.

Mike's wife Lisa is the one-dimensional version of the shrew, rarely showing affection for her husband and clearly calling all the shots in the relationship. Rarely will Mike discuss his wants, needs, and dreams, as Lisa is the controlling figure and shows no concern for her soft male husband. When Mike recalls "Santa Barbara," he was undoubtedly thinking of an exciting time in their relationship that was filled with romance. But for Lisa, Santa Barbara is a forgotten moment in the past that she only associates with sex. Could anyone possibly be more crass and cruel than Lisa for summarily ordering Mike out of the house after he intervened on behalf of the woman next door?

Scott, the new neighbor is a loud-mouthed car salesman and wife-beater. His shallowness and violent temper are his primary traits. One of Scott's goals is to produce babies with Jenna and have a big family. He is obviously unaware of the damage to the planet that he is leaving in his wake in siring a brood of "little Scotts."

Jenna is the flirtatious, flaky, and vulnerable wife of Scott, who is unable to bring herself to get out of an abusive relationship. But that doesn't stop her from shamelessly flirting with Mike, leaning on him when she is depressed, and leading him on to the degree that he eventually crosses the line of propriety.

Of course, the Everyman character of the film is Mike. In Jenna, Mike deludes himself into seeing her as the answer to all that is missing in his stultifying existence. He may be egged on by his callous friend Brian. But the fatal decisions are made by Mike himself.

Mike's major flaw is that he violates that the good neighbor policy by walking into the home of Brian and Jenna in response to her scream. Lisa had warned him, "Call the police!" in the future. But that advice never registers with a poor schlub who never seems grounded enough in reality to behave like an adult. When he finally does take a stand, the result is the tragedy on Meadowpark Drive.
23 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Slow-Paced But Effective
sddavis636 July 2018
I needed to sit with this for a couple of days and give it some thought before I could actually write anything about it. To me, that's a good sign. This was a movie that required some reflection rather than just a knee jerk reaction. My initial reaction to it (even as I watched it) mirrored many of the comments I've seen made about it. It's very slow paced, and there are perhaps times when you wonder what the point of it is - if there is any real point. I've realized that maybe that is the point - that there's no real point to the movie. Not in a comedic "Seinfeld" sort of way, but in a more dramatic, slice of life fashion. We're just watching a guy whose life is slowly falling apart - and, at least for a while, he doesn't even realize that it's falling apart. As Mike, I thought William Fichtner put on a superb performance. He's a middle aged guy with a predictable but satisfactory life. His wife loves him, he loves his wife. They both have careers. They have a home. There might be a bit of tension with his son (the movie hints that the father-son relationship isn't perfect) but - hey - even that's part of real life. Basically, things are OK for Mike - if a little bit predictable. And then, into the middle of this predictable, "satisfactory" life, he gets new neighbours: Jenna and Scott. They're a young, attractive, friendly and outgoing couple. And Mike starts to fall for Jenna.

That's where things go off track. Maybe until Jenna appeared he hadn't even realized that his life - being satisfactory - was actually a little unsatisfactory to him. And instead of choosing to spice up his own life and marriage, he falls for the fantasy. He gets increasingly obsessed with Jenna. It's a typical mid-life crisis, helped along by a friend of his who sees the spark with Jenna and encourages him to go with it - after all, in the eyes of his friend this is apparently how you keep your own marriage happy. This was where Fichtner really shone I thought. He's a quiet, soft spoken, kind of dull guy. He moves slowly, he speaks slowly, there doesn't seem to be much passion in him. Everything about him screams "average" and "typical." There's nothing outstanding about him. But he likes Jenna. Perhaps innocently at first. Even his wife teases him about having a "crush" on Jenna. But it grows and it grows. And Jenna's life isn't blissful either. Scott turns out to be a less than ideal husband, and Mike starts to think he's abusive toward Jenna. Jenna needs consoling - someone to make her feel better. And Mike's right there. And they connect. They kiss. Nothing more than that, but it's moving in the direction of something bigger. Jenna, to be honest, is a more or less sympathetic character. You can understand her starting to fall for a guy who's everything that her husband isn't - kind, attentive, gentle, helpful. But you're increasingly appalled by Mike. He had a good life - and he's throwing it all away. And the whole movie becomes this study of Mike, and his relationships with Jenna, and his wife, and ultimately with Scott - who definitely notices something's going on.

I've seen Fichtner in a few things, and I have to admit that he's never really stood out from the crowd for me - but in this, he nailed the part. And I would credit Jessica McNamee as well. I'm totally unfamiliar with her, but she also captured the part of Jenna. At first, she's the young woman in the seemingly normal, happy marriage, but McNamee gradually and effectively reveals layers to the character as the movie went on. These were two very good performances. Admittedly, this movie isn't going to be for everyone. Those who've become accustomed to high-octane all-action films are going to find this a frustrating "slog" to say the least. It's driven by character and not action. It's about life - it's not a fantasy - and there's a certain believability to it. But a lot of people don't want to watch a movie about life. They want an escape. I get that. So not everyone will appreciate this - and, as I said, it really took me a couple of days of mulling it over before I really came to fully appreciate it. I will say that after a pretty slow-paced movie, the ending came across to me as rather abrupt and left a lot hanging. After everything that went on, what actually happened to Mike? Perhaps the ending could have been a little bit tighter and been a better example of closure. All things considered, though, this is a very good movie, and a movie that's quite different from the blockbusters that get all the attention. (7/10)
8 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Don't waste your time
creepergirl-3832530 January 2018
The only reason I gave this a 3 star is because of the acting, the story itself is a 1 star or less because its bland and builds very slowly. His wife starts problems for no reason but the neighbor girl script is pretty decent because people in abusive relationships are usually finding excuses to be with them or thinking they'll change. So take my word and ignore this title even if you're a fan of the actors. They all do a great job but it's ruined by the story.
35 out of 54 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Boring, slow, uninteresting
fireflicker3827 January 2018
Aside from some decent acting, this movie was a wash. Pace was soooo slow. Plot was uninteresting. I kept waiting for something to happen. I should have turned it off then, but I watched til the end and wasted my time. I cannot say enough how boring and just a complete waste of time this movie was.
62 out of 102 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Really???
ljo-4831822 July 2018
Warning: Spoilers
This review contains spoilers, and it's only two sentences long. Seriously. I want my hour and a half back. Killed the guy basically by accident, and he didn't even sleep with her!!???!! Just. So. Terrible. I'd give it negative stars if I could.
27 out of 43 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
So slow it does not even merit a 30 minute episode
omendata28 January 2018
Acting was ok.

For some reason Fichtner looked like he was playing someone with autism or Dustin Hoffman in "The Lettuce" lol

Produced by William Fichtner as well - poor sod what a waste of money..all of the 50 cents and a bag of monkey nuts it must have cost!

Gosh this was a boring film and the denouement was not actually very interesting either! The accompanying funeral dirge of the awful sound of a Cello was most discordant and depressing as was the movie!

THIS IS NOT A THRILLER IN ANY WAY IT IS A DRAMA!!!

I guess the moral of the tale is just to keep yourself to yourself and avoid your neighbours - probably very good advice these days but could have been done in a 15 minute short!

Best thing about the movie is the music at the end credits!
41 out of 71 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
no good deed goes unpunished
tomsawyer-018581 February 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Presented as a thriller, I was expecting some twisted role changing, and that kept me thinking during the entire movie. Who is framing him ...?

The neighbour is a good guy, with no bad intentions. Helpful, calm, social, caring a bit too introverted, his way of stiff movements is awkward, like there is something wrong captured in his mind. But from the outside, nothing is wrong.

Until that freshly married naive young woman starts sympathizing with him. You can feel the awkwardness grow inside him. Every little attention from the young woman, made without any bad intention, every little tap on his shoulder strikes him inside with lightning.

His wife feels the transformation, as he becomes more absent-minded, fixed to that girl. It's a great slow quiet crescendo scripted, filmed and acted brilliantly.

His wife starts to separate, which increases his silent paranoia, up to his final personal disaster.

As many I got cheated. It's not a thriller, no one is planning any conspiracy. Everything is realistic, no thriller, just an individual drama.

You have been warned.
10 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
I Honestly Don't Understand How Movies this Bad Get Made
leftbanker-129 January 2018
This film cost at least a few million dollars. It's not like it was a high school film project, so people had to discuss this in some sort of serious manner. You have to wonder on the scripts Hollywood passes on if something this horrible is green-lighted.

There is so little to this film that it doesn't even merit a review. It would have made a mediocre 30 minute TV episode; as a feature it is a complete disaster.
37 out of 66 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A Very Different Fitchner than we have seen before
skip-9875629 January 2018
I really enjoyed this! I love fitchner in the roles he has played in the past and to see him as a meek, introverted,weak minded individual was freakin bizzare but goes to show his range and his willingness to be seen in this light... cool story! sad story... well acted
9 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Fitchner at his best. Storyline, not so much.
npjy8316 August 2019
If you like Rear Window, Lakeview Terrace, Disturbia, The Intruder, and other movies which involve spying on neighbours, then you 'MAY' enjoy this.

The acting by William Fichtner is top class, he plays the pre-occupied mind, infactuating, midlife crises, creepy stalker neighbor to a TEE. He plays this character very well.

He has a crush on the much younger neighbor who plays him along and leads him down the garden path. His wife has lost interest in him sexually and his mind begins to wander across to his neighbor. What turns out to be a crush on his neighbor, ends up as a genuine care for her as he is concerned about the neighbors drunk bad tempered husband, who he holds no disregard towards.

It's not the usual thriller/suspension type movie, more of a drama/intense film. If you like the above mentioned movies, chances are you will enjoy this one, perhaps even as a one off watch. If you do not enjoy the movies mentioned above, chances are you will not enjoy this movie. Five stars for the great acting, storyline not great and slow at times.

The storyline does have a serious dive in it, however. William Fitchners character does have a mid life crisis, and rather than talk it over with him, his wife (who is played by the teenager Tia, in Uncle Buck) throws him out with no questions asked, and he more or less accepts. I don't buy that reasoning.

If you are a Fitchner fan, then watch it for him. 5 / 10 for me, 50/50 chance you'll like it yourself.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Loved this! Not what I was expecting..
lk-1738727 January 2018
This is the best acting performance I've ever seen William Fichtner do. And let me say first, this film is not what I was expecting- but I loved it. It's marketed as a thriller, but it's definitely more of a slow burn drama about a man who is unhappy with his life and becomes infatuated/obsessed with his young female neighbor who has her own problems. Never seen this actress before but wow, she's incredible. And somehow Michael Rosenbaum's character is both vile and charming simultaneously. Highly recommend watching this as a fantastic piece of film, acting, characters, and storyline. Just don't go in thinking it's some crazy thriller movie.
74 out of 101 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Well a short movie bt better made like a short film
nallaiah28 May 2020
Acting was good and the story reveals about a old man and hia family and his mew neighbour accompanying next door..no other interesting facts other than these...intense acting can b seen from hero..climax was little confusing..rest it is a average movie
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
What is new?!
AhmedMw27 January 2019
Warning: Spoilers
When u watch this movie u feel like u watched it million time before.

The only good thing about this movie is William Fichtner acting

the movie could have been better if they add some plot twist or something to the original story .
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Dumb!!!!!
crosbyp120038 April 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Waste of my time. This should not be a thriller. Slow and then you end it with no resolution. He's shown with a pretty decent relationship with his wife but she wants him out why? I thought he was autistic. Look at something else.
24 out of 43 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed