I believe she was completely wrong on her decision because she spent entirely too much time on the fact he had a ONE NIGHT STAND. What did that have to do with the case. Her decision was based solely on that one thing. If the woman entered his name on the paperwork in order to enter the contest then the prize winnings should be split. They lived together as a couple. I am sure if the sexes were reversed, the man would have to split the winning as well as everything else. I would like to know why it was so important to spend more time on the fact that he cheated then the rest of the case. The decision was based on the fact that a woman judge heard the word cheating and that was it, her mind was made up. I will never watch her show again and will discourage others not to watch.