"The Madame Blanc Mysteries" Christmas Special (TV Episode 2022) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Undemanding
keysam-026102 January 2023
Warning: Spoilers
This show is the very essence of undemanding, or maybe cosy. I do enjoy it but it's just a bit sugary, so you feel rather as though you've seen off a few cream cakes or chocs by the end.

As with most crime dramas of the sort, everything really hinges on the "detective" - in this case Jean White - working it all out before the *trained police officers*. Treating the police like dimwits wasn't actually all that acceptable back in the "Golden Age" of crime when Christie & co were writing (& indeed some of those authors did have police detectives who aren't idiots - Ngaio Marsh for example) but it's even less realistic nowadays. Much of season 1 of Mme Blanc featured mysteries Jean was involved in due to it being her own life that was affected, or because Caron enlisted her help due to her knowledge of antiques. It was much easier to suspend disbelief.

In this instance, the prickly Insp Gaultier would almost certainly warn Jean off far more harshly than she does here, and I was also expecting her to turn up to chuck Jean out of Caron's house. You can't swan around in a crime scene even if the home owner gives you the key!

But never mind - it all allows Jean to solve the mystery in double quick time, so that she can explain to Gaultier (& us) who did it and why. Plus she finds a business opportunity for the future, which presumably will provide at least some of the plots in S2.

I do hope the Tony Robinson character will be back so that he can get a PROPER comeuppance for his pilfering. It was all well and good him returning the music box, but it was only one of the several things he had stolen and there really ought to be consequences.

I liked the increase in the spoken French but as someone else says, the subtitles need attention as they are virtually unreadable in some instances. They need a grey background so the text is properly visible.

I have to be honest the choral bit at the end didn't impress. It was a bit too underpowered. Allowing the two rich characters to "join in" was crass.

I will certainly watch the new series of Madam Blanc, but it's 100% forgettable and undemanding "comfort" TV.

.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Best episode yet
SunnyDaise22 December 2022
This is a really great continuation of the series - it is back to the quality of the first three episode, with the addition of a beautiful festive feel and some Tony Robinson fun! There are so many gorgeous moments, especially in the last few scenes with the Secret Santa and beautiful choir singing. There's also more French spoken - subtitles need to be clearer though! I was in two minds whether to continue watching after the later episodes of Season One, but this has got me hooked again. Really looking forward to the new run and am glad it follows shortly. Great job Sally and everyone - see you soon!
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Christmas Special
Prismark1023 December 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Chief of police Andre Caron does not seem to have cordial relationship with his wife. After some non stop nagging he goes out for a walk.

When he returns he discovers that his wife was brutally murdered. Caron is left shell-shocked and forgot his basic police training.

Jean White finds Caron covered in blood and his prints on the knife.

The investigator, Inspector Gauthier arrests Caron and she holds a grudge against him. With such an open and shut case. It is up to Jean to clear the police chief's name.

She finds a lead with an art gallery and an up and coming artist whose face keeps showing up.

A breezy mystery with roots to money laundering. It was a bit much that Jean White needs to explain the plot to Inspector Gauthier.

Although it was nice to see Tony Robinson as Dom's Uncle Patrick, I was not riveted by the sub plot.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed