User Reviews

It was a closer adaptation than the official show. Though it cut a lot in order to produce an entire arch in one sitting. Despite all the cuts and the changes made, the lines were almost verbatim from the comic. So high points there. Though there were aspects which made it seem like a college film, and the first scene with the "other Beth" felt rushed and unrealistic. In the comic it took reasoning and coaxing to get Yorick to be unfaithful, so the fact he was so willing to be with the other Beth conflicted with his personality in the comic. Though this abnormality was most likely formed because they melded together his meeting with Beth at the church and his meeting with Sonia in Marrisville in order to form the arch required for what turned into an amusing ending. A few minor changes might have corrected it. While it went off the rails, I respect that it seemed to stick to them as much as possible. I imagine if the creators of this film and the creators of the other fan made Y: The last man I've seen got together, they might create a spectacular recreation... In the end it gave me hope that a better recreation, than the 2021 series, might exist. Thank you.