"Five Days at Memorial" The Reckoning (TV Episode 2022) Poster

(TV Mini Series)

(2022)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Decent ending, despite too much focus and singular scrutiny on Anna Pou
michiganave_p17 September 2022
Warning: Spoilers
I was a little surprised John Ridley focused on Dr. Pou as much as he did in this final episode. Granted, she deserves the scrutiny, as I've been in the camp of "neutral player in a bad game" where Tenent shouldn't have put her in a situation where she had unchecked authority and was sole decision maker. But what was surprising was not that she got off (we already knew that per Fink's book), but the focus of the last scene of the series where Dr. Horace Baltz/Robert Pine and basically confronts her disaster narrative at the dinner seminar.

That scene is pretty much real-life Dr. Pou in a nutshell since she was cleared by the grand jury until now, where she's made a career of speaking at road shows blaming everyone but herself, all while omitting anything she actually did (the injecting part) at Memorial that was questionable.

That is a real-life scene, or where Dr. Pou is receiving speaking fees for being the "hero" of Memorial Hospital, but in reality is rallying the NOLA medical community (mostly MD's and nurses) and pushing for civil protections against malpractice lawsuits when they make grave mistakes during natural disasters.

She didn't do a thing to make sure a situation like this won't happen again to her patients and staff (like coming up with disaster triage best practices including from flooding) but will do everything possible to CYA.

I was mixed on the updates at the end Ridley provided as they were truth telling, sans Tenet's civil liability, with regards to Pou going back into the backwater Louisiana medical community having faced no real consequences except a civil settlement. But there was one big thing he did not mention: These were the Diane Robichaux and Butch Schafer investigative files being sealed despite being a public investigation. Want to know who is fighting in court currently to keep these 50,000 pages of records sealed?

Dr. Pou, that's who. This is the one part Ridley covered well (the pages upon pages of findings) but never followed up with how those records are never seeing the light of day, mostly because it would be bad for Pou.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The show needs a second season, and heartstrings are broken
moviesfilmsreviewsinc23 September 2022
Episode 8 of Five Days at Memorial starts this finale with Dr Horace's account of what happened on that fifth day inside Memorial. After leaving the hospital, he felt guilty about not staying and how the doctors became blind to their main ethos - "do no harm." At Baton Rouge, 11 months after Hurricane Katrina, the Attorney General gives a press conference, confirming that Anna Pou and two other nurses - Cheri Landry and Lori Budo - have been arrested on charges of murdering those patients. Poring over the details of each patient who was injected, Butcher and his team come to the same conclusion for all patients - homicide. Assistant District Attorney Michael Morales shows up and takes charge as the lead prosecutor of the case. Unfortunately, he's decided to go against the evidence Butcher and Virginia have gathered and chooses to go a different route with his argument. So Five Days at Memorial ends with a pretty average final episode, one that gets caught up in the aftermath events for Hurricane Katrina and a somewhat muddied focus on who the protagonist is in this. Are we supposed to be rooting for Anna or Butcher? Either way, the events leading to Anna and the other doctors not being arrested for what happened to those patients is likely to spurn mixed reactions and I'm certainly not about to dive down that rabbit hole here!

After how good the opening set of episodes have been for this show, it's a little disappointing to see the series take its foot off the gas for these final few chapters. We also don't really see much of what happened to Susan and Diane either, with no focus on the former reuniting with her mother. That's a bit disappointing and it would have really helped give this some much-needed closure to help showcase what everyone has been up to since Katrina. Assistant District Attorney Michael Morales shows up and takes charge as the lead prosecutor of the case. Unfortunately, he's decided to go against the evidence Butcher and Virginia have gathered and chooses to go a different route with his argument. A month passes and Morales has drafted a letter from Eddie Jordan to the attorney general saying they don't need Butcher and Virginia working on this case anymore. They want a summary of the 50,000 pages of work that they've spent so long to gain instead. However, the media side of things is still working in their favour. In fact, the heat gets so overwhelming that Anna's defence lawyer suggests she go on 60 Minutes and tell her side of the story. She comes across really well, although some of what she says is pretty subjective, especially as she claims she doesn't believe in euthanasia... but does believe in "comfort care." Virginia refuses to take this lying down and pores over the toxicology reports again with irrefutable evidence. The thing is, public opinion is what swings things here and it's something Butcher is quick to point out to his co-worker. And speaking of opinion, Frank (the coroner from last episode) actually thanks Anna for everything she's done. Even worse, he comes out and publicly claims there's no evidence... even though there clearly was. Virginia is livid and after questioning Frank to his face, starts to lose faith in the system. In fact, she's going to quit.
2 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed