Retornos (2010) Poster

(2010)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Returns
jotix10010 July 2012
Warning: Spoilers
The story begins with an automobile accident. Alvaro, a Spaniard living in Switzerland, is called to his father death bed. As he arrives, the funeral procession is about to start. Alvaro, being away now for about ten years is not a welcome presence in his father's home. His former wife, Elisa is now married to the owner of the local sex club and his own daughter, Mar, seems at odds with a father she hardly knew.

In flashbacks we get to know a little bit of the past. Alvaro's brother, Xose, had to deal with the tragedy of having been cuckolded by Alvaro, who fleeing from the small with Carmen, his sister-in-law, suffers the accident we saw at the start of the story. He caused the death of Carmen and Xose cannot forgive him. Elisa has her own reasons for hating Alvaro, the man who abandoned her and Mar.

As Alvaro is going back to Switzerland, he hits a woman on the road. The woman turns out to be Lidia, a prostitute Alvaro met. Alvaro maintains Lidia was dead when he hit her, but he becomes the primary suspect. Mar comes to his help in trying to retrace Lidia's last moments in the small community and her unexpected death. It appears Lidia knew a horrible secret about herself and took it to her grave.

A somewhat interesting Spanish drama set in Galicia, in Northern Spain. Directed by Luis Aviles, whose first full length feature this is. The screenplay was a collaboration among the director, and Alvaro Hernandez and David Perez Iglesias. The rain soaked locale plays well as a background to all the emotions running underneath the story. It is a family conflict, with shades of mystery since the people that stayed behind never came clean to their own sins. Alvaro is not welcome to come and dig on wounds that are now partly forgotten because no one wants to own to the actions of the past. The tense atmosphere in Galicia, where passions and hatreds run side by side is done without the extreme pathos in other Spanish films set in the region.

Xavier Estevez, who has worked mainly on Spanish television, is a surprise as Alvaro. The actor shows he has what it takes to carry a movie on his shoulders, as he demonstrates here. He cast a virile figure as well as an affinity toward the material. Xose Manuel Oliveira Pico makes an outstanding contribution as Xose, the brother betrayed by Alvaro. Manuela Velles plays Mar, the confused young woman whose father left her behind when he left with Xose's wife, leaving her behind.
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Beautifully Stupid
samkan13 March 2014
Warning: Spoilers
The setting is beautiful. The initial plot set-up is loaded with potential. Camera work and, except for the lead's perpetual deadpan, acting is adequate. But the major plot devises are simply too incredulous to overcome. We never learn precisely why a person, presumably overcome with the exposure of his eloping with his sister-in-law, drives off a bridge he's negotiated his whole life. Apparently neither the extended family nor the local community think it all inappropriate that their chief source of revenue is a whore house. Pivoting clues miraculously turn up or spill out unsolicited from blabbering mouths. All such commotion tied around an inner narrative of a dead-beat dad reuniting with his saint-like daughter. So ridiculous and unabsorbing is this film I managed to turn it off with just 13 minutes to go before finishing it this morning for the privilege of writing this COMMENT. Remember, just because it's foreign doesn't mean it cannot be a mess.
1 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed