"Fringe" The Same Old Story (TV Episode 2008) Poster

(TV Series)

(2008)

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Great.
habrapoesia19 September 2008
This episode demonstrates that the show operates beyond a monster-of-the-week level. While that element exists, the story presented this hour is fully tied to the story of the first episode. This is true not only in the sense that the situation presented is part of The Pattern; in fact, the actual circumstances tie to the histories of the characters. We don't feel as though we've entered a world relevant only to this hour of television.

The plot being investigated is interesting, and while some dialogue is a bit wooden, I was overall very engaged. The narrative doesn't dwell too long on Olivia's angst over John, but her feelings are instead connected both to her investigation of the case and to the nature and goals of her character; they mesh perfectly with all facets of her search for truth, a concept highlighted by an exciting dialogue between Olivia and Ms. Sharp.

Once again, the series' weakest point is its dialogue. But the way the story is put together--and the elements that comprise that story--are very strong.
19 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Accelerated Growth
claudio_carvalho6 July 2016
After having sex in a motel, a woman called Loraine Daisy feels pain in the stomach and her partner drives her to the hospital. The medical team finds she is pregnant and she gives birth to a child that moments later grows old and dies. Olivia and Peter investigate the case and Dr. Bishop recalls an experiment he carried out to develop a young army with his colleague Dr. Claus Penrose. Olivia finds cases of women with the pituitary gland removed and she recalls an unsolved case that she worked in the FBI many years ago. Could the cases be connected?

"The Same Old Story" is another mysterious and engaging episode of "Fringe". The plot about an accelerated growth has an excellent screenplay that increases tension until the great resolution. My vote is eight.

Title (Brazil): "The Same Old Story"
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
It's a Freak Baby!
injury-6544715 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
The opener to this episode is great. It's very disturbing and horrific. The ultimate reveal of what was inside her is totally nuts! You can't help but watch on to find the answers.

I can totally see this story working in the X-Files. Growing soldiers using pituitary gland technology.

I had a lot more fun watching this episode than I did watching the pilot. The characters are coming into their own, especially the dynamic between the Bishop father and son. I love how they provide natural comic relief. I'm loving Joshua Jackson in this role; he's adorable.

I love how we are already getting more answers about the Pattern and starting to explore mysteries that were raised in the pilot episode. I was worried things might be left hanging for too long.

Strikes a great tone between sci fi, horror, mystery, comedy and crime drama. Really fun watch.

I'm even more excited now to see where this goes. Also, the hint about Peter Bishop's birth that we are given is tantalising!
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Same Old FRINGE
XweAponX8 February 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Revisiting these Season 1 eps has solidified my love and support for the show. And this 2nd Episode was a great start. We are handed a bucket of conundrums in the Pilot, this ep get right into the grisly meat of what makes Fringe a great show.

It is as if, this team of people has been working together for years, the chemistry is that good. The cast of Fringe is probably the best ensemble ever assembled for network TV. But in reality this is NOT Network TV: This is Feature Quality Filmaking at it best. Each camera move, each gag, has been carefully thought out with love by a production team of basically young people, a production team who understands not only how to make good product, they also understand things like the angst of teenagers, the lure of sexual drive, the consequences of bad decisions and the need for self-protection.

It's all personifies here, in the character "Christopher" played by Derek Cecil, and his "father" Dr. Claus Penrose (Mark Blum). And as someone else stated, this is a level beyond the "Monster of the Week" kinds of shows that have been around lately - These two characters are intrinsically connected to Walter and his work.

This episode defines "The Pattern" and gives us a look forward into how these things are all interconnected. The more Walter works on these cases, the more he realises that HE is the cause of them. This is explored through the entire series, but it is put into place here, in this 1st "Procedural" episode.

Watching these 1st-Season Eps and comparing them to S4, there is NO drop in quality - The show is still made using the same care that was used in making these eps.
16 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Don't shag a stranger...
Chalice_Of_Evil2 October 2009
Warning: Spoilers
You'll end up with a magic man baby bursting your nethers to bits.

While not quite as grisly as the series premiere, this episode's opener was still pretty freaky. If the last episode played on fears of flying, this one tackles fears of pregnancy gone wrong (and how!). We begin with a young woman (in her underwear), lying on the bed of some seedy motel, showing off her perfectly flat stomach, and asking the dude she's with whether he brought her a mushroom pizza. Sadly, though, Loraine Daisy (as she informs us her mother so cruelly named her) never gets her mushroom pizza. Instead, she gets a belly full of magic old man baby. She's certainly one hell of a screamer (but, hey, wouldn't you be too, if you had something growing inside of you at an accelerated rate?). The dude drives her to the hospital...then promptly dumps her ass out on the snow, leaving her alone and driving off. Cut to her declaring that she's "not pregnant" to the doctors (meanwhile, her distended belly begs to differ). After some cringe-worthy ripping noises, she flat-lines and the doctors cut open her stomach...just in time for something gruesome to emerge, making horrible moaning/groaning sounds, which causes interns and nurses alike to throw up/scream their heads off. Then comes the tinkly, effectively eerie Fringe theme music - which is just as unsettling as it was in the premiere.

Then we get an exposition-heavy scene with Broyles, Nina Sharp and various other shady types. They basically just tell us stuff we already knew about Walter, Peter and Olivia. Obviously this scene was designed to catch up those who missed the 'Pilot'. When Broyles brought up the subject of his old team (which this new team is now replacing), I couldn't help but be reminded of that scene in the first Futurama episode, where Professor Farnsworth is asked what happened to his old crew, and he says, "Oh, those poor sons of-- But that's not important. The important thing is I need a new crew. Anyone interested?" and then proceeds to tip out the career chips of his previous crew from an envelope labeled 'Contents of Space Wasp's Stomach'. Why do I get the feeling it's a similar case with Broyles' last team?

Moving things along, Broyles awakes Olivia (except she's already awake, wearing glasses and going over old case files), who wakes up Peter (who *was* actually sleeping), who then finds Walter in his closet. He tells his son that he's unable to get to sleep without being sung 'Row, Row, Row Your Boat' (which another inmate used to do back when Walter was in the mental institution). Walter makes a rather amusing/memorable first impression on Broyles, when he's sitting in the car, fiddling with the seat warmer, and informs him, "I've never seen a feature like this before. It warms your ass! It's wonderful!". We're then treated to the rather nasty visual of a bloodied magic old man baby (as Peter refers to it as). It becomes clear that this is a case of rapid aging.

After some poking around the seedy motel, Olivia quickly makes the connection between what's currently going on and an old case she and John Scott investigated. The killer removed the pituitary gland from his victims (Olivia gives us a rather nasty visual description of the killer making incisions along the gums of his victims and pulling their mouths open up to their eyes, going in through the nasal cavities and removing a piece of their brains). This also happens to be the MO of the current killer, who they discover the identity of after some investigating. They're not in time to save another woman, though (who he takes back to his abandoned industrial building, telling her to look at a bridge and injecting her with muscle relaxant when she's distracted. Apparently, he was *really* into that bridge). It is soon discovered the killer needs pituitary glands to keep from aging (chalk up another one to those crazy experiments Walter did back in the day!), and that the woman he impregnated with a rapidly-aging baby was an accident.

Luckily, Walter knows of a way to see the last image the victim saw before she was killed - which will help them find the killer. Of course, to do this, they need a piece of equipment from Massive Dynamic. Whilst waiting for Nina Sharp, Olivia talks to Broyles. He asks her a personal question about whether she was safe the last time she was intimate with John, then says, "You weren't, were you?" and suddenly Olivia's screaming, her stomach bulging outward, with something writhing around inside. Thankfully, it's nothing but an unnerving dream sequence (effectively shot, with changing lights in the background, all very moody and off-putting).

After extracting the last image the previous victim saw (of the bridge) - by literally pulling out her eyeball from its socket - they manage to hunt down the killer (who doesn't get to finish off his latest victim). He winds up aging into a grandpa and dies, while Peter magically brings back the killer's latest victim (from flat-lining) with a makeshift defibrillator.

While the second episode wasn't as great as the first (but then, when are they ever?), it was still quite good. It had its fair share of creepy moments, and some intriguing mysteries (such as "the truth about Peter's medical history", which Walter mentions to Olivia, then that final strange image of three bodies lined up like they're seemingly part of some experiment. What are these images supposed to be of and where exactly are they coming from? Is Walter dreaming them as Peter attempts to lull him to sleep by singing 'Row, Row, Row Your Boat'? Guess we'll find out).
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Intriguing and intense episode.
Darwinskid16 September 2008
Warning: Spoilers
After a young woman becomes mysteriously pregnant she is quickly dropped off to a hospital where she delivers an infant whose above the normal baby, especially for the doctors delivering. In an instant, all heck breaks loose and immediately officials are on it. Newly recruited Olivia Dunham, Peter Bishop, and Dr. Bishop investigate the hospital only to find an old lifeless corpse. This corpse, is only a few hours old. That WAS the baby delivered. Following the path of the mothers' night Olivia and Peter discover that the mother, before she went into labor and passed away, was with a man( the same man who dropped her off, and high tailed it) the same man who Olivia and her late boyfriend Scott had been tracking down years ago but never found him. This killer has only been known to have young females as his victims, why? They don't know. Soon, the serial killer strikes again and another life is lost. The new body is fund and with some new old tricks up his sleeves Dr. Bishop does an experiment which will help them see the victim's past prior to her death.Thsi helps them discover the setting of her death. But there is more to this killer, this killer often injects something into his victims and once they are frozen he takes something from their jaw area, but why? To continue living as a young man for it is revealed that he was an experiment apart of a program which Dr. Bishop had worked on which was to make the perfect soldier and for them to stay young at all times, this also explains why the over-aged baby came to be. Can Olivia and Peter stop him? Who knows, but in the meantime Nina Sharp of Massive Dynamic takes interest in Olivia, after Olivia asks for some help out of Nina of course.

I really enjoyed this episode, probably more than the pilot. It had some pretty intense and graphic moments to it and at the same time it had a nice balance with it's humor and drama( A very good balance I'd might add). This episode also had more character beats, which made the characters a little more interesting and it also explored a bit more into the father-son relationship between Walter and Peter. This episode also had better direction and acting than the pilot delivered, the chemistry between the actors was much more costumed and Anna Torv did a better job here than before. I liked how director Paul A. Edwards handled things a bit more than Alex Graves did with the pilot episode. Can't wait to see Edwards next episode.

Overall, this was a pretty good episode, it had a nice twist at the end to, but I'm not spoiling that one.

9/10.

Can't wait till next week's episode...
6 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
There are places in this world where one can pick up a girl by merely making eye contact w/said girl and smirking
citizenchris22 September 2008
Fringe: se1 ep2 The Same Old Story

There are places in this world where one can pick up a girl by merely making eye contact w/said girl and smirking...don't believe me just watch this episode of Fringe. In any case this episode is riddled with far too much redundant expositionary dialog that seems to exist only for those who did not see the pilot. What we're left with beyond that is a typical serial killer plot w/a "fringe twist". I fear that this could end up being the formula this series will adhere to. Of note in this episode is the wonderful score and (as in the last episode) Anna Torv's performance. Mark Blum made a nice supporting guest appearance as well.
10 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Out of Control
Hitchcoc23 October 2023
We are still in the early stages of a science fiction crime drama where we are asked to accept some really wild "truths" in order to enjoy the plot. For now I am hooked because through the first two episodes things are tight and have a logical truth within its boundaries. The problem is going to be sustainability. Can this stretch of medical and scientific believability keep moving forward. That said, I'm willing to take the ride to see. Once again we have those who have dabbled in the world of sustaining youth, or returning the old to the young. A woman is assaulted during a tryst, becomes pregnant immediately, and when, one her deathbed, a baby is born, the thing ages a hundred years in a few minutes.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Why is this rated so highly?
mdking-492445 January 2023
Having watched the pilot the night before and been non plus about the whole thing I thought I'd try episode 2 to see if it could generate a spark of interest, and quite honestly I won't be going beyond that. What an utterly preposterous plot. I'm totally shocked at all the good reviews for this garbage. The guy who plays Walter is so bad, how on earth did he get the part? Talk about putting you to sleep with his monotone voice. And the two other older characters are almost as bad. The FBI boss couldn't act his way out of a paper bag and the obvious corporate "bad guy" has no redeeming features so far. All three of them were grating on me by the time the episode was half way in. The only reason this episode doesn't get 1 star is because I liked the other two lead actors, but that's about the only positive in an otherwise terrible show!
0 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed