Magical Christmas Shoes (TV Movie 2019) Poster

(2019 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
11 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
A better movie than most of its kind
doctorsmoothlove4 December 2019
Warning: Spoilers
"The Magical Christmas Shoes" is the second film I can think of specifically about Christmas and shoes. The first is last year's "A Shoe Addict's Christmas," which I haven't seen yet. This film amazingly incorporates shoes into its plot in a meaningful way. Viewers might learn something about how the Low Countries celebrate christmas.

Erin Karpluk plays Noelle, an accountant who receives a shoe full of Christmas gifts each year from her grandmother who immigrated to the United States from Belgium. In Belgium, a folkloric character is said to fill shoes with candy for children each year.

Noelle discovers that a local candy store is about to go out of business. She goes inside and uses her latent artistic talent to put out beautiful Christmas display. Of course the sales skyrocket. People just love Christmas, don't they?

The store's proprietor is a troubled man by the John Reid (Damon Runyan). He runs the store on behalf of his father who founded the company. John longs for a career in the arts and believes he is ill suited to be a businessman. He and Noelle fall in love perhaps based upon their mutual suppression of their true desires.

The actors get along well together. I wouldn't say they have romantic chemistry as much as they just get along as friends. That's ok. The film isn't really about a romance as much as the script believes it is. The main theme is having the courage to do something you really love. I felt like the romance was added as a genre requirement for a made-for-tv film.

I haven't seen Mr. Runyan in many films. I felt he was more emotive here than in "Christmas Festival of Ice" where he was a mayonnaise bore. Here he is steadfast and warm.

"The Magical Christmas Shoes" is better than it has any right to be. It feels as if the screenplay was given real thought and effort. It's competently acted. Add it to your marathon.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Erica, Its Not Really About the Shoes
story_by_corey4 December 2019
Starts out as a formula Lifetime Christmas movie and then through the magic of the shoes slowly evolves into an introspective exploration of how the shoes made her the person she is today. If this story sounds familiar, its because it is. The second half of the movie feels like a lost episode of Being Erica with the shoes serving the role of Dr. Tom and supporting actors sounding remarkably like Erica's friends. Being Erica fans craving for one more episode will enjoy this Christmas knockoff. For those who didn't see the show, its something a bit different from the formula Lifetime Christmas movie to fill an evening.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Adorable, offbeat charming movie.
Racingphan22 November 2020
Warning: Spoilers
I love how Lifetime produces Christmas movies that don't adhere to a strict formula..... like Hallmark does. This delightful movie features a fun and quirky performance by Erin Karplunk. Although not the traditional tv movie beauty, she is an amazingly cute and effervescent presence.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
nice
Kirpianuscus7 December 2019
Like many Christmas films, just nice. The axis - a seductive idea about shoes and about choices. Romance, options, friendship and decent performances. Nothing original or spectacular but smart manner to use pieces of the genre for a not so bad film about signs, grandmother, mistakes and the fair to yourself way.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Suck my candy cane!
adamjohns-4257524 November 2020
It's a charming story, a cute twist on the same old boy meets girl.

Are the shoes really magic though? Or are they more of a curse? I need some if they can help. I'm actually quite good in heels and I particularly liked the purple knee highs.

The film is full of happy festive activities and you can see the romance blossoming quite happily.

Damon Runyon is quite appealing and easy on the eye too.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Did not disappoint to disappoint me.
BaileySEA2 November 2020
The usual Lifetime Christmas movie (bad script, bad acting) with an unknown Canadian actress Erin Karpluk, an annoying actress who talks too fast. Christmas shoes, really? And her window displays for the Candy store were awful. I wish Lifetime and Hallmark would stop making these awful movies.
2 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Some Dutch traditions
Jackbv12327 November 2019
My son's family just came home from two plus years in Belgium which still has a lot of Dutch tradition, so some of the things in this movie were familiar like candy in the shoes. The Dutch traditions gave this movie a slightly different flavor from so many of the Christmas romance movies around. The premise of the story was similar to those of many of these movies, but at the same time it felt a little different. Certainly, the relationship of the lead male, John, with his father and how that progressed through the story is a very well used trope. The themes of be-yourself, take-risks, and do-what-makes-you-happy are in many Christmas movies. While save-the-store is well used, this had a slightly different take on it. The meddling arrival of the hated ex is another well used trope.

John and Noelle clicked from the beginning. I find I like this kind of movie when the leads have plenty of screen time for relationship building and that was the case here and I did enjoy it.

The conflict involved a couple of other well used tropes, but I didn't see it coming, so I give points for that.
12 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Good watch
t-mccheyne14 December 2019
Loved this one. Good connection between couple. Held my attention. Nice story, a little different at last.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Shoe magic
TheLittleSongbird20 October 2020
Despite it not being one of the most inspired of titles, the premise did sound quite charming. Also saw 'Magical Christmas Shoes' for two other reasons. One was my love of Christmas. Two was that it was part of my Lifetime (and Hallmark) Christmas film completest quest, despite their 2019 output being such a mixed batch with some good, some mediocre at best and some somewhere between average and decent. A better standard than Hallmark's 2019 output.

'Magical Christmas Shoes' to me was one of the good ones. Was a bit unsure about it at the start, not uncommon with Lifetime Christmas films in the better faring category, but once the film started to warm up and find its footing it got a lot better. From personal view, 'Magical Christmas Shoes' when seeing it some months back was among the better 2019 Lifetime Christmas films quite easily, better than most of their films this year and certainly better than much of Hallmark's 2019 Christmas output.

The film does start off on the slow and formulaic side.

Some of the dialogue is also pretty bad early on too, sounding a little stilted and corny.

However, as said, once it got going (and it did so not too far in) 'Magical Christmas Shoes' got a lot better. Visually, it looks good in particularly the scenery which is nicely complemented by the photography. The music is pleasant and not intrusive, not always the case with Lifetime (even more Hallmark) films. The script is far from perfect, but is sweet and raised a number of smiles while not being too heavy on the sentiment. The story isn't perfect to begin with, but is mostly very charming and warm-hearted with an authentic atmosphere.

While the characters are familiar in type, my way of trying and failing to avoid the word cliched, they to me had personality and ones that didn't come over as stale or annoying. The central relationship didn't feel rushed, so less of a chance of out of the blue motivations, or take too long to unfold, and was amiable. Erin Karpluk and Damon Runyan are fine in the lead roles and well supported by everyone else.

Overall, well done and charming. 8/10
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Great Lifetime Christmas Movie
aliyahrocks28 November 2019
This film was better than some of the Hallmark Holiday movies that been released this year. The leads have great chemistry and the plot was interesting and kept me engaged from start to finish. It was great to see Erin Karpluk back on my screen as I remembered her from "Being Erica" Definitely a movie to watch again next year.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
TYPICAL XMAS MOVIE
valica-338497 November 2022
What gets me & know a movie, why wearing open toe shoes & no stocking? It's winter snow on ground. I thought was getting little girl skates.

When does she sleep, decorate all night, thn goes to work, which is like right next door. They're neighbors but never seem run into each other outside house.

These reviews really kill me with having to be 600 characters. There really isn't that much to say. I just wanted to leave a comment and keep it moving. Okay 142 still Okay, I'm from Boston, Patriots, and been living in Georgia for about 20 years, haven't been back except maybe twice, but will always be home to me. Will NOT claim GA.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed