- Show Offs ThemeWritten by Casey Jost
- The Show Offs Christmas Show
- Will and Matt's Christmas SongPerformed by Matt Cook, Will Forte
- Wash Your HandsPerformed by Hailey Smith, Lisa Valentine Clark, Kendra Lowe, Brady Bills, Francisco Ojeda, Bart Olson
- The Candy Cane ShufflePerformed by Matt Cook, Will Forte, Kendra Lowe, Brady Bills, Francisco Ojeda, Bart Olson, Trenton James
- Snuggles in the Big Apple
- Christmas in New York
- Rickter and ReboosePerformed by Maclain Nelson, Will Forte, Kendra Lowe, Brady Bills, Francisco Ojeda, Bart Olson, Candido
- Oh Christmas TreePerformed by Matt Cook, Hailey Smith, Kendra Lowe, Brady Bills, Francisco Ojeda, Bart Olson, Candido
- I'll Get the PresentsPerformed by Jake Van Wagoner, Tom Quinn, Kendra Lowe, Brady Bills, Francisco Ojeda, Bart Olson, Trenton James, Candido
- Christmas Beatdown
- Money Isn't EverythingPerformed by Shaun Johnson, Kelly Lohman, Brady Bills, Francisco Ojeda, Bart Olson, Trenton James, Candido, Kendra Lowe
- It's BeautifulPerformed by Matt Cook, Brady Bills, Francisco Ojeda, Bart Olson, Trenton James, Candido, Kendra Lowe
- The Mistletoe You're WearingPerformed by Jake Van Wagoner, Shaun Johnson, Brady Bills, Francisco Ojeda, Bart Olson, Trenton James, Candido, Kendra Lowe
- Snuggles in the Big Apple (Reprise)Performed by Maclain Nelson, Jake Van Wagoner, Brady Bills, Francisco Ojeda, Bart Olson, Trenton James, Candido, Kendra Lowe
- Rob Some Houses
- Pay It On Forward
Contribute to this page
Suggest an edit or add missing content