Shy neighbors Sam and Addie never dared express their potential romantic interest, until senior neighbor Mrs. Motley inspires her to make a Christmas wish 'the strongest kind, always comes true'. Surprisingly it does, but she mentioned not Sam, just 'my neighbor', and that hit a Cupid-arrow on just moved-in former high-school star jock Pete, whom she never dared ask then. Pete now is obsessed with her, sabotaging her job as event planner. She discovers Sam has similar interests, even in her, but intrusive Pete scares him off, having bluntly dumped his fir fiancee Gina, so he deems Addie a wedding wrecker, like Gina. Addie and her job buddy Drea spare no effort to recruit Sam and Gina for an effort to reunite the prospective spouses, whose impending nuptials aren't refundable, but that keeps going pear-shaped. Everyone meets professionally and seemingly clashes at the Christmas Eve party, last chance to rectify the wish.
—KGF Vissers