Much to the boys' horror, PJ bombs as a guest commentator on a local sports cable show, wondering how to break it to her gently (even initially-envious Bobby). Stephanie, brought along to watch her back, instead spends time fishing for a date to take on an Italian vacation deal. Meanwhile, Andy accepts Mike's invitation to stay over on poker nights and avoid the long, late commute home, unaware of Mike's lack of accommodations, and Kimmie ends Kenny's plans to be the father of her surrogate child.
—statmanjeff