A Bothered Conscience (2006) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
13 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
No-budget sylvan Arkansas slasher
Wuchakk22 September 2017
RELEASED TO VIDEO IN 2006 and directed/written by Dennis Smithers Jr., "A Bothered Conscience" takes place in rural Arkansas and concerns a hermit father who has "No trespassing" signs posted all around his remote property and he ruthlessly kills those who disobey. He passes this curious hobby on to his son whose conscience can't handle the mounting slayings and corresponding guilt.

My wife & I saw a 'film' by a local 'filmmaker' (terms used loosely) that cost $2000 and it was easily the worst 'movie' we've ever seen. Keep in mind that I'm a fan of micro-budget indie horror flicks and am well aware of their typical limitations (bad sound, dubious 'acting,' shaky hand-held cameras, bad editing, etc.). Despite this, they CAN be entertaining, whether the creators shoot for campy & amusing, like "Backwoods Bloodbath" (2007), or thoroughly austere, like "Butchered" (2010). Yet both of those movies cost quite a bit more than $2000, likely somewhere between $10,000-$50,000, give or take. Two great examples of micro-budget indie horror are "The Lonely Ones" (2006) and "Another Kind" (2013), but they cost $100,000 and $120,000 respectively.

"A Bothered Conscience," by contrast, only cost $2300 and so I was expecting a real dog, like that local 'movie' noted above. Thankfully, that's not the case at all as the film has a professional indie air from the get-go with a superlative score. The entire story takes place deep in the Arkansas forests and the sylvan cinematography is superb, creating an ominous vibe (comparable to the exceptional opening credits of the TV show Tales from the Darkside). While most of the acting is okay at best they're masterful performances compared to the non-acting of that other 'film.'

The first 50 minutes revolve around people getting killed in the forest whereas the last 37 minutes reveal the title of the movie. There are some effective scenes in this last act involving a currently popular 'monster' (I don't want to give it away, but it should be obvious).

It goes without saying that, to appreciate this movie, you have to enjoy the woods or woodsy outdoor photography. It successfully establishes a foreboding forestry ambiance. But the story isn't tight and it gets tedious after 30-45 minutes of redundancy. It's also marred by minor anachronisms. But things like this can be overlooked in a flick that only cost $2300. Another problem is the lack of quality females until just past the hour mark; and not enough is done with her (Tina Martin) when she shows up, but she's appealing enough for her brief period.

Despite these glaring problems, there are moments of greatness, like when a certain character in the last act gets shot and the song "When I Awake" by Hollow Earth Conspiracy is heard on the soundtrack (written by Paul Zlotucha). The sequence is almost worth the price of admission.

THE FILM RUNS 87 minutes and was shot entirely in northern Arkansas (Cushman, Horseshoe Bend, Weaver's Chapel & Spring Mill).

GRADE: C
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
A Bothered Conscience: Another Braindead studios mess
Platypuschow4 May 2018
Braindead studios aren't exactly known for good films, quite the opposite in fact. They are all hyper low budget movies and rarely have anything going for them beyond T&A.

A Bothered Conscience otherwise known as Fatalities & Phantasms doesn't even have that going for it.

It tells the story of a redneck father & son who kill trespassers on their land, who also happen to be rednecks. A combination of criminals, poachers and idiots and thus you have absolutely no protagonist in this film.

Weak death scenes, shoddy camera work and a finale that is just seven shades of awful this is one of the worst Braindead films I've seen and that is really saying something.

The Good:

Nope

The Bad:

Score is an annoying mess

Who was I supposed to be rooting for?

Fails on every front

Things I Learnt From This Movie:

All rednecks are criminals
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Really, really awful.
poolandrews15 December 2007
Warning: Spoilers
A Bothered Conscience is set in Arkansas & starts in 1974 where Keller McGavin (producer Dennis Smithers Sr.) is very possessive about his land, he hands out rather brutal justice to anyone who trespasses on his land. Jump forward '20 Years Later' over the course of which Keller has tried to teach his son Lucas (Stephen Martin) to follow him in his murderous footsteps, that's about it really...

Photographed, written, produced & directed by Dennis Smithers Jr. who is also credited with the special effects one has to say this glorified home video is awful. This is the sort of film that makes you want to give up on the medium, seriously A Bothered Conscience is maybe the worst film I've seen this year & believe me I've seen some stinkers. This is one of the most plot less, pointless, boring & downright awful films I've ever seen. Hardly anyone is even given a name, character development is absolutely zero, there's barely any dialogue in it, no-one is given any motivation for anything (one guy puts a gun in his mouth & commits suicide because his mate might have killed someone. Eh? How does that work?), there's no logic behind anything that happens (one hunter tries to shoot Keller but he has no bullets in his gun, what would a hunter being doing carrying a gun with no ammo in it? Seems a bit pointless to me) at almost 90 minutes in length it feels like it goes on forever with shots & scenes drawn out to tedious lengths & to top it all off there's one of the worst most pointless twist endings I've ever seen. This is a horrible film in every way, seriously it's one of the most plot less & amateurish films I've seen.

Director Smithers was working on a low budget but that's no excuse for making such a crap film, if I released my holiday video footage badly edited together as a film that wouldn't automatically make it any good. This is literally home video stuff, these days it seems like anyone with a camcorder think they can make a film & all us horror fans are mugs who will put up with any old crap aren't we? Not me, this is crap of the highest order & I honestly don't know how else to describe it. Although set in 1994 the cars on show are modern contemporary vehicles, during the flashback to 1974 the woman has a brand new modern camera with an LCD display & Keller mysteriously doesn't age a single day between the flashback to 1974 & the later day events of 1994. The gore consists of some fake blood, a few zombies & a headless corpse. The effects are rubbish & the blood doesn't look like blood.

With a supposed budget of about $2,300 you can see why this is such a poorly made, conceived & executed film. Shot on location in a patch of forest in Arkansas. The production values are rock bottom & generally speaking it's an eye sore. The acting is awful as well & the guy at the end looks like an idiot in that bright orange hat.

A Bothered Conscience is awful, it's one of the most plot less & pointless films I've ever seen & I urge you not to waste your time or money on it. I have nothing against low budget films or the makers but that doesn't mean they are immune to criticism.
7 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
TELL-TALE TRESPASSERS
nogodnomasters13 December 2018
Warning: Spoilers
There are a number of ways to deal with trespassers. Some work better than others. Certainly, hunting them down and killing them rates at the top of preventing the violators from doing it again.

The opening scene was an Ed Wood special. The man (Dennis Smithers Sr.) is wearing an old military style shirt with the sleeves cut out, but it has a new looking airborne patch on it. The son starts out walking on his dad's left, then he is suddenly on his right.

Trespassers are shot and stabbed. They are killed but never tortured. The movie flashes forward 20 years. The son Lucas (Stephen Martin) is grown. After 41 people have gone missing, the sheriff (MacFarland Martin) is getting a bit suspicious.

Dad eventually gets killed. Junior now must learn to kill trespassers on his own, except now he has descent into madness as he sees trespassers they have already killed. Shades of the Tell-Tale Heart! Now the problem with this madness scenario is that the dead walk like zombies and appear even when Junior can't see them.

And as for the twist at the end...my problem with the twist is that there was no clue during the film that is was going to happen. It was like putting space aliens in an Indian Jones film.

No sex or nudity.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A REAL backwoods Production with classic B-movie grace!
dbs630-697-95279425 September 2011
Warning: Spoilers
The locations and scenery in this film were perfect. The cast was very believable, especially old man "Keller!" Its the kind of movie that has its roots set in the right place. "Don't go messing around them there parts!" for sure that was the morale of the story. Very atmospheric and chilling, with some very good home grown effects and scares. The editing was good, and the use of "jittery" zombie motion was effective. I have to take my hat off to the cast and crew, it couldn't have been easy to make an indie feature in such a remote part of the country for such a low amount of money. I enjoyed this tale and would like to see a sequel in the making! (Next time get some "home grown girls next door" in their birthday suits!)
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Truly Great Indie Horror Movie!
brian-148323 May 2007
While it's not perfect (and I think Dennis will admit to that), it's far from your standard low budget horror fare. A Bothered Conscience is what indie films are all about, from the story to the acting everything here is top notch! The story involves a 'mountain man' who just wants to be left alone, it's the lengths he'll go to to be left alone that makes this different. The lead actor here is Dennis Smithers, Sr. and, for someone who's never acted before, he's the standout! I honestly believe him in this, and, frankly, he'll make you watch over your shoulder the next time you go camping in the woods!!

Also, there's a great twist ending to the movie that makes it just that much better. If you're looking for something scary, but also something different and original, then A Bothered Conscience is an A+ movie!
9 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
This one scared me ... a little ...
Jeff_Free_Jacob28 June 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Wow! ... While this movie was not great, it was very well made and I jumped a few times. Unlike the new influx of crap horror movies that rely on creepy music and and actor (or 'something') jumping in front of the camera, A BOTHERED CONSCIENCE has some truly scary moments. The good points of the film are in its direction and music score as well as very talented acting by ... um ... amateurs!! The cinematography and editing are astounding and quite realistic. A bad point would be the opening 'kill.' Little was explained why the young woman dropped her beloved camera (and, I instantly thought the camera would have 'somehow' snapped a picture of her demise). Another bad point would have to be twofold: the film opens in 1975, then proceeded "20 years later." That would make it 1995?!?!? I wanted to feel it was taking place today (like I did watching the original TCM upon its release). The 'dream' sequence was quite a surprise as it pays homage to many of my favorites: The EYE, Ju-On, Living Dead (series), and Italian Giallo. I even knew before I saw it there was going to be a 'twist at the end,' but I wasn't ready for it. The images from this film kinda freaked me out. Oh ... if you are going to see this because you want to see gore ... Forget it. There isn't a lot, and what there is is kinda dumb, and uncalled for. Watch it with the lights out, during a storm, alone, at night, in the dark ...
8 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Surprisingly good
duckman_07915 September 2020
My ratin finger was twitchin prematurely at a 2 or 3 during the first chunk of the movie, because it seemed like just another violent hillbilly flick. But, I'm glad I had patience. I was surprised when the story took a more, seemingly, supernatural turn. And I was impressed when the ending made everything come together and I was finally able to make sense of it all. I rate movies with a 5 if they were worth watching once, and a 6 if I would be up for seeing it again. This was an outstanding job for an extremely low budget film
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
There is no forgiveness for some trespasses.
darkconan200023 January 2007
If you are looking for a new original horror movie then this is exactly what you are looking for. Dennis is getting better with every movie he makes. The story is really good and easy to follow and has some damn good twists near the end. The effects are done very good for a low budget movie, but like before with his short film, he needs a bigger budget. A lot of people that make low budget movies stick their family members in and sometimes it hurts the movie but not in this case. Dennis Jr. knew exactly what he was doing when he got his father to play Keller. Stephen Martin did a good job as Lucas. I don't want to take anything away from Martin's job as Lucas, but I personally would have liked to have seen Thomas King come back and play that role. Speaking of Thomas, I think he stole every scene he was in. Overall, A Bothered Conscience is smart, dark, twisted and original. Just what horror fans have been needing!
11 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Neat backwoods horror outing
Woodyanders11 July 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Vicious redneck patriarch Keller McGavin (well played to the stern'n'steely hilt by Dennis Smithers, Jr.) and his wimpy bumbling son Lucas (a solid performance by Stephen Martin) protect their secluded forest land against trespassers through the most harsh means imaginable in rural Arkansas. After Keller gets bumped off by a sleazy cocaine drug dealer, Lucas is left to fend for himself and exact revenge on those responsible for his father's death. However, Lucas is soon plagued by unsettling visions of all the people him and his dad have killed. Writer/director Smithers, Jr. ably uses a mean'n'lean style in order to effectively create and sustain both a gritty no-nonsense tone and a creepy atmosphere which becomes more progressively bleak and spooky as the unsparingly grim story unfolds towards a genuinely startling surprise bummer ending. The outbursts of raw savage violence pack a really nasty punch. The remote sylvan location projects a truly harrowing feeling of dread, isolation, and vulnerability. Of course, we also get a handy helping of grisly gore and a good deal of nerve-rattling tension. The rough widescreen cinematography by Smithers, Jr. gives the picture an appropriately grainy look. Doug Johnson's neatly varied score alternates between harmonic hillbilly jamboree music and shivery ooga-booga moodiness. A cool little indie fright flick.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Actually my favorite
I bought this film in a collection from Walmart. It was this movie, Breadcrumbs, Mother's Day Massacre, and Butched. Out of all of this. This one was my FAVORITE. I honestly do not know how many times I've watched this. It's as bad as it is good. For the longest I thought it was an 80s film. But for an '06 production, to bring back old school horror, it was nicely done.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Excellent for what it is.
chikid-284374 September 2021
You have to bear in mind that this is not the work of a production company even though braindead films is handling the distribution.

This is a wholly self made film created with zero budget.

Well $2600.00 and that included the camera purchase.

Here I feel that it's only fair to tell you that since I have first gotten this film as a part of the backwoods butchers pack I have become aquatinted with Dennis Jr and consider him a friend.

That aside I have a little bit of behind the scenes knowledge about it.

This was the case of a young man following through on his dream of making a film.

Is it comparable to a blockbuster from a major company no but for a no budget production it's more entertaining than a lot of films with a much bigger budget.

If you don't mind seeing a film made by a rookie filmmaker on a true shoestring give it a chance.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
My Review Of "A Bothered Conscience"
ASouthernHorrorFan2 June 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Dennis Smithers Jr's "A Bothered Conscience" is a dark character asseveration of cold, driven horror. The film stars Dennis Smithers Sr., Stephen Martin, MacFarland Martin, Thomas King, Tim Turner, Dannial McCoy and Tina O'Neal. The plot is more or less an open one with a father taking brutal measures, and cruel tutorship, in raising his son to protect the family land from outside influence and trespass. "A Bothered Conscience" really proves that indie horror can be done and done well.

"A Bothered Conscience" is a stark, nearly flawless tragedy of sorts, filmed with an effect that hearkens to late 70's video nasty days, Smithers captures all the raw, edgy elements in "A Bothered Conscience". It is a story that plays out harshly and matter-of-fact with characters that almost feel both protagonist and antagonist simultaneously for most of the film, until the real protagonist comes forth near the end. The dialog is minimal but effective, character dramatics are short bursts of terror or just straight chilling shock as most of the interactions are of a brutal nature.

The acting is mediocre but very committed to the story. The atmosphere is very reminiscent of classic gore flicks like "Stanley" or " Let's Scare Jessica To Death". Only the surreal is almost non-existent until the last act, most of the film is a visceral nightmare that unfolds plainly, with calculative bluntness. Although there is no layered visage to the characters, "A Bothered Conscience" creates a powerful, straight forward modern video nasty that is very entertaining.

Special Effects and soundtrack are mild but clear elements that really make "A Bothered Conscience" a good film for gore-hounds and horror fans. The effects are smart, thought out tricks that offer gruesome moments to kill scenes without looking cheap, or cheesy. The blood is convincing enough, the deaths are creative and effective emotionally to the scene. Honestly it is amazing that "A Bothered Conscience" was shot on a shoestring budget of 2,300 dollars.

The soundtrack is an instrumental chorus of highs and lows that fit perfectly, I found myself having to keep saying "this is a modern film and not a previously unreleased video nasty from the late 70's. I didn't really expect much from "A Bothered Conscience", and true the acting isn't stellar, but everything works, and I enjoyed everything about this film.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed