"The Simpsons" Homer vs. Lisa and the 8th Commandment (TV Episode 1991) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
11 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Back when Homer could learn and grow
athomed28 December 2011
Couch gag rating: 8/10 It's the same couch gag from a prior episode in the season, Simpson and Delilah.

Right after the couch gag is a great scene. It takes place at Mt. Sinai as Moses reads the commandments from God... hilariously in no particular order. Phil Hartman plays Charlton Heston's Moses. It doesn't get much better than that.

The episode: Homer gets a cable hookup which isn't exactly legal. Lisa learns in Sunday School about the Ten Commandments and worries that the family will go to Hell for stealing cable.

This episode provides the perfect opportunity for The Simpsons to satirize cable programming. This episode also helped establish the moral code existing within the show for years to come. This episode makes us question our every day actions and how we justify them.

Favorite moment(s): Phil Hartman as Moses. Homer's foot. Bart's "Man, I wish I was an adult so I could break the rules."

Overall rating: 9/10 Homer vs. Lisa and the 8th Commandment showcases the first appearances of both Troy McClure and Drederick Tatum. It shouldn't be missed on that alone.
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Homer vs. Lisa and the 8th Commandment
studioAT20 July 2020
A really funny episode from the 2nd series, with some nice deeper messages too, as Lisa/Homer centred episodes tend to.

Great stuff.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Good Satirical Episode!
g-bodyl20 April 2014
The thirteenth episode in the second season of the Simpsons takes a great look at religion and the use of cable, which was popular back in the day. It has some memorable cultural references like the Ten Commandments and films like Jaws and Wall Street. Despite the satire, I found this episode to be pretty comical and surely I was laughing a lot.

In this episode, "Homer vs. Lisa and the Eighth Commandment," Lisa is shocked that Homer stole cable and in order to protest, she refuses to watch the cable and even protests a big boxing match that Homer and all his friends were going to watch.

Overall, this is a delightful episode and really funny. It shows that there are some consequences when it comes to stealing cable. Not the best episode, but still very entertaining. I rate this episode 9/10.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The cable guy
safenoe12 January 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Homer vs. Lisa and the 8th Commandment debuted in 1991, so that's almost 35 years ago, but it stands the test of time and also as part of the golden era which in my humble opinion is the first 10 seasons of The Simpsons. Here the writers consider the eighth commandment and apply it to Homer seeking to illegally connect to cable to watch a big boxing match. Everyone from Springfield, well not everyone, but you know what I mean, make their way to Homer's place to watch the big fight, but Lisa appeals to Homer's conscience to skip the fight.

Anyway, all credit to the writers for covering such issues.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
9/10!
Analog_Devotee4 June 2021
The one where Homer has illegal cable hooked up! Definitely a fun episode which also acts as a timepiece - who even has cable anymore?
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Thou Shalt Not Steal Cable
Hitchcoc11 April 2022
Lisa pulls her morality card when Homer gets cable illegally. The family begins to disintegrate, and our hero can't avoid overstepping his bounds. The best part of the show is a scene from Mt. Sanai as Moses brings down the Ten Commandments. Great bits concerning temptation.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
We just wanna watch the fight
snoozejonc30 June 2022
Homer gets an illegal cable hooked up to his television.

This is a strong episode with memorable character moments.

This is a morality tale with Homer being comically guilt-tripped by Lisa over breaking the law in what feels like a trivial way most people in Springfield.

It starts with a very strong parody of Exodus that sets the theme nicely, before it humorously shows the effect Homer's behaviour has on both children.

I love the vast congregation of Springfield residents that descends upon the Simpson residence and Homer's reaction to various individuals as the arrive at the door.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Cable Entanglement
hellraiser717 November 2021
This is an honorable mention for favorite episodes of Season 2. It's true there not much to it, this episode is what you would call one of the shows Christian/Preachy episodes but the execution of it is good as it has subtlety, let alone it's always good seeing Simpsons showing and exercising a moralistic side to them.

The plotline is simple as the Simpsons inadvertently have Cable illegally. It's understandable as to how each of the Simpsons get seduced by Cable TV. You must realize way before the Streaming, in the 80's and 90's cable was a really big thing. The concept of just having more channels than the usual standard meant more decisions and access to programing you can't always get on your standard channels. Like this little montage we see as to how addictive cable truly is as we see the big dent Homer has made on the couch.

Though of course you know that the cable party is over once Lisa and Bart learn about Hell and the "Ten Commandments" I don't blame Lisa for being really scared, the concept of Hell, as a Christian myself I don't doubt nor deny its existence. Whether any of you believe it or not one thing is always certain, everyone that violates Ethics in one fashion, or another eventually suffers the consequences.

There are a lot of funny moments, from the beginning of the episode seeing "The Ten Commandments" read off, it was cool seeing Phil Hartman doing his Charlton Heston impersonation. But what really made that scene funny was seeing each of the specific sinners night completely ruined from each commandment read, all I can say to that is serves them right.

Some of the verbal humor as usual is funny, clever, and memorable. One scene is when Bart says the word Hell a lot and he brings up a good point on the usage of the word and then Marge completely contradicts herself to get Bart to stop using the word and we see only a look of confusion in Bart and Lisa (same with all of us) after she says it.

Another is the Boxing promo where one of the boxers dramatically dedicates a fight to his late Manager. And then there is this Mike Tyson like character that does the same and of course it results in the cliched prefight roundness.

But what really drives the episode is the slight arc with Homer. Homer is just about dead set in keeping the stolen cable completely disregarding the ethics/morals from Lisa and his religious practice; though despite Homer's defiance, his conscious soon starts to catch up to him. From one creepy encounter with the shady cable guy again that wants to sell him a stolen car stereo, which shows how much bad karma juice the stolen cable has produced in their home. Afterward, Homer installs bars on his home afterward which brings out uncomfortable irony as it shows how close Homer is to sealing his fate.

Can Homer cut the instillation of sin before it's too late, you'll just have to wait and see.

Rating: 3 and a half stars.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Great mainstream seasons episode
richspenc23 May 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Seasons 2 - 8 are the mainstream episodes, the seasons that were the best and the most comfortingly familiar and the funniest.

"Lisa verses eighth commandment" really brings out Lisa's moral and extreme righteous side of her that will remain in the series for a long time to come. Actually, the first season Bleeding Gums Murphy episode was the first to explore Lisa's intelligent moral diversities, but this episode explored it deeper. Lisa is taken aback during Sunday school class when she learns about the horrors of not obeying the ten commandments. She then starts to see how members of her own family, especially Homer, are not keeping up with the commandments with little things in their day to day life. This is not the first episode that's toyed with the idea of hell. In "Bart gets hit by a car", Bart makes a brief visit to the damned before reviving after Mr. Burns hit him with his car. This episode discusses the details of hell further. Lisa is mortified over her dad getting an illegal cable system hooked up (after a funny moment with Ned Flanders going off on the sleazy illegal cable installer (Ned: "get off my property you..jackaninny!" Cable man laughing at Ned's non intimitading comical anger: "easy tiger")). The cable man stops at the Simpsons residence next and has no problem at all convincing Homer to let him install it, even with Homer knowing it's free. Lisa refuses to watch the ill gotten cable with the rest of the fam, with Homer grumbling to Marge about it, "why does Lisa have to be so moral? Why can't she be more like..well not Bart, there's got to be a happy medium". That right there really sort of defines the nature of the Simpsons; they don't want to be goody goodys, but they don't want to be totally reckless and rebellious. More modern 21st shows will often lean towards the latter rather than somewhere in the middle like the Simpons.

What I also like about the Simpsons (at least the 1990s Simpsons) is their values about needing faith and believing in God and attending church sometimes. Homer may've had some moments where he didn't want to get all into church (such as episode "Homer the heretic"), but he wasn't trying to completely go athiest. Even in "Homer the heretic", he doesn't stop believing in God, he just doesn't want to go to church. He has a dream about talking to God (where he suggests Homer to seek a new path of enlightenment), and is then quite happy and moved by it. That's not what it's like in "Family guy" where there are characters who openly admit to being a complete athiest and are proud of it, and there have been comments in that show that seem to encourage viewers not to believe. And that is not the only show or film today like that. It's because more people in real life are atheists today than than in the 1990s. It's the changing of the times in 21st century society.

There are a lot of good lines in this episode. Martin's reaction in Sunday school, "so there's a downside to the afterlife, how does one steer clear of this abode of the damned?" Bart's question "what if I were a good guy but in a really bad fight and lost a leg. Would it be waiting for me in heaven?" Teacher: "For the last time Bart, yes!" Then in car going home; Marge: "what you learn about in Sunday school today?" Bart: "hell" Homer: "Bart!!" The scene with Lisa and Marge in the grocery store with Marge stealing two grapes, Lisa's reaction, then the cashier's reaction when Marge told him was priceless (Cashier: "you stole two grapes? Who cares?" But overly moral Lisa still refuses to let it sit at that, then Marge says "can you please just charge me for them?" Cashier: groans, "I need a price check for two grapes. That's right, two measly lousy stinkin grapes!"). Also great during the time when the Simpsons are watching the cable, you can hear things playing on the TV that were in earlier episodes (i.e. Duff beer commercial, Troy McClure show, etc.). You can also pick up on major moments in TV history, such as "Dallas" "Who shot J.R." episode. I also found amusing Bart letting all his classmates from school, while charging admission, inside to watch the adult channel. Then of course the big fight on TV with Drederik Tatum (parady of Mike Tyson), and the comment about dedicating the fight to beloved deceased manager (taken from "Rocky"). Oh and Smithers and Mr. Burns discussing going to watch the fight at the Simpsons house, Smithers: "Why can't we just watch it here?" Burns: "the fight is one of those rare events where I savor the sights, sounds, and smell of other men". Smithers: "Still haven't lost the common touch sir". Also funny joke of Homer quickly hiding all the stuff he stole from Moe's when he sees Moe walking up to the house. And the continuing joke of Homer screaming every time he sees Mr. Burns coming to his house. Great episode.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
This episode isn't even worth stealing if it were a VHS Tape
snickzella21 September 2022
This episode is not terrible as it is preachy, dated and systematic of a much bigger problem with the early seasons of The Simpsons. First off, it's ironic that Lisa would go on to become a Buddhist later in the shows run. Seeing as how she's scared of the idea of Hell and what will take you there. What makes this episode dated is the stuff involving the cable stealing. Stealing is wrong, we get it, but they hammer it in really hard to the point that it becomes obnoxious. But the preachiness comes in the form of the "Christan agenda" I see going on. Now I have nothing against Christians. But part of the appeal of why the Simpsons has been such an enduring show, was that it didn't feel like it was specifically made to please people of a certain ethnicity or majority. While I'm not calling Christians a majority or minority. I will say that it feels like this and a few others that would come later on, that it felt like it was playing up agenda and need to scare people into religion. There has always been this very naïve and straw man esque belief that people who are religious aren't in anyway morally sound or have any kind of ethics. That is very naive and far fetch thinking, since there are plenty of people who are indeed very religious, but they aren't ethical, kind, or morally sound, instead it becomes all about being egoistical, manipulative, selfish, and criminal. Point is, you can still be morally sound and have ethics, and concepts of right and wrong, without being religious, otherwise we still be living in that flashback sequence we saw at mount Sinai. I totally believe stealing is wrong. But this episode feels like a very preachy, and strawman-based argument with really no nuance or the like. All in all this isn't a good episode, is worthless.
4 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed