"Rawhide" Incident of the Valley in Shadow (TV Episode 1959) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
too sugary, coincidental, clichéd, unbelievable
chipe3 January 2012
I loved the "Rawhide" series when I watched it as a kid. And I know that these Western stories are "morality plays," that one should gulp a strong dose of "suspension of disbelief" to enjoy them. However there has to be a limit. This episode was an embarrassment -- so saccharine and filled with corny clichés and unbelievable actions and coincidences. Most of the Westerns I have seen that involve Indians are like that.

Among the many things that disturbed me here included:

¶ Favor, riding alone, just happens to encounter and rescue the Indian chief who resides with the "captive white girl" the bounty hunter who joined the cattle drive was after. ¶ the white captive girl having the identifying jewelry with her initials. ¶ Favor endangering the herd, all for the sake of one white "captive," who may have wanted to stay with the Indians anyway. That annoyed me the most. ¶ Favor forgoing the $8000 reward (huge for the time). ¶ the Chief willing to fight to keep the "captive white girl" (his future bride-to-be), then encouraging her to return to her white family after she returns to him. ¶ Favor, and others, riding off alone in wilderness away from the other trail hands.
10 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Bounty on white captives
bkoganbing30 June 2018
Shades of the John Ford classic western Two Rode Together in that this Rawhide episode deals with white Indian captives and some of the drovers encouraged by Leo Gordon who is with the herd, but is a bounty hunter and after a particular white captive woman who is worth $8000.00.

Even Eric Fleming who is usually all about getting his herd through even has some thoughts on the subject. Especially after he meets Fay Spain the object of Gordon's search.

The whole thing is of concern to Cheyenne chief Rick Jason as Spain is to be his bride. Flemng and Jason agonize, only Gordon is sure of what he wants, that $8000.00.

Nice episode, but the John Ford film was so much better.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed