(TV Series)

(1977)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A far-fetched but entertaining episode
rayoflite249 August 2015
The Hot Dog Murder begins with Quincy (Jack Klugman) guest lecturing at a University Pathology class where a student approaches him to discuss some suspicious findings from the body of a prisoner he is examining which was donated to the university. A nearly frozen hot dog was found wedged in the victim's throat, and this evidence does not support that the death was an accident. Quincy becomes even more suspicious when he learns that the victim was convicted of embezzlement and had ties to a shady businessman, Arhtur Brandeis (William Windom), who evaded any charges during the investigation.

Although there are some pretty far-fetched and ridiculous elements of this episode, it does involve a murder mystery and an investigation into corruption which makes it quite worthwhile. William Windom is always good as the slimy type and he played this character as a guest star on several shows of the time. Quincy goes way out on a limb and engages in some trickery to get the evidence needed for justice to be served and it is pretty interesting to watch throughout. Overall an entertaining episode as long as you don't focus too much on the absurd aspects.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Quincy is VERY tricksy in this one!
planktonrules5 March 2013
Brandeis case it makes sense Quincy would investigate the suspicious death but to investigate and prosecute Brandeis himself?! "The Hot Dog Murder" is a very entertaining and funny episode--as well as one of the more ridiculous shows from "Quincy". Because it is so much fun to watch, I do recommend you see it even though it's absurd throughout.

Quincy is nuttier than usual in this episode--that's for sure! The show begins with Quincy learning about a bizarre apparent murder from a student at one of his lectures. It seems that a dead prisoner was found with a whole hot dog shoved down his throat!! The most likely man behind this--Brandeis (William Windom). Brandeis is a rich chiseler--and the prisoner is a guy who apparently took the rap for Brandeis' actions. So, instead of waiting for the justice system to react, Quincy becomes like a super-spy and not only infiltrates the prison (where he does some incredibly unethical things) but he then buddies up to Brandeis and pulls a sting to get the creep to confess to his evil deeds!! As I said above, it's absurd. But there are so many funny moments (such as his impromptu lie detector in prison) that you ALMOST can forgive its excesses...almost! Fun but stupid.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"This is more interesting than the anatomy of a bicuspid." Quincy solves a murder committed with a frozen hot dog!
poolandrews1 March 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Quincy M.E.: The Hot Dog Murder starts as Los Angeles coroner Quincy (Jack Klugman) is giving a lecture at a local University, afterwards he is approached by a dental student named George Talbot (Jonathan Segal), he ask's Quincy to take a look at his findings from the autopsy of maximum security prisoner John Kendall who donated his body to the University for experimentation. Officially Kendall died from natural causes but while dissecting him George found a frozen hot dog in his throat & evidence that it had been forced down there & therefore choking him. Quincy agrees with George's findings & sets out to prove that Kendall was murdered to silence him, but finding proof proves difficult as he tries to uncover the truth of the hot dog murder...

Episode 9 from season 2 this Quincy story was directed by Alex March & is a good solid early Quincy murder mystery with a little bit of humour & quirkiness thrown in for good measure. The main aspect of The Hot Dog Murder is obviously the unusual method of murder used, I would imagine there aren't many people killed with a frozen hot dog! Like a lot of the early episodes from the first couple of seasons a fair amount of the action takes place outside the traditional laboratory setting, here Quincy volunteers to become a prison doctor (a plot reused in House of No Retrurn during season four) to gain entry & do a little detective work in order to catch a killer. All in all this is a really good murder mystery & there isn't a moral or social issue in sight. Having said that Quincy as a character was still being developed & he does some uncharacteristic things like deliberately stealing confidential X-rays, torturing an inmate with electricity to gain information & spiking someone's drink in order to give them severe stomach & chest pains in an attempt to make him think he was dying (Quincy also gives him a set of rosary beads & shouts 'hurry up I've got a man dying back here' to the ambulance driver) which when you think about it is a really nasty thing to do & only tells him that he isn't dying when he admits to the murder. I mean he phones an ambulance up to take him to hospital which ties the ambulance up if anyone else needed it & then puts him in a room which ties the room up & all the equipment inside & again I ask what if there was a genuine need for that room or equipment? Also I would like to know what happened to the large envelope stuffed with money Brandise tries to bribe Quincy with? He gives it to Sam for safekeeping & then it's never mentioned again so what did they do with it? Maybe they split the cash between themselves?

This episode is well made & there's a half decent fight in it but it's not exactly stylish or memorable in that regard. The acting is fine form most of the cast.

The Hot Dog Murder overall is a good solid quirky Quincy murder mystery that came at a time when the production team were still working the character's out & therefore some of Quincy's behaviour in this is a little odd. Definitely worth a watch & fans of the series should enjoy it.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Answer to Paul Andrew's question regarding envelope
The_Snowdog13 March 2009
Warning: Spoilers
Comment on the bribe money in the envelope received from Brandise: Previous poster - Paul Andrews - was wondering what happened to it.

At the end of the episode, Quincy and the student (Talbot) headed off to let the wife of the murder victim know that her husband was indeed murdered and they were able to catch Brandise.

Before they leave Quincy asked Sam for the envelope with a comment such as "well Brandise told me to put it to good use..." and then Quincy hands envelope to student and says to him "You give her (the murdered victim's wife) this" meaning the envelope.

So the bribe money went to the murdered victim's wife.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Syringe goof
trainjustleft22 January 2022
It takes about 10cc of air injected into a vien to kill someone. That small amount in a handheld syringe won't do it. It's great theatre to show a doctor or nurse expelling the "deadly" air.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
hit dog
AlsExGal6 February 2024
A student is examining a convict's body donated to the university where Quincy is lecturing, and he asks Quincy to look at some of his findings. The convict supposedly died of emphysema, but on closer examination it is found that a hot dog was lodged in the convict's throat. Also, the man did have emphysema, but it was not at such an advanced stage that it would have killed him. The convict had been in solitary confinement for his own protection, as he wasn't a common criminal. Instead, he was scheduled to testify against a mogul who was allegedly running an insurance fraud scheme. But the hot dog had never been cooked - In all likelihood it was still frozen when it went down the dead man's throat.

Holy Roald Dahl Batman! This has shades of that author's tale "Lamb To the Slaughter", where the murder weapon was a frozen leg of lamb, defrosted and then cooked by the murderer and fed to the detectives working on the case. But I digress.

This is a completely far-fetched episode of Quincy, with him turning an EKG into a makeshift lie detector and simulating a coronary by "poisoning" a man with vitamin C. But just enjoy the journey and forget the ridiculous signposts along the way. There is a bit of a social message in this one, but it is subtle. Quincy volunteers as a doctor at a prison to gather clues, and the low quality of medical care available to inmates is discussed, but it is not at all the centerpiece of the episode.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed