(TV Series)

(1978)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Fairly good yet far-fetched episode
rayoflite2431 August 2015
Gone But Not Forgotten begins with a mysterious man being escorted from the airport to a hotel suite as several workers comment that it must be Stanley Troy, a reclusive tycoon who heads up a conglomerate. Later, an embittered man, Ben Mular (Ramon Bieri), is released from prison and escorted to the hotel suite in the same manner. Only moments after entering the room, Mular reemerges announcing that Troy is dead with a letter opener buried in his chest. Quincy (Jack Klugman) is called to the scene of what appears to be an open and shut case as Mular was the only visitor logged into the room by security and he and the victim had a turbulent history. However, when he conducts the autopsy there are several unexplained findings which lead him to believe this is not such a simple case after all and further investigation is warranted despite internal and external pressure to complete his report.

I found this to be a fairly good Season 3 murder mystery episode despite being pretty far-fetched. The investigation uncovers an epic conspiracy which was planned out over several years and involves many players, but I suppose this type of plot could be plausible given the power and resources available to the people running the conglomerate. The guest stars give solid, convincing performances and we see Joan Van Ark of Knots Landing fame appear as a reporter who assists Quincy in more ways than he expected.

Overall an entertaining and worthwhile episode as long as you watch it in the right frame of mind.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"Holy mackerel... I thought this was going to be such a simple case." Imaginative Quincy episode.
poolandrews27 December 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Quincy M.E.: Gone But Not Forgotten starts as Los Angeles coroner Quincy (Jack Klugman) is called out the Regent Plazza Hotel where the dead body of reclusive billionaire Stanley Appleton Troy has been found in his executive suite with a knife stuck in his chest. Lt. Monahan (Garry Walberg) thinks it's an open & shut case since there is only one way into the suite, only one man Ben Mular (Ramon Bieri) has entered since Troy was last seen alive & his fingerprints are on the murder weapon. At first glance Quincy agrees but several things don't add up after the autopsy like why no rigour mortis? Why the unusual blood test results? Why the needle puncture wound on Troy's arm? Quincy becomes convinced Mular is innocent & knows Troy was murdered by someone else, but will he be able to put the pieces of the puzzle together & prove it?

Episode 18 from season 3 this Quincy mystery was directed by Paul Kransy & is another great murder mystery, like a lot of season three this one has a neat story which is surprisingly clever with a good twist ending. It's not so much whodunit as to how they did it which provides the fun here, I won't spoil it but it's a well thought out idea which maybe is a bit far fetched but certainly isn't predictable. As usual no-one believes Quincy & he has to stake his reputation to solve the most baffling case he's ever seen so there's still plenty of scenes with Quincy tackling bureaucracy, red tape & stubborn unhelpful officials to give the episode a familiar feel. At 50 odd minutes (without commercials) it moves along at a nice pace, the basic mystery surrounding the events of the story is enough of a hook to keep you watching & I really rather enjoyed it.

Made with competence but little style this is a bland to look at but it was probably made on a shoe-string budget. The acting is alright, like always the regular cast do a better job than the guest stars although someone called Joan Van Ark (why does that name sound funny to me?) who is probably better know as Valene Ewing in the cult soap opera Dallas (1978 - 1991) & the same character in over 300 episodes of the Dallas spin-off series Knots Landing (1979 - 1993) becomes Quincy's latest conquest.

Gone But Not Forgotten is a good solid Quincy murder mystery episode with a much better twist ending than usual, in fact it sort of comes out of the blue & does take you a bit by surprise. This is one of the more imaginative Quincy episodes & definitely recommended.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Rather ridiculous, even for "Quincy".
planktonrules16 April 2013
Although this episode stars John Colicos (who is always delightfully slimy), this is a weak episode--mostly because the solution to the murder is utterly ridiculous.

The show begins with an older gentleman getting out of prison after eight years. He apparently was VERY angry as his old 'friend' (who is the head of a mega-corporation) wants to see him and make good on his promise to take care of him for going to prison in place of him. However, after the ex-prisoner goes up to the man's apartment, the police are called--and they are told that the angry ex-prisoner killed his old business partner. However, Quincy is convinced that the case isn't as open and shut as people think--mostly because some of the autopsy results are too bizarre to be true. Plus, there is a lot of pressure from corporate officials to wrap it up...fast. All this is pretty interesting. However, when the pieces all come together at the end, the solution to the crime is utterly stupid and so difficult to believe that I felt cheated. Decent episode with a rotten solution at the end.
5 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed