"Perry Mason" The Case of the Spurious Sister (TV Episode 1959) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Perry is up against a dead woman signing divorce papers.
kfo949423 May 2013
When this episode finally gets to the climax of the mystery, we get a confession, after thinking, did not really makes sense but we take it for TV sake. Someone on the witness stand is caught in a lie it will bring the entire house of cards down and we hear those three little words, "I killed her".

The story is rather complicated since it involves four women, especially in B&W, looking very similar. Marie Chapman is the murder victim in this episode as she is killed at a cabin in a rural part of LA county. She and her husband, Bruce Chapman, have been having trouble due to Marie's gambling habit. And as Mr Chapman is leaving on a trip he tells her that he wants a divorce. Later Marie is found dead and Mr Chapman has a pile of evidence pointing to him as the killer.

But here is the rub, later Mr Chapman, after having information that his wife was killed, receives a divorce degree from a lawyer in Las Vegas asking for a divorce and it is signed by Marie Chapman. Someone has posed as Marie in Las Vegas and is trying to blackmail Mr Chapman. But with three other women, that all look similar to Marie, may also have a motive for murder.

Perry will defend Mr Chapman through a long session of courtroom examinations. And through these examinations, Perry will work his magic until the real murderer is clumsy caught in a lie and then confesses to the crime. Not one of the better shows but an episode that makes you watch just to see who was posing as a dead woman for a divorce settlement.
22 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A Good Story With Lots of Blondes
Hitchcoc3 January 2022
A nasty woman is draining the checkbook of her husband and he puts a stop to it. This leads to her seeking a divorce. Of course, she is killed and her husband sits next to Mason in court. In the process there are identity issues, since putting big sun glasses on any blonde makes them look alike. This sounds silly but the actual case has some nice twists and turns, leading to the resolution.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A case of a bunch of blondes
AlsExGal18 December 2022
Marie Chapman has a compulsive gambling problem and is angry that her husband Karl has her on an allowance in his absence, as he is going out of town for six weeks. Marie says she needs two thousand dollars and decides to get it by hitting up her ex-husband - actually his current wife - for the money he owes her. It sounds like it could be blackmail money, but it is not explained.

Karl Chapman returns after only two weeks and finds that he has been sued for divorce by his wife in his absence, who has seemingly moved to Las Vegas in the interim. Karl goes to Perry to handle the divorce and the redoing of his will that will be necessary. But then Marie is found dead, strangled, at her cabin. Karl is charged with the murder, mainly because he went to the cabin in the middle of the night and went straight to the wrecked car where her body had been placed. Great shades of Humphrey Bogart in Conflict.

What goes on here? How does a dead woman sue for divorce? If her husband killed her, why would he want to settle with said dead wife? Watch and find out.

Marie was really a piece of work. Has she ever loved anybody or anything but money? That is one question that seems easy to answer - No! I'm surprised her killing didn't result in a medal ceremony rather than a murder trial, but I digress.

Because somebody has been in Las Vegas impersonating Marie and suing for divorce, the multitude of similar appearing blondes comes into play, and Perry has to sort them all out.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Fraught with peril
darbski13 July 2017
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS** Peggy Knudsen plays the victim in this sordid soap opera turned murder mystery. She was Eddie Mars' wife in "The Big Sleep" - one of my favorite movies. She's still a babe in this one. Several problems. One, Marie had been dead in her car for four weeks prior to discovery? The lying, snoopy, neighbor knew her, and used to ride horseback past their cabin? He didn't smell Marie's decomposing body? in a car with all the windows down? "Stinkin' to High Heaven" is the descriptive terminology that applies here. The car (a nice, new Edsel), would've stunk so bad it would have to be scrapped. See Bobby Fuller's Corvette. One other small thing. Greg Evans had said that Bruce had coasted by his place with the engine and the lights off. He had a beautiful Buick Invicta convertible. These cars ALL had power steering and power brakes; they are big cars and need the assistance to steer and brake them. The engine must be turned on for these systems to operate. Driving down a dark, hilly, road at night without it would be next to suicide. Evans had to be lying.

Ginny Hobart was a deceitful, thieving, fool, and the lawyer was the key. Where was his cut of the dough Marie extorted out of her Huz for a settlement? Why didn't Perry argue harder against such a payment? ANY TIME someone says "It HAS to be paid NOW or you'll lose everything"; you know it's a con. Never pay under those circumstances. Still, we have to have a story, or, there's no mystery, and, after all, people do stupid stuff all day long; that's why there are lawyers, right? All the killer had to do was deny recognizing the victim. It had been five years since he had seen her, and peroxide blondes were a dime a dozen there and then.

Why did Chapman not just hire a detective to check on his wife, rather than return and incriminate himself? Four weeks the body had decomposed? Very poor evidence, indeed. How much time did Ginny get in Tehachapi for felony grand theft and conspiracy after the fact in a murder? Speaking of flimsy, the "happily ever after" in this one stunk to high heaven.
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
One hard hearted golddigging dame
bkoganbing29 August 2019
Peggy Knudsen is one hardhearted golddigging dame and few tears will be shed when her demise comes. Come it does and the big wallet of a husband Karl Weber becomes the Perry Mason client.

Because he tries to control her gambling addiction Knudsen serves Weber with divorce papers. But she wants it all freedom and hubby's last bit of loot. She gets her money and later is found dead.

Perry has Paul Drake check on her Las Vegas background and he comes back with all they need. She was a showgirl and had a sister act with Marion Marshall though there is no blood relation. And she was forever on the lookout for guys with spending loot. She was however a bit sloppy with keeping track of marriages. Leads a bit to her demise.

I wasn't expecting the murderer I got, the mark of a good mystery.
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
She came to Vages to see me not the gaming table
kapelusznik185 November 2017
Warning: Spoilers
***SPOILERS*** Perry Mason, Raymond Burr, has to dig deep almost all the way to China to find the killer of Marie Chapman , Peggy Knudsen, who's husband-Perry's client- Bruce, Karl Weber, is on trial for her murder. It's after Bruce came home from a business trip that he found Marie's body decomposing in her car at the bottom of a ravine that was left unattended for almost ten days. It was the greedy and degenerate gambler Marie who had threatened to sue Bruce for divorce and take half of his property and money unless he gave her a flat $25,000.00 payment to fly down to Las Vages to gamble with it on the crap and card tables. It soon turned out that while Marie was dead someone was impersonating her to get her hands on the $25,000.00 check that Burce sent to the casino of her choice in Vages for her, the impersonator, to pi** away on the gambling tables.

Far too complicated to go into the plan that hinged on the fact that nobody knew that Marie was dead but still alive and in having the check cashed as well as it was gambled away before her body was discovered after her killer with his accomplice would be long gone before the police knew what happened. It was the luckless Bruce who faced ruination who not only ended up broke but arrested for Marie's murder. Perry following a number of clues at a local nightclub who Marie's Bopsie Twine act partner impersonated her to get the $25,000.00 in payoff money that her husband Bruce mailed to her.

****SPOILERS**** With Perry really getting nowhere he gets help from the killer himself who should have know better that a sharpie like Perry Mason would easily find the connection to his involvement with Marie that not only had him purger himself but also, by shutting her up, have her murdered. This little tidbit that Perry dug up about Marie's past and her killers connection to it was all Perry needed to get him to confess without even being cross-examined by him. As for Marie's Bopsie Twin partner she was so brainless that she left herself wide open for at least a charge of perjury or even worse accessory to murder by claiming that she was never at the murder scene even though she knew-or should have known-there was a photo of her being there!
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed