"Murder, She Wrote" Death Takes a Dive (TV Episode 1987) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
"She Joins with Harry to See the Spree. And What Does She See? --a Body or Three."
WeatherViolet3 March 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Jerry Orbach returns for his third "MSW" outing as Boston P.I. Harry McGraw in this episode centering around professional boxing, featuring numerous familiar guest stars, including John Amos, Ernest Borgnine, LeVar Burton, Bradford Dillman, Ray Girardin, Lynne Moody and Adam West.

At Ponzini's Gymnasium, in Boston, Massachusetts, Cosmo Ponzini (Ernest Borgnine) oversees a practice sparring round between veteran boxer Blaster Boyle (Harold Sylvester) and a rookie boxer who is coached by Trainer Dennis McConnell (Bradford Dillman).

Harry McGraw (Jerry Orbach) stands outside the ring, cheering on Blaster Boyle, with Harry's guest, Jessica Fletcher (Angela Lansbury), at his side. Cosmo Ponzini orders Harry to stop Blaster's fiercely beating the trainee, and so Harry and Blaster escort Jessica to a restaurant, for Harry to explain his reason for inviting Jessica to Ponzini's Gymnasium.

Harry explains that he has acquired Blaster's contract through a $5,000 loan outstanding to Pinky (uncredited actor), who has passed and left Harry in charge of Blaster. But Harry still owes the $5,000 to another unscrupulous creditor, as requests that Jessica purchase into a partnership, by pitching in the same amount.

Jessica says that she doesn't wish to own a boxer's contract, but trusts Harry for a $5,000 loan, and, after Harry steps aside, she tells Blaster that she trusts that he could win the fight.

But Blaster replies that his upcoming bout against Sean Shaleen (Michael McGrady) (who is also trained by Dennis McConnell) must be rigged in order for both contenders to survive the wrath of Sean Shaleen's contract holder, Wade Talmadge (Adam West), who escorts his squeeze, Lois Ames (Caren Kaye), wherever Wade goes, even to Ponzine's Gymnasium, at which Cosmo frowns upon the presence of women.

Cosmo doesn't evict Lois because of the powerful Wade Talmadge, but points to the "No Women Allowed" sign upon Jessica's presence, as well as to the equity-minded Pam Collins (Lynne Moody), who arrives with Reporter Dave Robinson (LeVar Burton) and objects mightily to Cosmo's mistreatment.

When Jessica returns to Cabot Cove, she receives a telephone call from "Boston Evening Post" Sports Reporter Dave Robinson, whom she tells that she has no interest in boxing matches, until he informs her that according the the Massachusetts Boxing Commission, she is listed as Blaster Boyle's contract owner.

An incensed Jessica immediately telephones Harry McGraw to demand an explanation, but Lieutenant Casey (Ray Girardin) answers the call, telling Jessica that his officers are in the process of arresting Harry for murder.

So, Jessica returns to Boston, to hear Harry's account of the incident, as ballistics tests match bullets with Harry's pistol, and he explains that an altercation erupted inside the Gymnasium, in which a perpetrator fired Harry's firearms during a struggle, in order to ward Harry to the floor, at which time nobody was hurt; plus, he was nowhere near the scene of the park, where the body has been discovered in an automobile.

Jessica then decides to investigate Ponzini's Gymnasium, when her taxi driver turns out to be Photographer Pam Collins, who picks up Reporter Dave Robinson along the way, to provide information regarding the murder, for which she suspects ulterior motives to Robinson's investigation.

Blaster and his Trainer, Doc Penrose (John Amos), also meet with Jessica, to provide additional clues, as they announce plans to purchase a Tennessee dairy farm, to leave the boxing world behind, as "Death Takes a Dive."

The cast is rounded out by Marcia Moran as Waitress, Richard Bravo as Sanchez, Bill Capizzi as Doorman, and Richard Balin as TV Sports Commentator.

This episode marks the first of two "MSW" appearances for Richard Balin, the second of three for Ray Girardin, including this, his second of two as Boston P.D. Lieutenant Casey, the first of four for Michael McGrady, the third of six for Jerry Orbach, each in his role as Harry McGraw, and the second of eight "MSW" guest starring roles for Bradford Dillman.

Jerry Orbach, acting in film and on television since 1955, has unfortunately since passed.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A Boxer's Manager, J.B's talents are endless.
Sleepin_Dragon20 November 2017
Jessica answers the call of a friend, and rushes to New York only to discover that Harry McGraw wants her cash, he's stepped aside from his role as a P.I and is now managing boxer 'Blaster.' Harry has high hopes for Blaster, but the experienced pro wants to settle for the quiet life. Harry needs $5,000 to pay off tough guy Benny Falcone, Jessica duly gives him a loan. Wade Talmadge has arranged a televised fight between Blaster and his boy Sean Shaleen, but insists Blaster throws the fight, Harry refuses. Harry is arrested by Lieutenant Casey, when Talmadge is found dead, shot with the same gun as Harry's.

This episode has some interest it's fair to say, judging by the number of reviews it's one that sparks a feeling, generally more negative view points. It's far from one of the best, the story itself is quite odd, and doesn't really feel like an episode of Murder she Wrote, the story doesn't have the usual pizazz. While not being a story that grips you as a viewer, there are some good points, always great to see the return of McGraw, although why is he now a boxing promoter? So popular was he, he gained his own spin off show. Lieutenant Casey also makes a welcome return.

The best bit of course has to be the presence of Adam West (Talmadge) who is just brilliant, that distinctive voice and particular style of acting made him so wonderful to watch. Such a shame he's passed away.

It's a bit unusual, but watchable enough. 6/10
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Adam West, Jerry Orbach and Ernest Borgnine join Jessica in this boxing mystery
cgvsluis15 October 2022
Jessica gets snookered into becoming a boxer's manager by none other than her friend played by Jerry Orbach.

There are great cameo's in this boxing Murder mystery in which Jerry Orbach is framed for murder. Adam West, Ernest Borgnine, John Amos and Michael McGrady join this star filled cast with Angela Landsbury.

Jerry Orbach has a boxer who he convinces his friend, Jessica to invest in. Later the fighter then tells Jessica that he is supposed to throw the fight...so she isn't going to be getting her money back. Then Jerry's gun shows up at a crime scene and all bets are off...Jessica's fighter is going to go for it and she is going to solve the crime.

This is a classic non-Cabot Cove Murder She Wrote episode in and around a big city boxing venue.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Batman's turned evil! And now he's dead!!!
planktonrules8 November 2022
In this episode, Adam West plays a scumbag boxing manager...the type to pay boxers to takes dives or pays goons to break legs. So, it's not surprise that eventually this guy is found dead....and a bullet from Harry McGraw's gun in the body. But how...unless Harry (Jerry Orbach) killed him. After all, he still had his gun when the cops arrested him and he swears the gun was always with him. So how did the bullet get in the body IF Harry is right?

As IMDB says, this extended length episode was shown as a lead in to Orbach's short-lived series, "The Law and Harry McGraw". This is a bit odd, however, as he's really barely in the show. Still, it IS entertaining and well done...I'm just not sure IF the way the killing occurred in the show is really possible. If it isn't, they sure made it sound plausible.

By the way, if you do watch, get a load of LeVar Burton's crazy hairdo.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Forensics is the key
bkoganbing10 July 2017
It's Jessica Fletcher's old friend Harry McGraw who is in a jackpot now and also has himself a new racket. Jerry Orbach is now the proud owner of a prizefighter in the person of Harold Sylvester. Sylvester's contract was left to him in a will. Orbach is now trying to turn that into some quick money.

After first being rejected, Orbach is then approached by crooked promoter Adam West and Sylvester will get a fight with an up and coming contender Michael McGrady if he'll agree to tank it. That he won't do and when West is found shot to death and the bullet from McGraw's own gun, it's Angela Lansbury who has to pull him from the jackpot.

As is usual there's a whole lot of other suspects around as West was ruthless and not well liked. Forensics is the big stumbling block for Lansbury. How the murder could have been done had me reaching I'm still not sure if it was possible the Lansbury described it.

But the casting as always is fabulous.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Slightly odd...
ian-payn18 March 2015
Warning: Spoilers
This episode of MSW is moderately interesting, but what's really curious is that two of the big-name guest stars have small and irrelevant parts. Neither Ernest Borgnine nor Bradford Dillman make much of an impression in this rather contrived tale in which Harry McGraw gets involved in boxing management, and then involves Jessica, before he's accused of murder (in such a desultory fashion the cop investigating more or less lets him go). Sadly, Adam West does not impress as a boxing promoter, and it's left to LeVar Burton and Lynne Moody to add what zest they can as a reporter and photographer, but even they get side-lined. The episode is written by stalwart co-creator Peter S. Fischer and directed by the equally reliable Seymour Robbie.I think the problem is that they were both a bit too much in love with Jerry Orbach - everyone else is just dancing around him.
4 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The dark side of boxing
TheLittleSongbird8 August 2017
Have always been quite fond of 'Murder She Wrote'. It is a fun and relaxing watch that makes you think as you try to unwind in the evening. If one wants more complex, twisty mysteries with lots of tension and suspense 'Murder She Wrote' may not be for you, but if you want something light-hearted and entertaining but still provide good mysteries 'Murder She Wrote' fits the bill just fine.

"Death Takes a Dive" was something of a disappointment. By all means, it is not the first underwhelming episode of Season 3 (didn't care for "Dead Man's Gold", "Murder in a Minor Key" and "Night of the Headless Horseman" either), but considering that it had a great actor like Ernest Borgnine, the recurring character of Harry McGraw (one of the show's better recurring characters) and the magic chemistry between Angela Lansbury and Jerry Orbach it could have been much more.

It is certainly a watchable episode and has its merits. The cast are the best thing. Angela Lansbury is terrific as is Jerry Orbach. Those two and their chemistry were the two main things "Death Takes a Dive" had going for it, and their chemistry is simply magical and what stops the viewer from bailing. Borgnine and Bradford Dillman do do very well too in their roles, which are agreed rather too small, while LeVar Burton and Lynne Moody spice things up.

Production values are slick and stylish as ever with 'Murder She Wrote'. The music has energy and has presence but also not making the mistake of over-scoring, while it is hard to forget or resist the theme tune. There are a few good ideas here and it is always interesting to see the dark, not so glamorous side of something that is often depicted as exciting and passionate (if brutal).

Adam West however was rather bland as Wade. The episode could have done more with the character, giving more development to make him other than the typical uniformly disliked "victim stamped over his forehead" sort of character. West does little with the character and doesn't look comfortable stepping out of his comfort zone, which immediately sucks the juice out of a role that, considering the show's record with other uniformly disliked characters, should have been juicy.

While the dialogue has some thoughtful and amiable moments, a lot of it is both overblown and under-cooked. Likewise with the story, which is often very dull (at times in a deadly sense) and sometimes far-fetched. The ending underwhelms, being handled so indifferently and staged in a static and completely lacking in energy or tension way, the identity of the perpetrator also seemed random and last minutes. And yeah, even the least demanding viewer will find themselves questioning the forensics here, am a fairly relaxed viewer myself in this regard especially when viewing 'Murder She Wrote' as escapist relaxing fun but that left me perplexed too.

In summation, watchable for Lansbury, Orbach and their chemistry but disappointing. 5/10 Bethany Cox
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Murder She Wrote Or Police Squad?
Imagine if you will the episode of Police Squad about crooked boxing, but without the laughs - this is exactly how this episode plays out. Considering it was made well after Police Squad, I can't even suggest that the writers of PS used this as the basis of their parody.

Even the same camera angles and terrible clichés are used, but this time the laughs they raise are unintentional.

A very, very poor script:it comes over that the actors involved have decided to play it just - and i mean JUST - shy of Leslie Neilson.

Worth a view if only to see it for a comparison to PS

Truly awful.
2 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Death takes a dive
coltras3528 August 2023
Thanks to her latest run-in with Harry McGraw, Jessica discovers that she now is the manager of a down-on-his-luck prize fighter who is looking to retire following his next fight. And while getting a crash course on her new endeavor, she has her hands full trying to clear Harry in the murder of a shady fight promoter ( Adam West)

Chemistry and team work between Harry and Jessica is great as usual. Jessica's facial expression at Harry's schemes is hilarious. However, it's just an ok episode which overstays its welcome with its longer than normal . My favourite Batman - Adam West - guest stars and his character gets iced midway.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed