"Leave It to Beaver" Lumpy Rutherford (TV Episode 1958) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Is there a way to beat a bully?
pensman25 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Beaver is going "armed" to school: he's packing a piece of coal. Unfortunately, June confiscates it. Wally wants to know if Beaver was really going to throw the coal at Lumpy. At least, he would have made believe so.

At this time in the series, Lumpy Rutherford is a giant and a bully who is currently terrorizing Wally and Beaver. The one aspect of his character that is a constant is he immediately kowtows to his "daddy," Fred Rutherford. The actor, Fred Banks, who plays Lumpy is the size of Richard Deacon who plays his father. Lucky for him the other actors got their growth spurts or Fred Banks would have had a limited run in the series.

Up in their room, Beaver and Wally are trying to figure out if there is any way to pay Lumpy back. Ward is concerned that the boys are getting home late from school; but they don't want to tell them they are being bullied. Finally, they admit who it is, Lumpy and he's sixteen. Ward offers to intervene but the boys decline the offer. Ward does provide a story from his youth about how he got revenge on a bully using barrel hoops. June is not amused. Ward doesn't believe the boys would follow through on his misadventure; but they do. There is a difference: Fred goes out and the hoops do their job.

Now Wally and Beaver are worried they might be found out. The Rutherfords are coming over, but to play cards. June tells Ward they are running late because Fred had some sort of accident. Ward chuckles because he says Fred is the sort of friend you don't mind seeing fall down.

So far, the boys haven't been caught but that might be ending. June thinks it would be nice for the boys to come down and say hello. If there is anyone they don't want to say hello to, it's Fred Rutherford. Ward wants the boys to come down after they get their pajamas on.

Fred has started playing cards and begins with one of his boring stories. The conversation changes over to the "gang" who knocked him down in his backyard. Mrs. Rutherford says, with a wink, that Fred believes it's the same gang who stole tires off his rental car in Acapulco.

When Ward goes upstairs to get the boys, they are worried if they will be sent to reform school. Fred has the cap of one of the hoodlums but can't decide what he should do. Ward in a sort of joking manner suggests Fred should take the cap to the police; he would be doing a community service. When the boys come down they're wearing cowboy hats and bandannas, but even when they are removed they aren't recognized. They do get an invitation to come over and play with Clarence (Lumpy). Fred is still going on but his wife feels enough is enough. When Fred mentions barrel hoops, both Ward and June react.

Ward and June go out to the kitchen where as usual June over reacts to the situation. Ward says just to relax, he will take care of it. Ward confronts the boys and they admit their responsibility; but Ward knows he is on the hook too, it was his idea. Ward tells the boys to just not pay too much attention to his stories anymore; they agree but get Ward to promise he won't stop those stories.

In the epilogue, we see Ward has told Fred. Fred has also accepted responsibility that his son Clarence might be a bully, and he will talk to him about it. Mrs. Rutherford understands and is embarrassed by the entire situation. On the way out, Fred asks Ward not to tell the story at work: we don't want to give the men ammunition.

Beaver is still up and he has a question for Ward. How come there are bigger guys who pick on little guy. Ward says unfortunately there will always be guys like that. Sometimes you just have to learn how to get along with them. What's important is that to remember the only way to really beat bullies is you don't become like them. Maybe we should petition the major networks to show this series again. It still has much to teach us.
11 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Brotherly togetherness
AlsExGal29 December 2023
This episode has Lumpy Rutherford, corpulent son of Fred Rutherford, Ward's business partner, bullying Wally and Beaver and behaving like the Billy Goats Gruff - refusing them passage to walk home from school past his house. The boys confide in Ward who tells them a story of how he dealt with a bully in his day. He seems to forget that little pitchers have big ears.

When Ward realizes what happened and tells the boys he'll smooth things over with Fred, that "smoothing over" takes place off screen. I guess it was beyond the time limit and budget for a thirty-minute show to illustrate how to tell your business partner that his son is a bully and get him to accept it without repercussions. Also, a couple of episodes back June had some weird idea about forcing togetherness on her sons. She doesn't appear to be too happy when they actually demonstrate togetherness as they did here.

I'm not sure where the transition occurred, but by the end of the series Lumpy is a friend of Wally's and graduating in the same class. Here he is supposed to be a couple of years older than Wally. However, he was always playing the part of the classic daddy's boy who was babied too much.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Hilarious Episode
joenic-2927926 October 2022
Warning: Spoilers
This is tied with "Water Anyone?" as my favorite LITB season 1 episode. It introduces us to one of the show's important characters, throughout the run of the series, Clarence (Lumpy) Rutherford. At this point, Lumpy is much bigger than Wally and at least a grade ahead in school. He is also the neighborhood bully.

Of course, as all LITB fans know, in later seasons Lumpy will have to repeat a grade or two and winds up as one of Wally's best friends; also backing down when Wally threatens to clobber him.

In Season 1 Wally isn't going to clobber Lumpy, so the boys come up with an idea--actually sewed into their minds by Ward--to get even with him. This results in a hilarious sequence of events. The great Richard Deacon, as the bombastic Fred Rutherford, steals the scene here; as he often would throughout the show.

Interestingly, Deacon's recurring role as Fred coincided with his more famous "Mel" character on the Dick Van Dyke Show (from 1961 until LITB ended). How he found time to do both, is anyone's guess.

I recommend this one to anyone who hasn't seen it.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
My Favorite!
YouMakeMe26 June 2021
Warning: Spoilers
My favorite episode! So funny! I think the hoops are genius because Fred is as annoying as Lumpy.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
WHAT KIND OF A GUY IS LUMPY, REALLY?
tcchelsey23 November 2023
Enter Clarence Rutherford.

Series writers Joe Connelly and Joe Mosher originally made "Lumpy" Rutherford's character a bully, as he is seen here. Of course, as the series went along, actor Frank Bank, who was fun to watch, eventually turned into a gentle giant, AND not particularly smart. You have to admit, there were more funny stories with that slant.

In this case, Beave and Wally want to even the score against big bad Lumpy, and they get a few pointers from Ward. True, he had many stories (with possibilities) of growing up back in the day, much like all our dads at one time or another.

Does it all work... not quite. Without fail, complaining Fred Rutherford is dragged into the mess. Long time character actor Richard Deacon was perfectly cast in this role, although he bore no resemblence to Lumpy. I will always say he was best compared to wise guy Eddie Haskell, and it was a missed opportunity he didn't play Eddie's father instead.

Frank Bank, who quit acting after the series ended and went into business, later returned with the original cast members in the 80s reworking of Leave It to Beaver.

Don't miss this super comedy of errors. From SEASON 1 EPISODE 16 remastered Universal dvd box set.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Ward Cleaver Dispenses Some Really Unsound Fatherly Advice To His Boys About Bullies
(*Beaver Cleaver quote*) - "Lumpy! Dumpy! The big, fat ape!"

Like - Back in 1958 - Was Ward Cleaver really perceived as being the ultimate ideal father? I mean - Was this family, TV Sit-Com actually trying to present him in that sort of light?

'Cause after viewing this episode (along with many others in the same vein) - I found Ward Cleaver to be a man of very poor judgement and tact when it came to dishing out advice to this young and impressionable sons.

And (as was always the case in these circumstances) - Ward would end up having to admit to the error of his words to his boys and, with that, caution them to not take too much stock in what he had told them in the first place.

Anyway - With that in mind - This is definitely one of the main reasons why I have found this TV show to be a less-than-satisfying view (for the most part).
2 out of 38 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed