Greta is in the audience, and Al wants to ask her out. He is self-conscious and messes up on the show and asking Greta out. Jill suggests a double date with Tim & Jill, Al & Greta. Tim finds Jill's old diary and wants to read it.
Tim encourages Al to ask out a woman who is a regular in the Tool Time audience and is hinting she likes Al. So far, so good, but then Al takes other dating advice from Tim.