"Gunsmoke" The Whispering Tree (TV Episode 1966) Poster

(TV Series)

(1966)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Keeps ya Guessing Until the Last Moment... (NO SPOILERS)
atomicis6 July 2021
Would have been a "10" except for the lack of FESTUS!! Really good morality play. Which way will Matt fall? Is the inexplicably wide-faced wife going to stick around a few more minutes after waiting eight years?! Who knows!! But Ed Asner and the actor (Saxon) playing the convict are remarkably good in this episode! As another reviewer said, the colors are striking here, and this installment is an especially good hour of TV.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Great Cast, Memorable, Low-Action
wdavidreynolds18 July 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Virgil Stanley is released from prison after serving eight years for robbery. The money he stole was never recovered, because Stanley buried it on his farm before he was arrested. There are several others interested in finding that money, including Earl Miller, who was involved in the robbery, and Jack Redmond, a law enforcement officer from the area where the robbery occurred.

During the eight years Stanley has been in prison, his wife and two sons have managed to make significant improvements to the farm, which is now thriving. Stanley is surprised at the accomplishments of his family, especially since some of the changes they have made to the farm make it difficult for Stanley to find where he buried the money.

Stanley finds himself pressured from all sides. Miller wants a share of the money. Redmond is sure Stanley has the money and wants to recover it. Stanley's family have welcomed his return and want to move on with their lives.

Meanwhile, Marshal Dillon is involved, because he has Redmond relentlessly hounding Stanley, and Dillon is suspicious that Stanley may very well have the money.

This is another of those episodes where Gunsmoke is merely the place where the story is set. Except for Matt's attempts to try to maintain order and keep Redmond from crossing the legal line while harassing Stanley, there is nothing about this episode that depends on participation from any of the regular Gunsmoke characters. However, it is a very good morality tale of a man given the opportunity to change his direction in life by making better choices. Whether Virgil Stanley has the character to make that change or not is at the crux of this episode.

The acting in this episode is up to the level we have come to expect from Gunsmoke. John Saxon, the veteran character actor, does a great job in the role of Virgil Stanley. Ed Asner is his usually nasty self as Redmond. Morgan Woodward has a smaller part than we often see for him as Earl Miller, but his frustration and loss of patience with Stanley is evident in his character.

The episode is well-written, intriguing, and not at all predictable. There is even a twist at the end.
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Beautiful photography and splendid leads make this first rate an ep
smithbea20 August 2020
The color of the ep is often beautiful bright blue. But Saxon and beautiful Scott (as a married couple reunited) are both tops. The story is very powerful and memorable. Death count is rather high but it is in keeping with the theme of the plot and is not gratuitous. Morgan Woodward relegated to small part here. He would be on Gunsmoke much more often in the future in more prominent parts
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
There is more to this episode than buried money
kfo949425 April 2013
Warning: Spoilers
Virgil Stanley (John Saxon) is being released from prison after serving eight years for robbery. Virgil and a man named Earl Miller (Morgan Woodward) took the $40,000 and Virgil was the one captured. Before he was caught he buried the money under a tree on his farm. On his way from prison he is met by Earl wanting his cut of the money. Needless to say Virgil is not too happy with the freed Earl but agrees to split some of the money with him.

When Virgil arrives in Dodge he is met by a private police officer, Jack Redmond (Ed Asner) who they stole the money from, he tells Virgil that he knows he has the money and will not stop hounding him until the money is returned. Marshal Dillon breaks the little reunion up and tells Virgil to take his family back to the ranch.

When Virgil arrives at the farm he finds out that his wife, Ada, and his two boys have worked the land and changed the scenery that Virgil remembered. All of the sudden Virgil has no idea where the tree is located the money is under. With Earl wanting his money and Redmond around every turn, Virgil will have to remember the sound of the whispering tree from eight years ago. Virgil's life, and his families, may depend on him remembering where the money is located.

Even though this episode did not have much action the story held up well with a powerful script. The story is not just about the money but also about not being able to see what you have until it is nearly too late. The actors were perfectly cast and did a brilliant job of making the story come to life. A really nice episode that was a pleasure to watch.
20 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed