I'm surprised when consecutive episodes of any TV series (especially dramas) are similar thematically, or in tone. (You'd think the producer would try to separate them.) Yet this is true of "The Sisters" and the following "The War Priest", both of which feature loud, blustering males. You might wish to compare and contrast my reviews.
An actor's popularity can hide his lack of talent. It can also, oddly, obscure real talent. Jack Elam is a belovéd actor, and perhaps for that reason, never got recognition as one of /the/ great character actors, handling everything from broad comedy to the nastiest of villains with aplomb. I've never seen an Elam performance that was other than perfectly considered, thoroughly professional, and /restrained/ -- even when playing an over-the-top character.
Pack Landers is such a character. He wants nothing to do with his kids, and tries everything he can to weasel money out of the nuns, a sort of blackmail for permission to take the kids away. Though Elam comes dangerously close on occasion to making Pack comic, he never slips over the line. He remains thoroughly unsympathetic, and the ending /will not/ leave you feeling "warm 'n fuzzy". Amen! to that. I thank the writer, producer, director, and Mr Elam for not letting this episode slide into a sea of icky-sticky sentimental goo. Sentimentality is precisely what "Gunsmoke" is //not// about.
PS: I have a friend who looks a lot like Jack Elam, and has even been mistaken for him. We'd planned to drive down to Oregon and bust in on him, but he passed on before we had the chance. By the way, the young Elam was almost skinny, and verges on the unrecognizable. His "appreciation" was slow, taking decades. He said near the end of his life that he no longer played in Westerns because they couldn't find a horse big enough! What a lovely person.
An actor's popularity can hide his lack of talent. It can also, oddly, obscure real talent. Jack Elam is a belovéd actor, and perhaps for that reason, never got recognition as one of /the/ great character actors, handling everything from broad comedy to the nastiest of villains with aplomb. I've never seen an Elam performance that was other than perfectly considered, thoroughly professional, and /restrained/ -- even when playing an over-the-top character.
Pack Landers is such a character. He wants nothing to do with his kids, and tries everything he can to weasel money out of the nuns, a sort of blackmail for permission to take the kids away. Though Elam comes dangerously close on occasion to making Pack comic, he never slips over the line. He remains thoroughly unsympathetic, and the ending /will not/ leave you feeling "warm 'n fuzzy". Amen! to that. I thank the writer, producer, director, and Mr Elam for not letting this episode slide into a sea of icky-sticky sentimental goo. Sentimentality is precisely what "Gunsmoke" is //not// about.
PS: I have a friend who looks a lot like Jack Elam, and has even been mistaken for him. We'd planned to drive down to Oregon and bust in on him, but he passed on before we had the chance. By the way, the young Elam was almost skinny, and verges on the unrecognizable. His "appreciation" was slow, taking decades. He said near the end of his life that he no longer played in Westerns because they couldn't find a horse big enough! What a lovely person.