"Gunsmoke" The Blacksmith (TV Episode 1960) Poster

(TV Series)

(1960)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
George Kennedy shines in this 'near-poetic' episode
kfo949418 September 2013
This episode was not the most exciting story nor did much of the dialog make good sense but it was a tale that everyone will enjoy when a man stands up for the person he loves. No one can be dissatisfied with that type of plot.

George Kennedy plays a German immigrant and local blacksmith, Emil Wolheter, that is being harassed by a local brute named Tolman and his two sidekick friends. When Emil answers a letter from a German woman, Gretchen, asking to marry a Germanic man, the harassment gets stronger when Gretchen arrives in Dodge. During the wedding reception Emil has to physically taking Tolman to task when he wants to dance with Gretchen. So now Tolman is looking for revenge.

One evening Emil, thinking someone is in need of his service, leaves his house to help a stranded family. But this was a rouge to get Emil away as Tolman and his friends set fire to his just completed house. Now Emil is hot. It is not about him anymore but when they tried to hurt Gretchen, Emil will dish out some German justice on the three amigos.

Even with the odd way that Marshal Dillon handled the situation and the poor choreographed fight scene, the story was still so well acted that it will please about everyone. Add in some funny lines from Chester and Doc and the episode was entertaining in many ways. Good watch.
22 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Good Character-Driven Entry
dougdoepke10 April 2014
Good character tale with a particularly fine performance from George Kennedy on whom the 30-minutes turns. Nice guy, blacksmith Emil (Kennedy) sends away for German-born wife. Trouble is hulking bad guy Tolman (Anderson) doesn't like Emil or foreigners like Emil. So he breaks up Emil's wedding, after which the equally hulking Emil throws him into a water trough. Now there's going to be real trouble.

Great byplay between Doc and Chester, again showing why these touches helped lift the series into classic category. Kennedy manages a convincing German accent that helps give the entry an authentic feel. The brawl, however, is pretty much by the numbers and not very convincing. Still, the episode features three of the biggest men in Hollywood, counting Arness. Anyway, it's easy to see how Kennedy went on to feature films after his stellar turn here.
14 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Cordwood
darbski20 October 2017
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS** Yup, anytime a bully and his cowardly cohorts get taught a lesson, I like it. Especially, when they demonstrate that gift from the Almighty: Stupidity. See, it's a really bad idea to make an enemy out of the local Blacksmith.

Unless you can shoe your own horses, fix any kind of ironwork, repair virtually anything made of metal, and handle the work as a craftsman, you're gonna be plumb outta luck if you have to have it done. THAT'S why nobody with any brains picks a fight with this indispensable individual. Since everyone else in town also relies on his skills, you'd be making enemies of them, too.

In this case, Emil, a generally nice guy is threatened by a trio of idiots that results in the burning down of his nice house and home to his new bride. He then knocks the stuffing outta them about which Matt tells several bystanders "Just take 'em and stack 'em up somewhere 'till they get their health back"; one of his best ending lines, in my opinion. Seems like I saw a Rifleman episode with a similar theme; danged if I can recall more than that.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Hackneyed Mail-Order Bride Story
Johnny_West12 April 2020
George Kennedy plays the role of Emil the German blacksmith. Kennedy was a guest on Gunsmoke seven times. Kennedy's grandmother was German, and he speaks German to his mail-order wife, Gretchen (played by Anna-Lisa, an actress who was born in Norway and originally came to the USA as an au-pair). It was impressive to find out that both Kennedy and Anna-Lisa had backgrounds that helped them be credible as Germans.

The story itself is pretty lame. This story was done almost exactly the same way on The Rifleman, Big Valley, and Bonanza. I would guess it was done on a few other shows too. If you watched all the 1950s/1960s Westerns as a kid, you noticed that a lot of the same stories were used in different TV shows.

The racist for this episode is played by Robert Anderson, who was on Gunsmoke four times. Anderson often played bullies, thugs, slobs, racists, and town jerks. Anderson hates Germans, and he is further outraged to discover that Emil is getting married to a mail-order German wife. Anderson has a couple of goons who are presumably his employees. One of them is Wesley Lau, who would later play a Los Angeles police detective on Perry Mason.

One of the flaws of most of the Old West shows is that many of the town's characters are only seen once, and never again. So after Emil and Gretchen get married and the racists are run out of town, there is no follow-up to the story. Did they ever have kids? Did the racists ever give them any more trouble?

The best part of this episode was Doc Adams shooting zingers at Chester and Matt from the beginning to the end. Sometimes when the writers had a really bad story, they filled up the time by giving the regular cast good scenes interacting with each other.
10 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Best.... Line.... Ever
george-84112 August 2011
Warning: Spoilers
An average episode, by Gunsmoke standards, which makes it quite good by general TV western standards. A young George Kennedy plays the town blacksmith (this is before Quint... and we never see Kennedy in this role again) who's a German immigrant and he orders a German mail order bride. She arrives in Dodge and, of course, some of the racist town riff-raff decide to hassle the newly married couple. The story goes on somewhat predictably with the harassment escalating to their home being burned down (nobody's hurt, though, as this episode is somewhat lighthearted) and Kennedy takes his revenge upon the ignorant cowboys involved.

In my mind the best part of the episode is when Matt and Chester arrive at the wedding party only to find their old pal Doc has already been partaking of the "adult beverages." Here's the unforgettable exchange: Chester, approaching Doc who's near the beer barrel: "So, I see you've got a headstart on everybody here." Doc: "You betcha I did. I know how you and MATT (said with emphasis, for some reason) feel about free refreshments. So I wasn't gonna take any chances, I tell you that!" Chester, passing a beer to Matt: "Here y'are, Mr. Dillon." Matt: "Ah, thank you."

Eyeing Doc who's looking a wee bit inebriated, Matt cocks his verbal firearm: "Sure hope nobody gets shot tonight..." Doc, wiping his mouth with his hand, as is his habit, plus he's got a beer mustache to deal with, asks suspiciously: "Why?" Matt, smirk on his face: "I'd hate to see the hole you'd put in him trying to find the bullet", as he walks away to avoid Doc's inevitable comeback.

Chester: giggles Doc, said to Matt's back as he walks away: "Well, just because you can't keep the peace around here is no reason why I can't enjoy myself." They don't write dialogue like this anymore!! ;)
14 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed