"Gunsmoke" Tag, You're It (TV Episode 1959) Poster

(TV Series)

(1959)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Everybody is on alert when a gunslinger comes to town.
kfo949427 August 2013
A well written story that tells a tale, in a different that usual manner, of a gunslinger, Karl Killion, that comes to Dodge and makes everyone uncomfortable.

Matt knows of Karl's past but with no warrants and no past convictions, Matt is helpless to do anything about the gunslinger. It seems everyone in town is nervous about Karl to the point where they avoid places where Killion may visit. Killion has one man so nervous that he decides that he is the target of Killion's bullet. So he tries to kill Killion only to find himself being buried at boot hill.

With everyone in town walking on egg shells, Killion gets to know this saloon gal named Rusty Farrow. It seems that Killion may settle down after-all making the townsfolk happy. But Matt gets some information that will cause at least one person to realize that they were lucky to still be alive.

Paul Langton did an excellent job of making the villain Killion as exciting as possible. With the fine acting and the excellent script, this was a pleasant show for viewers. Good Watch.
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Hired Gun with a Tragic Backstory Must Make a Difficult Decision Warning: Spoilers
An interesting foray into the power of reputation and the weight of one's word.

Ultimately there was a lot of untapped character potential. However, what little background and depth the runtime could provide served the emotional core of the story well, even if the climax and reveal came rather suddenly.

But I very much enjoy the culmination of everyone's fear and the big reveal, in that the hired gun's actual target is one of the only peolple who was never afraid of him.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
No Name On The Bullet
The plot is similar to the 1959 Audie Murphy movie "No Name On The Bullet". A notorious gunman (Paul Langton) rides into town, making everyone nervous, since they believe he's been hired to kill one of them. I think Murphy was better cast in the original movie, given his innocent, all American, bland handsomeness. Langton does well, not radiating any menace. The gunman in both the movie and this episode are congenial enough that each could've given up his career and settled down in town. Both actually make friends in the town. Both have a romantic involvement with a woman in the town. Given that the episode was only 1/2 hour, not much emphasis is given to the subplot of the original movie where many of the leading citizens have a guilty secret in which they something which would motivate someone to hire a gunman to kill them. This episode should have been a full hour long, to give some of the townspeople a backstory where they'd done dirt to someone. Imagine if Miss Kitty or the Doc had an ugly episode in their past! As is, the only interesting plot point is finding out who the gunman's target is.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Smiling Cobra
dougdoepke18 August 2007
Black-clad rider arrives in town. Matt knows him from Matt's own unexplained past. The man's Carl Killion, a feared gunfighter, but he is also quite personable and not at all menacing. Still he does have a reputation, and above all, why is he in Dodge. As Matt observes, Killion's not a drifter, so there must be a reason-- someone's marked for death. But who. The whole town is on edge waiting to see how his presence plays out.

Pretty good episode. Paul Langton's Killion is a charming ladies man, even if a bit over-age. Chester's thwarted attempt to spark dance-hall girl Madelyn Rhue appears to be a sub-plot; however, these tightly scripted half-hours seldom meander. Good twist ending. Frequent mentions of head-writer John Meston's home-town, Pueblo (Colorado), made me think script must be from him, but screenplay is credited to Les Crutchfield. Apparently there're advantages to being a head-writer.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Settled??
darbski3 October 2017
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS** I really like Madlyn Rhue. She's a great looking lady with good acting depth whose talents were capitalized on by several casting directors through several decades. Even when she plays characters with ulterior motives, she's a sweetheart. The bad guy who Matt know from his days in "The Panhandle", is after her because of an inheritance. Matt finally figures it out. He's been hired to bump off Rusty (Madlyn) for her uncle in Pueblo. Matt levels his Karma, and saves Rusty. One problem is that she's still not safe, is she? Her uncle and money jealous cousin are still in Pueblo, aren't they? About the only thing Matt can do is get as much information as possible from Rusty, and telegraph the snakecrap relatives that their plan was discovered, and they'd better lay off the lovely lady. Of course, Matt now has a real nice back up Colt for the office, and Carl (bad guy) gets a nice dusty piece of earth to spend eternity.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A Matter Of Honor
StrictlyConfidential30 November 2020
(*Carl Killion to Marshal Dillon quote*) - "I'm just a drifter - Here today - Gone tomorrow."

Hired killer, Carl Killion has arrived in Dodge and his presence has got a lot of people in town feeling pretty uncomfortable.

Marshal Dillon knows the score about Killion and he confronts him to find out who is his intended target.

But, Killion ain't revealing anything and, so, the viewer is left wondering until the final climatic moment.
5 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed