"Gunsmoke" Pucket's New Year (TV Episode 1957) Poster

(TV Series)

(1957)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Matt Helps an Old Man Find New Purpose
wdavidreynolds23 December 2021
Matt Dillon and Chester Goode are on horseback in bitter freezing weather when they spot an abandoned wagon inhabited by an old buffalo hunter named Ira Pucket. Pucket and his skinner, Jed Larner, were hunting buffalo when Pucket injured his foot. Larner took the saddle horse and left Pucket stranded.

Matt and Chester take Pucket to Dodge, and Doc Adams treats his injury. The foot was so bad, Doc had to remove most of it, but Doc says Pucket should be able to walk with a cane once he has healed from the surgery.

Six weeks later, Pucket can get around using a cane, and he is still determined to find Larner and avenge his abandonment. In fact, Pucket is about as stubborn, prideful, ornery, and resolute as they come. Pucket's physical injury means he can no longer hunt buffalo, but his pride has suffered more than his body.

Marshal Dillon wants to avoid a situation where Pucket kills Larner and is hung for murder. He knows that finding a solution that will allow Pucket to regain a sense of purpose and self-esteem is the key helping the man.

Edgar Stehli was a popular radio voice, as he was a master of dialects. He moved into television in the earliest days of the medium and appeared in several television series in the 1950s and 1960s. He plays the Ira Pucket character in his only Gunsmoke participation.

The Jed Larner character is frequently mentioned in this story, but he only appears onscreen in a brief scene. Veteran film actor Grant Withers plays the character in his only guest appearance in the series.

The only other notable appearance in this episode is from familiar actor Richard Deacon, who plays the banker Botkin in the actor's only Gunsmoke appearance. Actor Wilfrid "Budd" Knapp played the Sam Botkin character in Season 1. This is the first appearance for the character in Season 2. The character only makes one more appearance in Season 2, and Kirby Swift plays Botkin in that episode.

Season 2 episodes broadcast in 1956 tended to be dominated by tragedies and episodes with heavy themes. The Gunsmoke producers chose a more lighthearted, feel-good episode to begin 1957, and it mostly succeeds. Stehli's portrayal of Pucket is a little excessive at times, but it clearly communicates Pucket's obstinate nature. It may be difficult for the viewer to sympathize with the character because he is not likable. In fact, it is surprising Matt goes to such extremes to help the man, but Matt seems more amused by Pucket than annoyed.

There are a few enjoyable snippets of banter between the characters that are now becoming commonplace and always add nice touches. Matt's frequent teasing of Chester about becoming "soft" because of city life is one example. In the opening scene, Chester is complaining about being hungry again. Chester grumbles when Matt tells him to make sure he keeps the fire going in the stove in the office, but only after Matt has left. Doc helps himself to Matt's liquor jug in lieu of drinking Chester's notorious coffee. There is even some flirtatious conversation between Kitty Russell and Matt where she tells the Marshal she expected to be in San Francisco.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A less serious show to start off 1957
kfo94945 June 2013
We get a change of pace in this episode as we take a different look into a new year with a story that is much more uplifting that some previous shows.

The story begins out on the cold prairie as Matt and Chester come across a unhitched wagon in an area that has been below freezing for days. Inside the wagon they find an old man with a lively spirit named Ira Pucket. Ira tells the Marshal that his partner left him on the prairie after he received a foot injury making him unable to ride a horse. Matt and Chester tell Ira that they are going to take him back to Dodge and let Doc look at his badly injured foot. As they are leaving Ira tells Matt that if he ever sees his partner, Jed, he is going to kill him.

Doc mends the old buffalo hunters but has to remove some of the foot due to gangrene. This causes the once proud hunter to become lame and he feels like his life is over. Matt is going to do everything he can to help Ira get back into life but it just became more difficult when Jed rides into town.

After some serious shows this episode is much more light and at times amusing. Some will find this show more child-like than regular but take it for what it is- a nice show to start a new year. With that attitude this show is not too bad.
10 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Lighter Holiday Entry
dougdoepke19 October 2011
A mildly humorous episode like this is mainly a matter of taste. A holiday entry, it was run right after New Year 1957. Crippled old coot Puckett (Stehli) is left to freeze on the prairie by cruel partner Larner (Withers). Instead, he's rescued by Dillon and Chester, who take him back to town. There, he's ornery as ever, swearing revenge against his former partner. Now Matt's got his hands full trying to restore the old man's stubborn pride before he gets into real trouble.

Nothing much to remark on: holiday episodes were supposed to be lighter fare. Puckett's not very likable, but we respect his obstinate independence. In passing— maybe the best acting is Arness and Weaver pretending it's a cold Kansas day when it really looks like a hot day in LA. I hope they got paid double.
10 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Abandoned On The Prairie
StrictlyConfidential12 August 2021
Warning: Spoilers
(*Ira Pucket quote*) - "I'll kill him when I find him."

"Pucket's New Year" was first aired on television January 5, 1957.

Anyway - As the story goes - Marshal Dillon promises to find the skinner who abandoned a buffalo hunter in a three-day blizzard.
1 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Winter in Dodge
vslawson-734981 February 2023
LMAO The show starts out with Dillon and Chester in heavy coats talking about the overnight temperature at 20 degrees below zero and viewers are supposed to get the impression its still incredibly FROZEN as they approach a run down wagon. So when they walk toward the wagon and Chester is clutching his coat to keep warm a fly lands on Dillon's shoulder and walks towards his head and to top it off in all the scenes where trees are visible they are all in full bloom with leafs. Cracked me up when I saw that fly land on Matt's shoulder. I tried to find the episode on one of my subscriptions to see the fly again but none were in my listing.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed