"Gunsmoke" Murder Warrant (TV Episode 1959) Poster

(TV Series)

(1959)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Not That Kind of Law
jamdifo8 September 2013
Warning: Spoilers
Dillon respects the law, but not the kind of law that will take a man dead or alive. As Ben Goddard (Onslow Stevens, his only time on Gunsmoke) says to Dillon "Don't you have respect for the law." Dillon reply's "Not that kind of law". Dillon uses his smarts a lot in this episode. He gets Lee Prentice (Ed Nelson) friends together to intimidate Ben Goddard not to act on taking Prentice. It works as Goddard goes away without a fight.

Earlier, Dillon arrests Prentice for a made up charge so bounty hunter Jake Harbin (Mort Mills) can't take him in. It almost backfires. But Dillon gets him, his 81st confirmed kill on the show.

I liked this episode, well done from beginning to end. I love when Jake Harbin tells Dillon he's going to kill Prentice and he can't do nothing about it. Dillon just lays him out with one punch. I don't understand why Dillon gave back Harbin his gun. Harbin could have killed Dillon right there in the marshal's office. Not too smart on his part. The episode did have mostly smarts and suspense thru out it.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Harmless
maskers-8712631 October 2018
Fairly typical episode and somewhat fun although its unlilely Matt world bénd the law like that'.
1 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Whose Law is It
dougdoepke10 October 2012
Lee Prentice (Nelson) seems like a nice enough guy. Then plug-ugly Harbin (Mills) shoots him in the back on the excuse that there's an arrest warrant out for Lee, dead or alive. Seems like Harbin prefers taking him in dead. Meanwhile Matt's concerned that Lee is being given no trial so the law is not being strictly observed. So Matt figures out a way to keep Lee out of the hands of the lynch mob jurisdiction.

Interesting premise since there's a conflict between two legal jurisdictions without an apparent legal way to settle the conflict. Of course, the script favors the clean-cut Lee and Matt against the vicious Harbin and the other sheriff. However, I'm not clear on the details of Lee's alleged crime, but the conflicting jurisdictions make for an interesting premise. I'd be interested in how the law actually handles such cases. Still, the thirty minutes manages its share of suspense.
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Deja Vu Again...
darbski18 September 2017
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS** Okay, I liked it. Why, you ask? Cuzz, the guy Harbin didn't need to see Lee any more in the Long Branch. Why? He thought he'd already killed him; OR thought he could dry gulch him later. Either way, he was a back-shootin' coward, and Matt KNEW IT. It followed right along that he'd try to back shoot him again. Remember the bartender who back-shot the guy who befriended him? Same type of deal; warrant dead or alive? That fact also calls into question Baker City; were they all back shooters? When the Sheriff comes-callin', Matt's ready, and he makes it impossible for him to arrest Lee (probably to shoot him in the back for trying' to escape). Matt backs him down. It was good watching the sheriff's hand tremble as he thought about trying' it. Only thing - he'd heard about Matt, his deputy was dead (He didn't seem too concerned about him, did he?), and he decided he wasn't suicidal, after all.

Think the sheriff tried it again? what if he just took the stage back to Baker City, got a couple good horses from the rich creep that put out the contract on Lee, traveled right back up, and bumped off Lee later? Yeah.. just get three good horses; 2 pack animals. One for his trail supplies and one for Lee's body (include a nice canvas bag for it), and tend to business. Of course, better NEVER have business in Dodge in your life again. Ever.

More likely, the sheriff went back, got all his pay, packed up everything he had that mattered, and hightailed it for parts unknown. After all, he weren't no Bat Masterson, were he?
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Wanted: Dead Or Alive
StrictlyConfidential7 March 2021
(*Lee Prentice quote*) - "It's bleeding, bleeding bad."

Legal deputy, Jake Harbin has come to Dodge from Baker City with a warrant for the arrest of Lee Prentice who is wanted for the murder of Jim Turner.

Marshal Dillon gets involved in matters which eventually brings Baker City's sheriff, Ben Goddard, to town.

It's a tight situation that soon escalates into a showdown of the most unusual kind.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Matt must have eyes in the back of his head
kfo949413 August 2013
In this episode we have a local boy named Lee Prentice that has got in trouble in a town of Baker City. The city is a corrupt town that is run by the whims of Ben Goddard. Prentice says he was defending himself but Ben Goddard issues a murder warrant for Prentice to be brought in dead or alive. Goddard sends a deputy, Jake Harbin, to Dodge to kill Prentice.

Matt finds out Harbin in town to kill Prentice so he arrest Prentice to keep him safe from the deputy's gun. And while walking away from Harbin, Matt somehow turns 180* and just so happens shoots Harbin that had pulled his gun to shoot the prisoner. Matt must have been able to see directly behind himself to make such a move.

Anyway it is not long before the tough looking Sheriff Goddard makes his way to Dodge City. But something strange happens when he gets in town. The tough looking Sheriff has not gone against Marshal Matt Dillon.

The episode had another of those questionable endings where Marshal Dillon seemed to overwhelm a person just by his presents. The viewer was expecting more but got less as this episode came to a conclusion. Just did not have the power that other episode possess.
4 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed