The Archer and gang have arrived in Gotham City, robbing the rich and giving to the poor in the style of Robin Hood. Archer is arrested, but not before managing to win the favor of the public with his good deeds. Upon his release from prison (owing to the citizens of Gotham City joining together to pay for his bail), the Archer makes a promise never to steal from the rich again.
Batman and Robin set out to explore the villians secret hideout, while Alfred distracts them at a shooting range by demonstrating his skill with bow and arrow. The Archer's keen sensing equipment soon detects the dynamic duo's presence though, and a trap is remotely sprung. Archer returns to his lair to question Batman and Robin as to the location of the Bat Cave. When the caped crusaders remain silent, Archer offeres them a "fair duel", only to leave our heroes tied up to giant poles for this jousting match...