User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Made me want to take the subway.
manbitesdog-19 February 2006
The documentary follows artists through their performances and troubles of being a struggling musician/artist working in the New York subway system. From the very beginning it caught my attention and was far more interesting than I figured it would be. Some of the performers were talented and some weren't but the one thing that remained and was addressed was that they were living the lives they wanted.

One of the main focuses of the documentary was that the city wanted to sponsor artists to play in the subways, guaranteeing a sort of quality of music that could be heard in them. They presented these artists with a banner proclaiming that they were good enough to be endorsed by the city. The film shows the tryouts for the project and the victory/defeat that accompanied them. At the same time it features interviews with a police officer whose job it is, is to bust up subway performers and keep the tunnels ear friendly. All the performers, regarding talent, are very interesting and provide for an entertaining glance into performance art and the sacrifices that are made to do what they love.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Inspirational and heartbreaking...
tstephens198124 January 2006
Warning: Spoilers
I had the chance to watch the premiere of this film at the Slamdance film festival, and thought it was a great documentary. The idea of looking at subway musicians is highly original, and it's refreshing to see them portrayed as the artists they truly are as opposed to obnoxious bums that apparently can't get a "real" job.

The film goes in-depth with several characters the directors found in the subway, some sponsored by MUNY (Music Underground New York? Something like that...) and some trying to outrun the cops that regularly kick performers out.

We get to see that these people see their lifestyles as careers, and their aspirations and joys are just the same as the rest of us. The movie follows the characters long enough that we really get to know them, without dragging its feet for any length of time. We are right there with each character as they confront their feelings about their lifestyles, some seemingly for the first time in a long while. By the end of the film you will be cheering for each artist, and hopefully look at street performers in a whole different light. I know I certainly will.

--------------SPOILER ALERT-------------------------------------------

This doesn't really "spoil" the movie as it's not really that shocking, but for the freshest experience don't read ahead unless you've already viewed the film.

I was starting to wonder about the drug situation, as some of the characters seemed overly eccentric and I wondered why they acted so strangely at times. They are all very talented musicians, to the point that you might expect them to be leading regular, productive lives (by most standards, of course) and yet they are still confined to the underground scene, w/o permits trying to outrun the subway-patrol. But as the movie carries on we see actual footage of one performer shooting up heroin, and two talk fairly in-depth about their addictions and how it affects their musical careers and daily lives.

The directors mentioned this in their post-screening discussion, saying that when they left production one character is still using (as far as they know) after a heartening, yet short-lived period of sobriety in the film. It's just another aspect of the movie that makes it all the more real, down-to-earth and refreshing. It's heartbreaking and inspirational at the same time.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed