The Wretched Life of Juanita Narboni (2005) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Interesting novel captured on film
JuguAbraham29 December 2005
Morocco is an interesting country--with a rich multi-cultural past that is somehow being overlooked by the predominant Muslim population. The cosmopolitan history of the city of Tangiers, before Morocco gained its independence, is captured in the 1976 novel by Angel Vasquez Juanita, which the director Farida Benliyazid courageously decided to adapt in this film.

There is a certain maturity that this film embodies--it is not often that directors pick up a subject centered on an anti-heroine. Directors prefer to deal with beautiful women, heroic and larger than life. Here is a quaint example of a lady director choosing to film a novel on the life of a "wretched woman," a spinster, and over-critical of life around her while coming to terms with political, social and pecuniary changes that affect her for the worse. Actress Mariola Fuentes, who plays the lead, interprets the unremarkable character with considerable restraint.

At the recent Dubai Film Festival, Ms Benliyazid stated to the audience that the subject of the film is very close to the present day Dubai--multi-cultural, multi-religious, and tolerant. The film does capture the incredible tolerance between Jews, Muslims, and Christians that must have existed in the past. I have been to Morocco twice this year, but this multi-cultural tolerance is not apparent today as the Morocco of the early 20th Century as has been portrayed in this film.

This is not a "wretched" film; it is merely a film on a "wretched" individual that will serve as a cultural memory for Moroccans of the current generation. I wish to compare this film to three Moroccan films made in the last two years that have won accolades around the world. Compared to Mohammad Asli's film "In Casablanca, angels don't fly" this film does not match it in any department. However, compared to Yassmine Kassari's "Sleeping child", Ms Benliyazid's film is more mature and even in quality (both films are made by women on women in Morocco) though the former won more awards at film festivals. While the subject of Ms Benliyazid's film may not be politically correct in some parts of the world to win awards, its underlying message is relevant for Morocco and the rest of the world!
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Novel adaptation about a woman's miserable life
sh_bronstein16 March 2009
Warning: Spoilers
"La vida perra de Juanita Narboni" is a film about a woman in Tangier, Morocco, who is very unhappy. She was born into a rich family, to an alcoholic father and a very controlling catholic mother. Her sister is basically a slut, as Juanita, the main character, constantly mentions. Juanita's own misfortunes with men start with her engagement to a gay man, who eventually leaves her for another man. She is afraid of meeting someone afterwords - not just because of her catastrophic engagement, but also because her mother's strict rules about prudence and chastity bind her very tightly. So Juanita ends up staying single. She lives to see both her parents pass on, and her sister eloping with one of her beaus. Her best friends die, or leave the country, and no one is left to share her life except her faithful servant Hamouch - who eventually disappears as well.

"La vida perra de Juanita Narboni" is a film about one woman's lifelong solitude, it portrays her inner struggles with a very high dose of irony. Mariola Fuentes, who plays Juanita, is a remarkable actress. Her monologues and soliloquies are very enjoyable - she really captures the character's self irony and humor, but also her pain. Other actors are unfortunately by far not as good as Fuentes, which is really a shame. Another weak point in the movie is that the narrative, which is set in a very interesting place (Tangier) in a very interesting time (1938-1965), does not actually exploit all the possibilities available through this setting. Important historical and cultural aspects could have made the narrative richer and more satisfying, in my opinion. Because these aspects are only in the very vague background, the movie gives the viewer the feeling of having missed something.

All in all, and foremost because of Fuentes wonderful acting skills, I would say this film is entertaining, but not quite fulfilling.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed