The Natural Route (2004) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
brilliant short film
jenniferkentau13 April 2006
I have seen the film La Ruta Naturale a number of times now and still regard it as one of the most moving short films I have ever seen. A simple story told in reverse questions the nature of memory and experience in a very powerful way. There are no need for words because the images used tell the story so beautifully. I was very moved after seeing this film at Telluride and still remember it in detail. I was amazed to discover the director was only in his mid twenties, as the themes explored so successfully in this film intimate a much older and wiser spirit. The subtle mood and tone of the piece will no doubt go straight over some people's heads, but what can we do? Anyone is allowed to see a film and post a review of it on IMDb...
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Disconcerting at first, but ultimately rewarding
el_monty_BCN23 February 2006
Warning: Spoilers
MILD SPOILERS

Given that since Memento, the trend of filming backwards has grown exponentially, I wasn't much surprised to find "yet another film in reverse" when I started watching this; but I was wondering exactly what was going on and why we were being told this story like this. Eventually you find out, of course, and what makes it more interesting is that the answer is not as straight away as in other examples of this budding sub-genre (which is generally: The guy's reasons to do what he did were completely wrong!!). Later you realize that the big hint was in the palindrome of the title, in the opening credits...
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Handsomely Made, But Please Give Credit Where It's Due
PilaMin30 January 2008
Warning: Spoilers
I applaud this short film for being a well shot, well edited mood piece with a very high concept and perfectly stylized narrative that properly evokes its theme of life and death and memory. Classical lighting, great separation of the actors, and solid application of colors. It all looks like a professional production. Very impressive for such a young filmmaker/writer.

**Spoilers**

Yet I am so very disappointed that the writer and director did not credit Damon Knight, the science fiction writer/editor of the 1950s/60s. He wrote an original short story entitled "Backward, O Time." In it, a man dies tragically in a car accident, only to be "born" out of the wreckage. He ruminates on the eventuality of every man's life. All the actions of the characters are performed backwards, as when he shaves, hair grows back, etc... He and his wife have one son, who "grows" into a baby, only to be taken away from him by nurses and inserted back into his wife's womb. In time, his wife is also "taken away" from him. The man eventually grows into a baby and is taken away from his parents and, you guessed it, inserted back into his mother's womb, where, in an epiphany, he wonders what his life was all about.

**End Spoilers**

The similarities can only stretch so far to the point where all assumption snaps off. Damon Knight was a wonderful writer of speculative fiction, and he died without the wider fame of Issac Asimov and Arthur C. Clarke. I absolutely admired this short film; but knowing what I know, it is very difficult to appreciate it any further.

It's easy to admire this short film for what it accomplishes on a technical level, and I am sure it has only helped the director's career. I do not want to accuse the man of plagiarism, and so I wish him the best of luck. Just don't forget the name Damon Knight.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Work of Art...
funkete921 April 2006
This is a masterpiece. One of the best, most moving things I've seen to date. So much for think-fullness. So much for another perspective on life, or death, or live after death. No dialogs. So what? I guess I didn't need the dialogs, just the voice of Divad in off narrating what was going on....that's it, that's all I needed.

Funny yet sad. Full yet empty. Most wonderful 11 minutes in a movie theater. See this short, and I bet you will change your perspective about almost everything that surrounds you. I bet you will want to see it over and over again.

A simple short, no effects, no chitty chat, just the story, as it is. It remembered me a lot of Memento. A very simple movie, very twisted in the edition process, and that twisting is what makes it more interesting.

Two thumbs up all the way for this short.
11 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A matter of pride to us
sergrb2 April 2009
A Short film, which project, in its beginnings, all of the classmates of Screen writing of its Director, Àlex Pastor, worked hard to be approved the Script of this Short. Finally, this project became, to me, a film that is already a Classic of all Shorts in Spanish Film History, which it's also a way of hope to the next promotions in the film school ESCAC (Cinema and Audiovisual School of Catalunya), which, as the years go by, next projects will be more ambitious and brave, after this one. Cause ESCAC has been the born of a lot of young talents in Spanish Cinema, who already directed their first Feature film: J.A Bayona, Guillem Morales, Roser Aguilar, and our hopefully first film of Kike Maíllo, and who knows, myself as one of them… in a future.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Gets more impressive the longer it runs
Horst_In_Translation23 December 2018
Warning: Spoilers
"Larutanatural" is a 10-minute live action short film from 2004, so almost 15 years old now, maybe older depending on when you read this review. The writer and director is Àlex Pastor and this was his very first filmmaking effort from a fruitful career he's enjoying since then that also led him to American English-language film starring the likes of Chris Pine. But yeah, back to this one here. I think it is pretty impressive for a rookie effort and lets me think that we will see some great stuff in the future from him. A very grown-up film for a man in his early 20s, certainly better than the first works by many legendary filmmakers. The film's title can be read from the first letter or from the last letter and the word is the same. And that is no coincidence as the film plays backwards from the final days of the protagonist to his youth and eventually birth while realizing at the same time that everything is written. He evaluates his life seeing what happens from the perspective of an old man as he is the voice-over narrator in this movie. Something you frequently see in Spanish movies I believe and it worked well. It felt right and insightful listening to him talk about his child, the love of his life and life in general. I felt the film needed a little while to get going strongly and really get me involved, but when it did, it was a very meaningful watch. I can see why it scored such a strong amount of awards recognition back then. Go watch it and make sure you have a set of good subtitles unless you are fluent in Spanish as the narration is very fast and spot-on and requires you to understand every single word perferrably. I give this movie a thumbs-up without hesitation. It is also a film that will make you think a bit. Everybody is talking about death and their fear from nothingness that happens afterwards, but nobody thinks about the nothingness for millions if not billions of years before we were born. Annd you will when the closing credits roll in. Also liked the reference about how we are born in pain and blood and the more I think about the film, the more I like it I must say. Maybe I will rewatch it at some point and then give it an even better rating. Right now I think it's not a must-see, but certainly very much recommend checking it out.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
This way to the Regress
lmattozz8 May 2020
Nice short film, yet the clever idea for the plot comes from Damon Knight's short story "This way to the Regress". This film should be considered an adaptation of that.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed