We Have Decided Not to Die (2004) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Beautiful and enigmatic...
Moxie23 March 2006
Warning: Spoilers
The title, nay, even the creators' intention with this short Australian film, is beyond my poor power to perceive, but it definitely is stunning for the senses.

It's all in black and white. There is no dialog or text; just slow, mournful, quasi-Middle-Eastern music. The entire film spans only eleven minutes (including credits) of three scenes: Birth, Between, and Rebirth.

Each scene features one individual: respectively, a young woman floating in a swimming pool, a young man (and his twin apparitions) gyrating between two oncoming automobiles, and a young man running and breaking through a skyscraper window into the open air.

You can view the whole creation at http://www.abc.net.au/tv/shortandcurly/txt/s1513993.htm

UPDATE: Thanks, planktonrules, for your kind words. But I didn't really "like" it, and I didn't really get it. My 8 rating was sheerly for production values. Seeing this again -- barely remembered 3-1/2 years later -- I still feel the same way, though a little less in awe of the artistry. And in my unperception I became as bored as planktonrules.

Judging from the "helpful?" responses, at least six other people have read our reviews. Negative numbers bestowed on a review most often indicate disagreement or displeasure. As my review was solely descriptive (neither true praise or criticism), I can only wonder what the problem was. Spoilers? Whatever, instead of hit-and-run, why not please add _your_ comments? Your review of the film could benefit us all more than your review of a reviewer!
8 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Eve Sander summed it up very well, though I was less impressed
planktonrules10 January 2009
It only seems fair to give credit where credit is due. While I didn't enjoy WE HAVE DECIDED NOT TO DIE, I must admit that Eve Sanders in her IMDb review did a very good job of encapsulating the film. I suggest you read her review in addition to mine, as I don't want to just repeat much of what she said. However, I should point out that while she liked this short Australian film, I didn't--though I could appreciate the work and skill it took to film it. The three segments all represent three stages of life and are carried out without dialog. My problem is that I just didn't find any of it interesting or compelling. Skilled, yes. Compelling, no. By the time this was finished as it played on The Independent Film Channel, I was aching to see what was coming on next.
12 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Beautiful short caught by chance
shmobbie20 May 2010
So, I won't mention what any of the other reviewers are saying because if you want to know what this special short film is about then you can read the plot synopsis or the other reviews.

I will say that I sat down on my couch, stoned, and started to watch a different short on IFC that was followed by this: A beautifully crafted and strange short film that I could never begin to explain. Well, I could try to explain it but I doubt my interpretation would matter. I didn't get bored, but hey, I was stoned(I'm also not one of those stoner's who think everything is interesting when I'm stoned, it actually gives me quite the short attention span), so say what you will.

My favorite ritual was the third, the other two were well done but this one stagnated in my mind for the longest time.

My only real gripe with this is the first ritual. I enjoyed it but it made me feel sort of uneasy, maybe that was the goal seeing as how it was meant to represent a womb? who knows. great stuff.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed