Dumb Witness
- Episode aired Oct 31, 1996
- TV-14
- 1h 43m
IMDb RATING
7.9/10
2.1K
YOUR RATING
An elderly woman confides to Poirot that she fears one of her relatives is trying to kill her for her money. He persuades her to disinherit her heirs, but she is murdered anyway.An elderly woman confides to Poirot that she fears one of her relatives is trying to kill her for her money. He persuades her to disinherit her heirs, but she is murdered anyway.An elderly woman confides to Poirot that she fears one of her relatives is trying to kill her for her money. He persuades her to disinherit her heirs, but she is murdered anyway.
- Director
- Writers
- All cast & crew
- Production, box office & more at IMDbPro
Storyline
Did you know
- TriviaAt the end, when Charles Arundel states that he's leaving water speed records to "Campbell and his cronies," he's referring to Malcolm Campbell (1885-1948), who set several land and water speed records. In his craft "Blue Bird K4" his highest water speed record was over 141 MPH (227 km/h), a mark reached in 1939.
- GoofsThe escaping natural gas from the room heater was not burning, thus it could not produce carbon monoxide. Doctor Granger died from suffocation, because there would have been too little oxygen. In an enclosed room, natural gas would eventually be in too high of a concentration to sustain normal oxygenating respiration.
- Quotes
Captain Arthur Hastings: I just wondered if you were having problems sleeping.
Hercule Poirot: So you awaken me to inquire? That is friendship indeed, Hastings.
- ConnectionsReferenced in Monk: Mr. Monk and the Dog (2009)
- SoundtracksBy the Fireside
(uncredited)
Written by Jimmy Campbell, Reginald Connelly and Ray Noble
Performed by Al Bowlly
Featured review
Intrigue to the end in this superb Poirot whodunit
The only frequent "other" person in this Agatha Christie mystery besides Hercule Poirot is Captain Hastings. Chief Inspector Japp and Miss Lemon got a holiday from this entry in the TV film series. But, Poirot does get other help in "Dumb Witness." It comes from Monsieur Bob, a wire Fox Terrier that is the pet of Emily Arundel. The clever, cute and curious dog is the dumb witness to the first attempt on the life of his mistress.
This mystery is among the very best of an excellent collection of some 70 Poirot stories that Christie wrote. Up to the very last, I had no idea who the villain might be. I had exhausted the list of suspects as, one by one, they were plainly eliminated. Even then, the ending caught me by surprise. And, I could see how it took Poirot the time it did to solve this one. The mystery of Madam Arundel's death with the circumstances about her will would throw even the world's greatest detective off the trail. At least for a while, as here.
Still, Poirot eventually pieces it all together - with the help of Bob, and surprises everyone when he reveals the murderer. This story has the usual outstanding qualities one comes to expect of the Poirot series produced for BBC (U.K.) and PBS (U.S.A.) airing. The scenery, camera work, costuming, technical production and direction and acting are superb.
A host of top actors join David Suchet and Hugh Fraser in bringing this intriguing tale to life. Patrick Ryecart and Kate Buffery are particularly good as Charles and Theresa. They play the snobbish and selfish nephew and niece to perfection. And, Pauline Jameson and Muriel Pavlow are very good as the giddy, superstitious but kind Tripp sisters, Isabel and Julia.
Here are some favorite lines from the film. For more dialog lines, see the Quotes section under this IMDb web page of the movie.
Captain Hastings, "I just wondered if you were having trouble sleeping." Hercule Poirot, "So you awaken me to inquire? That is friendship indeed, Hastings."
Captain Hastings, "Marvelous view over here, Poirot. Come and take a look." Hercule Poirot, "No. We will take your word for it."
Hercule Poirot, "Hastings, a favor. Whatever I should say, you are not in agreement." Captain Hastings, "Did I ever do otherwise, Poirot?"
This mystery is among the very best of an excellent collection of some 70 Poirot stories that Christie wrote. Up to the very last, I had no idea who the villain might be. I had exhausted the list of suspects as, one by one, they were plainly eliminated. Even then, the ending caught me by surprise. And, I could see how it took Poirot the time it did to solve this one. The mystery of Madam Arundel's death with the circumstances about her will would throw even the world's greatest detective off the trail. At least for a while, as here.
Still, Poirot eventually pieces it all together - with the help of Bob, and surprises everyone when he reveals the murderer. This story has the usual outstanding qualities one comes to expect of the Poirot series produced for BBC (U.K.) and PBS (U.S.A.) airing. The scenery, camera work, costuming, technical production and direction and acting are superb.
A host of top actors join David Suchet and Hugh Fraser in bringing this intriguing tale to life. Patrick Ryecart and Kate Buffery are particularly good as Charles and Theresa. They play the snobbish and selfish nephew and niece to perfection. And, Pauline Jameson and Muriel Pavlow are very good as the giddy, superstitious but kind Tripp sisters, Isabel and Julia.
Here are some favorite lines from the film. For more dialog lines, see the Quotes section under this IMDb web page of the movie.
Captain Hastings, "I just wondered if you were having trouble sleeping." Hercule Poirot, "So you awaken me to inquire? That is friendship indeed, Hastings."
Captain Hastings, "Marvelous view over here, Poirot. Come and take a look." Hercule Poirot, "No. We will take your word for it."
Hercule Poirot, "Hastings, a favor. Whatever I should say, you are not in agreement." Captain Hastings, "Did I ever do otherwise, Poirot?"
helpful•50
- SimonJack
- Sep 4, 2018
Details
- Release date
- Country of origin
- Official sites
- Languages
- Filming locations
- Keswick, Cumbria, England, UK(town where Emily meets Jacob)
- Production companies
- See more company credits at IMDbPro
- Runtime1 hour 43 minutes
- Color
- Aspect ratio
- 1.33 : 1
Contribute to this page
Suggest an edit or add missing content