The Eclipse: Courtship of the Sun and Moon (1907) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
13 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
You won't believe your eyes!
wmorrow5912 September 2004
Considering the brief running time of this bizarre and delightful little film, it's impressive how much detail, incident, and humor director Georges Méliès managed to pack into it. I've seen it three or four times now and catch something new every time.

The opening scene is strongly reminiscent of Méliès' most famous work, "A Trip to the Moon," made five years earlier. Once again we find ourselves in an ancient classroom of some sort, with benches arranged before a lectern, and once again the audience members march into the room like military cadets. But this time, instead of Victorian astronauts-in-training, we see a group of young astronomy students carrying telescopes across their shoulders like rifles, wearing costumes that suggest this story might be set in the 17th century. The white-bearded professor enters (once again played by Méliès himself) wearing the familiar star-bedecked robe and carrying himself with much pompous authority. This time, however, low comedy devices are employed to deflate the lecturer's pomposity: during his lecture the scribe falls asleep, a prankish student pins a paper doll to the back of his robe, etc. etc. Yet when it's time for the eclipse the students are genuinely excited, and eagerly rush to the window for a better look while the professor races upstairs to watch from his observatory.

As an earlier poster remarked, the eclipse sequence that follows really must be seen to be believed. We look on in amazement as The Sun --here depicted as an ugly, nasty-looking demon with pointed ears-- sidles up behind the coy, smooth-faced Moon and proceeds to inspire an unmistakable orgasm, as The Moon's facial expressions convey the full range of erotic pleasure. To call this "suggestive" doesn't do it justice: this is a sex scene without the sex, no two ways about it. One thing I still can't determine after several viewings is whether the actor playing The Moon is a mannish-looking woman or an effeminate man. Usually in art and literature the moon is portrayed as feminine (our "man in the moon" notwithstanding), but whichever the case, Miss Luna certainly looks ready for a cigarette and a nap afterward.

Méliès follows his coup-de-cinema with a charming sequence in which the planets Venus, Mars, Saturn, etc., are also portrayed as personified characters (ones that behave more decorously than the Sun and Moon, mind you), after which we're treated to a meteor shower. This brings us back to the elderly professor, who has become so excited by the astronomical display that he tumbles out the observatory window into a rain barrel. The film concludes with a slapstick coda as the old man's students and assistants awkwardly attempt to dry him with blankets.

The conventional wisdom concerning Georges Méliès is that his best days were already past by 1905 or thereabouts and that his subsequent films were dull and repetitive, but this one at any rate is far from dull. In fact I'd rank "The Eclipse" with the man's most delightful films, and recommend it to anyone interested in early cinema. Happily, the print recently restored for the Kino series 'The Movies Begin' is clear and sharp, and in far better shape over all than most of the director's other surviving works.
14 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Clever, inventive and enjoyable
ackstasis8 April 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Georges Méliès, most popularly-known for his remarkable 1902 film 'Le Voyage dans la lune / A Trip to the Moon,' was truly a magician with the camera – a pioneer of both cinematic special effects and narrative-driven films. Between 1896 and 1914, Méliès directed more than 500 short films. Though I am not overly fond of the director's early, one-shot efforts (usually just a vehicle for showing off his clever special effects), I am held in absolute awe with his more ambitious, plot-driven projects, such as the aforementioned 'Le Voyage dans la lune,' the glorious 'Le Voyage à travers l'impossible / The Impossible Voyage (1904)' and other lesser-known gems such as 'L' Éclipse du soleil en pleine lune / The Eclipse: Courtship of the Sun and Moon (1907).'

'The Eclipse' is largely a slapstick comedy, with its old and bumbling Professor of Astronomy (played by Méliès himself) suffering various unfortunate incidents both before and in the aftermath of a spectacular solar eclipse and meteor shower. Prior to this momentous spectacle, the aged Professor gathers a class of talkative and mischievous children to educate them of the phenomenon. At first, the children begin to fall asleep, and then one of them ventures to pin a scrap of paper (cut into the shape of a human) to his back as he scrawls onto a blackboard. Giggling at their little prank, the children pay little mind to what their teacher is telling them, though they scramble to the window excitedly as the eclipse draws nearer.

On a higher floor, the Professor and the other teachers eagerly await the awesome display, with the Professor helping himself to the largest telescope and pointing it directly at the converging sun and moon (don't try this at home!). As we've already noticed in his previous films, Méliès is fond of anthropomorphizing astronomical objects (who can ever forget that classic image of the explorers' rocket piercing the eye of the Man on the Moon?!), and here is most certainly no exception. The Sun – an old, bitter and ugly brute – licks his lips as the young, effeminate-looking Moon approaches. What results is an unmistakable, and infinitely-baffling, allegory for sexual intercourse. As the expectant Sun disappears behind the latter, the Moon's "face" suddenly shows an explosion of pure satisfaction, and each entity emerges from the encounter looking both exhausted and fulfilled.

Following this are two sequences described respectively as "The Wandering Stars" and "An Unexpected Bath." In the first, we are shown the spectacular skyward dance of various astronomical objects – stars, planets, moons – with a male or female "angel" perched upon each, and the occasional collision between two or more of them. The second sequence shows a meteor shower, with each of the meteors represented by a single, scantily-clad woman, a thin path of meteorite dust trailing above her head.

We then return to the exploits of the bumbling Professor of Astonomy, as he, overly-excited by the remarkable spectacle he has just witnessed, accidentally steps out the window and plummets head-first into a water barrel. The children laugh at his misfortune, proceeding to beat him mischievously with pillows, as the other teachers try awkwardly to warm him with blankets. An imaginative little film from an early master of imagination.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Solid Melies
gavin694219 April 2015
An astronomer of age, wealth, and erudition conducts classes in his home. His students are not always respectful, and he suffers their pranks and high jinks. Then, at noon, everything darkens and the astronomer hurries upstairs to his telescope. It is an eclipse of the sun, and through his glass, he sees a female moon coming toward a masculine sun, flirting as they move closer to what becomes a consummation...

As others have noted, this is not Melies' best work. It is still a fine film, with more than its share of humor. And quality-wise, it has held up much better than "A Trip to the Moon" (1902) and looks as clean and clear as any modern film.

If possible, catch this film live. The patio in Chicago played it in April 2015 with Jay Warren on the organ. This completely changes the way the film is experienced when you get that in-house sound.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Ecstatic Eclipse
Cineanalyst3 February 2008
The eclipse scene is certainly this film's most provocative point of interest. As usual in Méliès's films, the sun and moon appear with human faces, but what's curious is that the film quite clearly depicts the eclipse as an act of sex. The expressions of delight and orgasm from the feminine moon, in addition to the increased movement of the sun's rays from behind, leave viewers without doubt about that. This scene is followed by scenes of wandering stars and a meteor shower, with, again, as usual of Méliès, people as part of the celestial bodies. Originally, as John Frazer has pointed out ("Artificially Arranged Scenes"), this was the entirety of the film. It appeared as part of multi-media programs at the Folies Bergère. For this market, the sexualized eclipse was surely appropriate and appreciated. Méliès had already been doing well with commissions from music halls for his films, such as "The Adventurous Automobile Trip" and "The Merry Frolics of Satan".

Apparently, it was for adding the film to his general film catalogue that Méliès added the wrapper of the astronomy class. For what it is, it isn't bad, with Méliès playing the professor, who is made fun of by his students and by his own overexcitement. Overall, "The Eclipse" displays fantastical and theatrical elements typical in Méliès's oeuvre. Unlike some of his earlier films, however, dissolves don't dominate as transitions and the continuity, aided by title cards, is more modern and somewhat cinematic rather than the overly theatrical tableau vivant style. The transition from the eclipse scene to the wandering stars is especially good, as it's moving scenery of clouds that seems like, but is not, a dolly, or downward crane into the clouds. Méliès had previously moved scenery and props to the effect of seeming like the camera moved, which it very rarely, if ever, did in Méliès's films, but this instance is a rare example of its use as a transition between scenes. Moreover, by this time, the theatrics in Méliès's films had become more elaborate. The moving scenery and performers stringed to stars and planets, as well as the three-layered cinematic multiple exposure effect for the meteor shower bare evidence of this.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Sex Education
wes-connors19 July 2012
Warning: Spoilers
A white-bearded teacher dressed somewhat like a wizard informs his students of an imminent eclipse. He uses a chalkboard to illustrate the path of the sun and the moon. The students do not seem very excited. The teacher provides telescopes to the class, and there is more interest. He goes to watch the eclipse on an upper level. Hopefully, the teacher doesn't think this will get him a closer look. We see the eclipse through the teacher's lens. A feminine-looking Moon passes in front of a masculine-looking Sun. The Moon seems aroused. The Sun looks like it has a headache. Still, the forces of nature bring them together. Later, many little celestial objects are born. Lastly, the teacher loses his senses.

****** L'eclipse du soleil en pleine lune (1907) Georges Melies ~ Georges Melies
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Pretty Erotic
Hitchcoc18 November 2017
Hey guys! The moon is female. The scientists are all excited about an upcoming eclipse. A host of them bring their telescopes to report on and enjoy the event. The first part is the only interesting one. When the moon (which has a female face) goes in front of the Sun, there is some hanky panky going on. They react in a sexual manner. Yes, it certainly surprised me. The remainder of film created a galaxy of tiresome images. It isn't that they were poorly painted, but how many times have we seen a woman lounging on a crescent moon. It's kind of wild but repetitive.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Wonderful fun from Méliès, but not his best effort
planktonrules2 September 2006
I love the short films of Méliès, though in his day, a nine minute film like this one was actually considered "full length". They are wonderful for their clever writing, amazing and adorable sets, trick cinematography and coherence. While I am sure there are some out there who would disagree, I think his comedies of the 1900s are actually better and more watchable and amazing today than many of the comedies by Keystone of the 1910s. While Arbuckle and Chaplin's early stuff is very, very rough and almost plot less at times (it did improve), a full decade earlier Méliès was making wonderful gems like Le Voyage dans le Lune, Barbe-Bleue and this film.

While L'Éclipse du soleil en pleine lune isn't the best film he made, it certainly gets very high marks for its camera-work and its laughs (particularly at the end). So, even though it starts off kind of slow, stick with it--it definitely improves.

If you want to see this film online, go to Google and type in "Méliès" and then click the video button for a long list of his films that are viewable without special software.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Porn Stars
JoeytheBrit14 November 2009
Unlike most other reviewers of this film I found it quite dull, and wondered as I watched, whether it was around this time that Melies began losing touch with the development of the motion pictures. As filmmakers became more confident of their own abilities and that of their equipment more realistic stories set in real locations became more commonplace, but Melies was still staging his films against painted backdrops and producing the same kind of stories he was making in 1902.

The most remarkable thing about this film is the eclipse itself in which it is obvious that the movement of the sun and moon is equated with the act of sex. It would look like a cheap laugh if it was made today, but to see it in a film more than 100 years old is quite extraordinary. Apart from this sequence, the film's scenes last too long and the comedy isn't really that funny even by the standards of the early 20th century.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The screen's first gay love scene??
David-24026 April 2003
In this marvellous Melies fantasy, an eccentric astronomer is overwhelmed by excitement at the approaching eclipse. His students make fun of him initially but then become excited too as the moon approaches the sun.

Through the astronomer's telescope we see the man in the moon winking at the man in the sun. Both begin to lick their lips and wriggle their tongues with excitement as they draw closer together. Finally the sun goes behind the moon, and the man in the moon's face suggests orgasm!!

Finally they part again looking exhausted and satisfied. And the sky explodes in an orgy of sperm-like stars, each one carrying a scantily clad woman or man.

Surely this must be the first gay love scene ever put on film. It's hard to believe it's happening in a 1907 movie. You've gotta see it to believe it.

Great mix of gorgeous special effects, slapstick comedy and eroticism. One of Melies best!
15 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Méliès' weaker moon movie
Horst_In_Translation31 August 2017
Warning: Spoilers
"The Eclipse: The Courtship of the Sun and Moon" is a black-and-white silent film from 1907, even if you will find a few versions where they added sound or color afterward. But if you look at the year, you know what to expect here. And at the maker as Méliès was really the number 1 filmmaker during this really early era for the movies. I personally would say that these nine minutes here are not among his best and certainly not on par with his most known moon movie. It sure was a frequent subject back then and this fascination should go on for a long time afterward mounting in the race to space even. Okay drifting away now, no pun intended. And even if I did not like it that much overall, I think it is interesting to see how they are moments and scenes that may have inspired comedies in the century to follow. Oh yeah let me say that I watched the 9-minute version. I see there is also one at 6. Overall, really only the most hardcore silent film fans and Méliès fans should give this one a look. Even if it is among the master's most known works as of today, I believe a great deal of his gigantic body of work is superior to this one here and that's why I give it a thumbs-down.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An Odd & Interesting Méliès Feature
Snow Leopard10 November 2004
One of a number of oddities in the filmography of Georges Méliès, this feature combines an offbeat story with an array of visual effects to create an interesting, if strange, one-reel film. Most of the visual effects are close to Méliès's usual standard, and on the few occasions when they are not, it is usually the idea that is uninteresting, as opposed to the execution being faulty. Only on a couple of occasions do some of the seams show; the rest of the time Méliès's craftsmanship makes the best use of his resources.

The narrative intertwines two subplots, both of which are unusual in different ways. The main story shows a distinguished professor who is trying to teach astronomy to a group of eager but restless students. This is sandwiched around some sequences that depict the activities of various celestial bodies, which are given quasi-human personalities.

The scenes of the professor and his students consist mostly of slapstick, which is of uneven quality but has some good moments. The middle sequence has a weird courtship scene between a female moon and a male sun (both of whom are remarkably unattractive, for whatever reason), followed by a weird and suggestive succession of images of the activities of some other anthropomorphic astronomical objects.

The individual visual effects are not always particularly impressive, but the sequence as a whole lends itself to all kinds of possible responses and speculations. There are probably a lot of different ways that you could take it, depending on whether you were a Freudian, a Jungian, or a devotee of some other school of psychology.

All of this makes the movie not really one of Méliès's best or most impressive efforts, but it's certainly unusual. He had quite an imagination, and when he gave free rein to it, the results were always interesting, if nothing else.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Melies' Inventiveness Meets Salaciousness In Eclipse
CitizenCaine24 November 2012
Warning: Spoilers
By the time this film was released in 1907, Melies best days were behind him according to most film historians. However, this may be the only Georges Melies film requiring a PG-13 rating at least. The film is bookended with some comical sidelights about a stuffed shirt lecturer played by Melies who interacts (not always with aplomb) with a bunch of rowdy students who eventually do seem genuinely interested in viewing the subject matter at hand: an eclipse. Once again, the special effects of Melies are wonderful, first an eclipse in the form of human faces superimposed on images of the sun and moon, then some of the other heavenly bodies appear (literally!) like Venus, etc., followed by what appears to be a meteor shower. As some reviewers have noted, the eclipse scene is jaw-dropping for its time with its obvious eroticism, and unlike most of the rest of Georges Melies' films, you may want to remove children from the room when viewing this film. *** of 4 stars.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Fun Film from Melies
Michael_Elliott16 August 2012
The Eclipse: Courtship of the Sun and Moon (1907)

*** (out of 4)

aka L'éclipse du soleil en pleine lune

A professor (Georges Melies) is trying to teach some unruly students about astronomy and then we cut to the actual title of an eclipse followed by the meeting of stars. THE ECLIPSE is no where near the greatest work of Melies but I still found it to be an interesting film and especially for the special effects. I'm not sure if Melies was going for comedy during the school sequence but it's really not all that funny. I'm not exactly sure what the point was but perhaps Melies just saw some rude kids one day and decided to throw it in for good measure. The real fun starts once we get to space with the actual eclipse sequence looking very good and especially fun. Once again both the moon and sun are given faces and this certainly adds some charm to the picture. As other reviewers have pointed out, I'm not sure if it was Melies goal or not but the sexual nature of the second portion of the film is hard to miss.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed