Wanted: Dead or Alive (1951) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
3/10
Unattractive and unappealing lead!
JohnHowardReid22 November 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Whip Wilson, Fuzzy Knight, Jim Bannon (themselves), Lane Bradford (Utah), Christine McIntyre (Spangles Calhoun), Stanley Price (Meade), Marshall Reed (sheriff), Zon Murray (Mike), Leonard Penn (Taggart), John L. Cason, Kenne Duncan (henchmen), William Fawcett (bartender), Ray Jones, Jack O'Shea.

Director: THOMAS CARR. Screenplay: Harry L. Fraser ("Clint Johnson"). Photography: Ernest Miller. Film editor: Sam Fields. Music: Raoul Kraushaar. Art director: Fred Preble. Set decorator: Harry Reif. Dialogue director: Stanley Price. Set continuity: Mary Chaffee. Assistant director: Melville Shyer. Sound recording: Charles Cooper. Western Electric Sound System. Producer: Vincent M. Fennelly. A Frontier Pictures production for Monogram. Copyright 9 September 1951 by Monogram Pictures Corp. No New York opening. U.S. release: 3 April 1951. No U.K. or Australian theatrical release. 58 minutes.

SYNOPSIS: A U.S. marshal traps a gang of murderers that capture and kill outlaws in order to collect the reward money.

COMMENT: Weak Whip Wilson western. It starts promisingly with some ingeniously edited and atmospherically paced establishing scenes (although the plot is obviously derived from a Wild Bill Elliott western also directed by Thomas Carr), but on the entrance of Wilson himself (a stocky, balding, unattractive lead man with as much personality as a cheap but overworked dentist) interest deteriorates rapidly.

The rest of the cast has almost nothing to recommend it either. Christine McIntyre is an old bat and the lead villain is as dull as dishwater. His henchmen, played by Lane Bradford and some unknown, are a mite more interesting, whilst Jim Bannon does okay as the second lead (he looks and acts a bit like Wild Bill Elliott) and Fuzzy Knight is his usual self (though at least his "comedy" isn't so broad as usual — it's just plain dull).

Action is kept to a minimum and Wilson uses his whip only once — to unseat the villain from his horse at the climax (and then with just about one punch he knocks him out).

The rest of the film is filled with the most trite and clichéd dialogue ("You'd better have something real interesting to say, stranger") shot almost entirely in the same cramped set.

Production values are less than minimal ("The drinks are on the house!" the hostess exclaims after a tame fight scene, at which there is a stampede to the bar comprised of precisely two persons!)

Carr's direction after the first few minutes is steadfastly routine. Some of the exteriors are not badly composed, however, and some effort has obviously been made to make the best of the locations.

But the plot is too familiar, the action too infrequent and too tame, plus the added handicap of the unattractive and unappealing Mr. Wilson.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Another recycled western plot rides again.
horn-527 November 2005
Warning: Spoilers
U.S. Marshals Whip Wilson, Jim Bannon and "Texas" set out to capture a gang that has been collecting on wanted men, "Dead or Alive." The latter are all bought in dead...after the gang has helped them escape prison and a reward has been posted on them. Bringing them in alive won't work, as the escapees might get talky and tell the law who helped them escape in the first place. Whip, with the help of the law, poses as an "escaped" convict named Mason.The latter, fiancé of a girl saloon owner named "Spangles" Calhoun, has been imprisoned on perjured evidence. A reward for "his" (Wilson posing as Mason) capture has been posted. Whip goes to Copper City and "Spangles'" saloon. She, in the law's plot, hides him. The "Dead or Alive" gang, Taggert, Utah, Mike and others, are tipped to "Mason's" hiding place. Bannon gets in with the gang and when they attempt to grab Whip (posing as Mason), all are arrested. As a reward for her help Whip promises "Spangles" to get a full pardon for her lover.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed