A Woman Scorned: The Betty Broderick Story (TV Movie 1992) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
42 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Please don't let that Woman out of Jail!
lambiepie-211 August 2005
Warning: Spoilers
This film is a rarity: A good made for TV movie that is about a woman's relationship.

Many made for TV movies at the time about women and their relationships with family are made very sappy - to pull your heartstrings..but this one was done really well considering it was based on a true story.

What is laid out before you is a totally dysfunctional marriage with two dysfunctional people who had children and lived in the higher end of a California Community. The wife worked at first, put her husband through school and then stayed home to raise the kids, take care of him and the home. When he finally got a fabulous job, a foot into his career and made a standing within the community, he did what many middle aged men of that type would do....dump her.

But this movie lets you know its not so clear cut as that. The wife, Betty, was no picnic during these years. And the husband Dan was no day at the carnival either. They were toxic to each other and didn't realize it. Not until it was too late.

Betty was already emotionally drained and devoid by the time Dan made his move. And Dan was uncaring and selfish long before the money and status came into play - and not just to Betty.

So in comes the new woman, the perfect trophy and that's when all the real problems and emotions burst. Betty cannot let go of the toxin and Dan continuously feeds it. They keep on making horrid decisions for each other until the tragic ending. This is sad indeed.

While I understand the hell Betty went through, the truth is, she killed two human beings and she needs to pay for that. A few decades in jail is not enough for its more that two people dead here. there are three; Dan, Linda and Betty.

Whom do I feel bad for out of this all? The children of course. No mom, no dad, a lot of emotional abuse they will probably never get over. this is a movie with many lessons, many signs, many morals, many directions and for a made for TV film...that is quite an undertaking.
15 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
View on two dimensions
caa82116 September 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Sometimes you have to view a story on two simultaneous dimensions - especially those based upon a "true story." To say the least, one must cringe at the tragedy of two persons murdered in their bed while sleeping. And in this movie, anyone, especially a parent, cannot help but feel the greatest sadness for the turmoil which the Broderick children had to endure.

At the same time, this story also has some areas which have likely been over-dramatized - especially in Birney's Betty character - and on that level, her over-the-top behavior and constant shrieking and yelling are fascinating to view. Despite her outrageousness, you sometimes sympathize with her viewpoint. Her husband, and Stephen Collins' portrayal, present, IF POSSIBLE, someone for whom one feels even less sympathy than for her. I kept wishing that the director would have hired an actor to play Moe from The Three Stooges - and that "Moe" would appear on-scene and proceed to slap Stephen around, pinch his nose, and bop him with a mallet, the way he did to Curly and Larry.

Also fascinating is how, in her middle years, Meredith Baxter has carved a career in t.v. movies, always beset with someone trying to murder her, otherwise bring her harm, or thoroughly to disrupt her life.

Whatever else you might say, however misguided, at least Betty was a woman of action - in contrast to her husband, who needed a cattle prod, or whatever, to liven-up this insipid character.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Actually Quite Entertaining!
Sylviastel28 October 2006
Don't forget to note the other secretary is played by the wonderful Debra Jo Rupp. The film is based on the true story of Betty Broderick who shoots and kills her former husband and his pretty young bride in their bed. Stephen Collins is wonderful as the husband Dan Broderick. I forget who plays the second Mrs. Broderick. Meredith Baxter looks like she is having the time of her life playing a vengeful, spiteful, complicated woman. She should have nailed an Emmy for her performance. The oldest daughter is played by actress Kellie Williams. This film is often played on Lifetime television for women. Betty Broderick is still very much alive and causing trouble in prison. Just remember men, there are wives like Betty out there willing to go to prison rather than being taken for granted. Although Betty was getting paid $16,000 per month in alimony and lived in a beautiful home in San Diego, it's hard to feel sympathy for a woman who was pretty bought off.
5 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Superb performance in a compelling film
waylonsmithers922 July 2004
Meredith Baxter gives a superb performance in this film and its sequel. She captures the cold narcissism of Betty Broderick and manages to play scenes of rage in a surprisingly subtle manner. For example, in the scene in which Betty trashes her ex-husband's house, Meredith approaches the destruction with great nonchalance, which is ultimately more frightening than if she had played it full-on. She taps into the smugness and sense of entitlement that were strong components of Betty Broderick's personality and allowed her to murder two people in cold blood.
21 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Fascinating tragedy - Meredith Baxter is great
phd_travel13 August 2010
Warning: Spoilers
True life murder stories are always the best and this is one of the best minis made of a true life murder. Whoever you feel sympathy for this is just superb from start to finish.

The screenplay is balanced and detailed - not biased towards one side or another. Overall you get a picture of a very real American tragedy where everyone loses in the end. You feel for Betty the terrible injustice of being dumped for a younger model after putting her husband Dan through medical and law school and raising 4 kids. You also feel Betty over reacted and got out of control but yet understand her frustration.

Casting is superb. Meredith acts very well - the tension and anger that she shows on her face is not too much. Who else could play the cheating hubby as well as the then not old Stephen Collins? The actress who plays Linda the 2nd wife is good too - really smug. Pace and direction are great and what they choose to show is fascinating. Dialog is carefully chosen and not melodramatic.

And there are lessons to be learned too - for the man who is thinking of leaving his wife for a younger model and for the wife on how it might just be better to move on.

This is a must see.
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Meredith Baxter is too good!
skarylarry-9340028 February 2022
Meredith Baxter played the role so well, you wanted to kill her! Betty Broderick has to be the worst human being who ever lived! Just miserable! Glad she is rotting in prison! Also, stupid Betty is PRAISING Dan Broderick! What an incompetent attorney she had ( if all of this is true ). This case should never have even went to trial. She was guilty 100%!
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Outstanding Movie and Outstanding Acting
lyndaful28 June 1999
Betty Broderick worked hard as a wife, and Mother, and got a raw deal when her husband of 16 years, Dan, left her for his young, pretty, secretary (Linda). He finally asked for a divorce, and this was the beginning of the end. A betrayed Betty went on the war path, and made Dan's life miserable, which led to her shooting and killing him, and his new bride, Linda. She worked hard for years supporting Dan when he was in law school, and raised their 4 children as well. Excellently portrayed by Meredith Baxter, this movie was fabulous. Part II, her Final Fury, the last chapter was also an excellent movie!
26 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Betty Broderick should never get out of prison.
dsnow-129 July 2009
Warning: Spoilers
If this movie is supposed to make a person have sympathy for Betty Broderick it didn't make me feel sorry for her.

Should have Dan cheated on her, no, but she had no right to murder her ex-husband and his new wife Linda.

I read where Betty said once that she didn't go there to kill them but she was going to shoot herself in front of them. I don't believe her. Was the shooting an accident and was pulling the phone cord out of the wall an accident? Was calling her friend and saying I finally shot him an accident too? Only to someone who wants to make a killer into a victim.

Betty wouldn't listen to her attorneys which is why probably none wanted to take her case. California is a big state I'm sure she could have found a excellent attorney in Los Angeles who would have loved to take her case and take Dan to the cleaners. That's what he deserved but not to be murdered.

All she did was focus on herself with no regards to her kids. She stalked, harassed, and threatened her ex and his wife as if that would somehow solve her problem. All it did was put her in prison where she belongs.
21 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
This movie was biased
msmstik15 July 2005
Mrs. Birney was excellent in her portrayal of Betty Broderick. However, this movie was quite biased as I believe the woman had been driven to the point of insanity when she brutally murdered these people. Who among us today would be strong enough to be drug through the mud the way this man did, leaving her with a less than desirable life, without her children who he had turned against her? This man humiliated this devoted wife time and time again, He was abusive and used his power to overtake her. Sure, the deceased did not deserve to die, but Ms. Broderick did not deserve prison either. A mental home perhaps, but not prison.
17 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
To all the people who justify the Dan Broderick killings
slim_ten24 April 2008
I am sitting here reading these comments and I am appalled. To all of the people who are writing Dan Broderick got what was coming to him. What is wrong with you? What if your son, daughter, sister, brother, mother, and father got murdered in their sleep because they angered someone. Are you even looking at the fact that she called and harassed them every day. Think about it... would you seriously give your ex more money & custody of the kids if they 1.) Ran a door into your house with the kids inside, not even knowing where they were. 2.) Broken into your house not 1 but two times and destroyed everything. 3.) cursed and used profanity at your 9 year old child. No you wouldn't. So he left her BOO HOO! It's a sad day in the world when you justify killing somebody because they made you mad.
19 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Meredith Baxter shines here as a deranged psycho.
Wes4711 July 2016
Warning: Spoilers
This movie was more along the lines of Hitchcock's Psycho than a compassionate biography.

Betty Broderick claimed that her husband used her, abused her, then dumped her for a younger woman. It would make sense for her to file for divorce and try for sole custody. Instead, she inexplicably decides to leave her children with her abuser, and then fight for custody and against the divorce that he filed on her. It makes it difficult for me to believe anything she says.

And nothing Betty Broderick could have experienced justifies tormenting him by setting his clothes on fire, leaving hundreds of obscene messages on his phone, vandalizing his house, and finally going to his house with a gun and "accidentally" killing him.

The fact that Betty Broderick shows no remorse means that she will probably spend the rest of her life in prison, keeping her from becoming a threat to her children.
4 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Betty Broderick was not a battered woman!
BreanneB17 May 2005
Warning: Spoilers
I saw this movie a second time when it came on Lifetime again, recently. I just wanted to say that I cannot believe what I thought before or what I saw. This woman, Betty Broderick was not a battered woman. Yes, she was scorned but that was it. She was also a spoiled, self-centered little brat, who did whatever she wanted, whenever she wanted and thought of no one except herself.

I especially hated hated not only what she did to Dan and Linda, but also the other things she did when the kids were around. I really hated it when she slapped Lee across the face. That was a Christmas present Lee had for her and she tore it open. Unbelievable.

I notice that one person wrote, "Please don't let that woman out of jail." I'm pretty sure they won't because she lacks all of the following: remorse, the taking of responsibility for her crimes, good behavior, etc.
16 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The best example of Lifetime's Golden Era of True Crime
gearedqualitygrowth26 July 2020
This is my favorite "Lifetime" movie of all time, from a production period when the movies were about real crime events and the ensuing trials with quality stars, not the cheesy mass-produced drivel they churn out now. Told in the similar format as a flashback/courtroom docu-drama style of The Tracey Thurmond Story and The Burning Bed, this stars Meredith Baxter and a pre-scandal Stephen Collins, and as a true crime genre and forensic psychology lover, let me tell you, Baxter KILLS it. If you watch interviews with the real Betty Broderick, you will see how Baxter masters her self-deluded, persecution complex, functionally crazy personality. It was probably the best TV movie performance I've ever seen. In real life, Betty Broderick had a lot of supporters and this movie explores that, leaving room for the viewer to make up their own mind. It seems to present things from both sides' fairly--neither party is portrayed as a saint: she did sacrifice everything to make her husband successful and he did seem to trade her in for a newer model when he made it to the top, but the creators still tilt the viewer to the fact that's still not an excuse for murder. There's also the follow-up sequel that covers the court battle, portrayed from the prosecutor's perspective, which is also enjoyable. This is truly a based-on-a-true-story TV movie classic.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Adultery
pjwilliams-771859 September 2021
Betty loved Dan more than she lived herself. After giving her life to Dan so that he can be successful, with hopes one day she can begin to enjoy life. Yet, as it often happens, the successful man forgets the sacrifices that he allowed and insisted the wife take, without realizing that she's being used for a personal purpose that wasn't really love. Dan knew that Linda knew what she was going to get by cheating with him. Murder should not have happened, but I saw the hurt Betty had, she lost her youth to Dan and acted in an immature way because Dan didn't allow her to grow with him. He used her as a pretty young productive machine until got where he wanted to be and found a new Betty to start over again.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
An over-sensationaized account of a dysfunctional marriage
Whitetd120009 August 2012
Warning: Spoilers
This is the story of the real life Betty and her descent into madness, culminating in the murder of her ex-husband and his new, much younger wife. Betty Broderick, a loving mother and dutiful wife, is emotionally shattered when her workaholic husband Dan leaves her for his personal assistant, Linda. After viewing this movie, one is inevitably led to the actual story of the Broderick marriage. Taking both accounts into consideration, one finds that in an effort to attract viewers, the movie glosses over rather important information. The focus of the movie is not on the troubled marriage, but rather Betty Broderick's psychotic behavior. As a result, Betty is written in a rather unsympathetic light. Also, the audience never actually sees Dan physically cheat on Betty with Linda, although he is perhaps emotionally unfaithful. This makes Betty's confrontation seem almost uncalled for. Dan had actually been cheating on Betty on many occasions. As the movie goes on, Dan is more attentive with his children and new bride Linda while Betty's behavior becomes more and more irrational, turning Dan into an almost sympathetic character. In actuality, the Broderick marriage had been emotionally toxic with both partners feeding off of one another, something that is only hinted at in the movie. While movie is powerfully acted, with exceptional performances from Meredith Baxter and Stephen Collins, the audience doesn't quite get an accurate portrayal of the events.
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I love a daytime movie
cassie-fett14 September 2019
My childhood was spent in the 80s/90s and there was nothing more exciting than a daytime thriller!

From the fake footstep sounds to bad acting to the 80s outfits to the outlandish storylines! Love it all!!

This was a brilliant daytime movie based on real events.........and Meredith was an outstanding actress.

A very interesting story to boot....
8 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
The most miserable person who ever existed!
vgingerspice13 February 2021
Warning: Spoilers
A goof not caught: at the beginning of the movie when they are at the soccer game, Dan tells Betty he won a 360,000,000 case in damages and Betty answers, "$260,000,000"? As far as Betty goes, She complains about everything and argues and yells at anything that she feels is wrong, which is EVERYTHING! How did Dan take it for so long? She was such a miserable, rotten human being...THE WORST! She had no way of winning that case. And..she actually thinks she had a right to kill them! Absolutely NO REMORSE! EVEN MOST SERIAL KILLERS HAVE A TINY BIT OF REMORSE! AND WHOEVER HEARD OF SOMEONE RUNNING THEIR VEHICLE THRU SOMEONE'S FRONT DOOR OF THEIR HOUSE? THIS NO-GOOD ROTTEN PERSON SHOULD HAVE BEEN EXECUTED!
1 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Awestruck...
Keedee19 December 2000
"I have regrets but no remorse". I always get chills when I think of Ms. Baxter speaking these words as the character of Betty Broderick, a woman who has just murdered her ex-husband and his new bride. Her portrayal as a neurotic woman, scorned, blows the mind!! She breaks all stereotypes of the wholesome Elise Keaton from the 70's sitcom, Family Ties. She's an awesome actress! It's a very entertaining movie!
21 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Good Movie, Bad Murderer
sh33na4 November 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Betty Broderick is a cold-blooded greedy murderer. I don't care if what she thinks happened, happened. She can play the victim all she wants, but the fact remains that she shot her ex-husband and his wife and left them to die lying in pools of blood.

She confessed to her friend, "I finally shot him." Is that supposed to be payback for being a bad husband? What a sad rationalization that is. I hate to think what she would do her children if they turned on her. Oh, wait. At least one did. Is she safe now, or will Betty say that this child ruined her life by testifying against her and go after her with a gun? Meredith Baxter does a spectacular job of portraying BB. The follow-up movie is even better. These are movies I can watch over and over whenever they are on.

I hope this woman never sees the outside of prison walls. She is a lying, manipulative witch who deserves to die in prison.
9 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Still never gets old - Meredith Baxter just superb
Critic_For_Life4 January 2021
This movie just gets better and Meredith Baxter is so good. I hope Betty Broderick never gets out.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I Like The Movie, But Dan Doesn't Listen To Anyone
IMKidHunni27 February 2023
I like the Movie But I have noticed something about Dan Broderick he doesn't listen to anyone like if they had something important things to say he ignores it

Like Debra Jo Rupp's Character

Alice saying to Dan about him needs to treat all people with respect not to the ones he thinks who is special! Alice asked she be respected & she had to quit cause Linda was getting special treatment & Dan treated Betty the same way he didn't respect her!!!!

Larry (Dan's Brother) He was telling Dan on his wedding day that Betty has told people that she was going kill him & he didn't listen to him either & look what happened?! Betty Shot & Killed Him & Linda

Betty Asked For A ring that she liked for Christmas & he didn't listen to her & got her what she didn't asked for & she didn't like it & I bet when Linda asked for something for Christmas I bet he got it for her!!!! That is how little he thought of Betty he didn't really love her he just used her for putting him through school & he got tired of her & Threw Her Away like she was a bag of garbage!!!!

Linda said to Dan About The Custody Visitation She said to him that she was mentally unstable & she was right & he didn't listen to her!!!! It's Dan's fault for putting whatever he said in the Document he knew that would get her upset & he didn't care on how that would affect her & looked what happened she snapped?!?!

What I'm saying is that Dan didn't listen to anyone!!!!

It was also Linda's Fault she knew he was married & i didn't like how he rather spent his birthday with her & not his wife & kids it was so very inconsiderate of him to do that?! & then lied about not being with Linda for 7 hours?!

I Also don't like that he Manipulated the system on getting things his way like the selling the house even though she doesn't like the price of the house that was selling & that other lawyers was scared of Dan he manipulated other lawyers on Winning a fair settlement against him!!! The friends they both had those so called friends sided with Dan & turned there backs on Betty those aren't friends if they turned there backs on her, friends stick with you even if a couple have been divorced I Don't know if I'm right or not, i don't really know I never been married or divorced but I'm guessing?!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
terrible story belongs on lifetime!!!
hydebee4 January 2007
This is a terrible story. As I sit watching this today on lifetime, I wonder how such a crazy b---- have a movie made about her. The sad thing is the story portrays her as a victim she murdered 2 people but she is the victim? the acting is average or should I say typical Meredith Burney and Stephen Collins, not anything new just the story of how her bad ole hubby abuse her mentally ,so she then gets the right to murder ,yes murder 2 people, give me a break , why lifetime or whoever made this film would waste time and money is beyond me, it reminds me of the world according to garp, where we find a whole little cult waiting to murder whoever they can , fact is it is not interesting nor is it socially deeming in any way, betty should be in jail forever, what she did was murder, and yes her hubby and children paid the price of this mean vengeful b----
0 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I love movies based on true story
nina_60063 February 2021
This story happens all the time in all countries and cultures but in different rates... not every time it has to end in tragedy ... The thing is, regardless of this is a TV movie, but still it was really good and interpret the Betty Broderick story to the audience... I enjoyed every minute of the movie
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
"Bad Publicity"
lavatch8 August 2021
Warning: Spoilers
While this film was based on a true story, the dramatization of Betty Broderick' neurosis was never made credible. Above all, the passive response of her ex-husband Dan was appalling in his failure to use the legal system to constrain his nutty ex.

The biggest stretch was how to believe that a distinguished attorney like Dan Broderick would not take action to enforce multiple restraining orders against his unhinged ex-wife.

But the entire film was filled with incredulous situations, such as the oldest daughter's unwillingness to accept that her mother was a lunatic. Based on the situations, the daughter should have been afraid of this woman.

And where was the law applied to Betty and her outrageous stunts? Even when she plows her car into Dan's house, Betty apparently only receives a slap on the wrist. She should have been in prison.

The saddest part of the story was the fate of Linda Kolkena, the kind secretary of Dan, who eventually married him and was on the receiving end of a bullet courtesy of Betty. From start to finish, the reactions of the mild-mannered Dan Broderick were not plausible. Once, when Linda was desperately pleading with him to take legal action against Betty, his terse response was, "it would be bad publicity" for his law firm.

Despite the good performances, this was a most depressing film experience.
0 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed