El Dorado (1988) Poster

(1988)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Slow road to madness
rogornmoradan24 February 2007
Shot in Costa Rica in 1988, 'El Dorado' is one of a rare breed, a Spanish film about its own role in America in the 16th century. However, this film doesn't tell a story of glory and conquest, but one of failure and slow descent into madness.

The story is about an expedition down the Orinoco river in 1560, undertaken by Spanish soldiers with the aim of finding the famed land of El Dorado, where gold is supposedly plentiful. I suppose that it is not a spoiler to say that the place doesn't exist and that what the expeditioners find is something completely different.

The film is 142 minutes long, and not exactly action-packed, so a prospective viewer should realise that the leisurely pace is meant to reflect the utter boredom provoked by the long and uneventful days in the journey, but these 'dead' days, as in many expeditions, are punctuated by moments of high intensity and tension in which the travellers will have to react to the challenges thrown at them by the jungle... or by themselves. In this sense the film is a study on how to face (or not) insurmountable obstacles in extreme conditions, in particular when greed, pride and lust are thrown into the mix.

The filming on location does half the job for the film-makers. The river and the jungle are like one additional character, and one can feel the stuffy Old-worlders slowly stewing under their heavy shirts and armour as the days pass. I find a bit of fault with the way Lope de Aguirre, the main character, is played. The film goes for understated menace from a quietly unscrupulous man, which ends up adding to the slowness of the film. Of course, that's the director's choice, but I feel that a bit of energy and feeling of danger coming from the villain of the piece would have been welcome.

All in all, it's an effort that meant a lot for Spanish cinema in the 1980s, having been filmed only four years before the 5th centenary of the discovery of America and just a decade into full democracy after the Franco dictatorship. But it if has to be enjoyed, one must come with 'Apocalypto' Mode firmly shut off.
20 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
An expedition formed by Spanish soldiers down the Orinoco and Amazon rivers searching for the fabled city of gold
ma-cortes24 April 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Epic film in big budget produced by great producer Andres Vicente Gomez and well directed by Carlos Saura . It deals with an expedition under command of Pedro Ursua (Lambert Wilson) with various officers (Patxi Bisquert , Eusebio Poncela , Feodor Atkine , Jose Sancho , among others) . The travelers who are over-dressed for the heat in their old world clothes and armour must survive the crises of jungle life and human badness . The river , jungle scenery and several dangers dominate the motley characters in the risked journey . But later on , Lope De Aguirre (Omero Antonutti) takes over the explorers .

Historical and interesting film that contains thrills , intrigue , sword-play , double-crosses and wonderful scenarios . The picture is overlong , 142 minutes long , and has been criticized for its plodding argument , with brief moments of tension when the travelers must survive the risks of jungle life and human frailty . Good performances from Omero Antonutti , who plays this actual historical character with quiet , understated menace , plus : Lambert Wilson , Jose Sancho , Francisco Algora , Francisco Merino and many others . Furthermore , Ines Sastre film debut . Colorful and glimmer cinematography by Teo Escamilla . Evocative score by Alejandro Masso based on Renaissance music and 'Tristan and Isolda' by Richard Wagner . Because of a similarity in plot and characters, the movie suffers by comparison with ¨1972's Aguirre, the Wrath of God¨ , by Werner Herzog but stands on its own as a less fantastic version of the same travel of obsessed adventurers .

The motion picture is well directed by Carlos Saura who also wrote the screenplay , he is a good Spanish movies director. He began working in cinema in 1959 when he filmed ¨Los Golfos ¨(1962) dealing with juvenile delinquency and similarly long time after ¨Deprisa , Deprisa¨ . Saura is a well recognized filmmaker both nationally and internationally, and in proof of it he won many prizes among which there are the following ones: Silver Bear in the Berlin Festival for ¨ La Caza or The Chase¨ (1966) his most successful film , and for ¨Peppermint Frappé¨ (1967), in 1967 . Special Jury Awards in Cannes for ¨La Prima Angélica¨ (1974), in 1973, and for ¨Cría Cuervos¨ (1976), in 1975 . Also, the Award-wining Saura filmed ¨Mamá Cumple Cien Años¨ (1979) and got an Oscar nomination in 1979 as the best foreign film, and it also won the Special Jury Award at the San Sebastian Festival. Saura made several films just a few years before and after the end of Francisco Franco's dictatorship , thus the search for political themes and symbols is mandatory for all . In 1990, he won two Goya , The Spanish Oscar , as best adapted screenplay writer and best director for ¡Ay Carmela! . Saura became an expert on Iberian musical adaptations as ¨Carmen¨ , ¨Amor Brujo¨ , ¨Bodas De Sangre¨ , ¨Sevillanas¨ , ¨Iberia¨ , ¨Salome¨ , ¨Fado¨, ¨Flamenco¨ and even recently Opera as ¨Io , Don Giovanni¨

The picture is based on real incidents , these are the followings : Lope De Aguirre together with his daughter joined the 1560 expedition of Pedro De Ursúa down the Marañón and Amazon Rivers with 300 Spaniards and hundreds of natives ; the actual goal of Ursúa was to send veterans from the former Peruvian civil wars away, to keep them from troublemaking, using the Eldorado myth as a lure . A year later, he participated in the overthrow and killing of Ursúa and his successor, Fernando De Guzmán, whom he ultimately succeeded. He and his men reached the Atlantic , probably by the Orinoco River , destroying native villages on the way. On March 23, 1561, Aguirre urged 186 captains and soldiers to sign an act which would proclaim him as prince of Peru, Tierra Firma and Chile. He is reputed to have said in 1561: I am the Wrath of God, the Prince of Freedom, Lord of Tierra Firme and the Provinces of Chile In 1561, he seized Isla Margarita and brutally suppressed any opposition to his reign, killing many innocent people. When he crossed to the mainland in an attempt to take Panama, his open rebellion against the Spanish crown came to an end. He was surrounded at Barquisimeto, Venezuela, where he murdered his own daughter, Elvira, "because someone that I loved so much should not come to be bedded by uncouth people". He also killed several followers who intended to capture him. He was eventually captured and shot to death. Aguirre's body was cut into quarters and sent to various cities across Venezuela.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The gold rush
jotix10016 June 2009
Warning: Spoilers
We watched this heavy and somber film, directed by Carlos Saura, as it was shown on cable recently. "El Dorado" kept reminding us of better made films such as "Fitzcarraldo", or even "Aguirre, the Wrath of God", both superior films because of the amazing contribution of Klaus Kinski and Werner Herzog to the genre. These two men put to shame what Mr. Saura has done to "El Dorado".

Again, we are taken to Peru, where the conquering Spaniards are searching the legendary gold, the rich commodity that seems elusive to them and the big scale mission undertaken by Ursua and his men. Little prepared these Spanish invaders to what they were really going to have to face in their quest for riches. Alas, the mission for finding the gold is a total failure and El Dorado just another myth, never have been found.

The Europeans only brought their diseases, greed and cruelty to the new world. We wonder how the native culture, in the conquered lands, would have fared if these men who thought they had the power to exterminate and make them practical slaves to their whim, never found them. For one thing, they might have survived better with the customs and rituals they had practiced before the advent of the white man. A lot of suffering would have been spared if these poor natives would have been left alone.

Mr. Saura doesn't add anything new with this film to his otherwise interesting career in the cinema.
4 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Between AGUIRRE and ORO (2017)
searchanddestroy-127 July 2022
There were not so many films about conquistadores in the movie history, not so many; I only know those three. And I stlll search for more material to purchase. This film seems more accurate to the actual truth and details, the preparation was very very meticulous, focusing less on the myth and eerie atmosphere - as Werner Herzog did - than on factual events. ORO was I guess more fiction material, but very interesting too. So, you can watch AGUIRRE and this one, you'll then have two approaches for the same subject. In AGUIRRE, Herzog litterally created this special, suffocating, wet, lethal, madly atmosphere, EXCESS IS THE TRUE WORD, but Carlos Saura used it, so far circumstances of the story allowed him to. He did not abuse of it. Saura was the servant of true facts, of pure history. Very subtle difference between two films speaking of the same subject. In both films - Saura's and Herzog's - Aguirre character is not shown in the same way, though both are ruthless and ambitious. Here Aguirre looks and behaves like a Mafia mob leader, whilst in Herzog"s feature, Klaus Kinski is closer to Colonel Kurtz in Joseph Conrad's HEART OF DARKNESS than Lucky Luciano.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Saura and the conquest
croslip27 January 2015
In the conquest of America, saved more than this gem that reveals the misery, violence and sacrifice, but also the epic adventure .An excellent cast,highlight the Antonutti actors as a martial Aguirre ranging from sanity to madness caused by the feverish lust for gold and embellished by a tangled grandeur and endless forest, well intrigues existing between the characters as Eusebio Ponzela (Guzmán),Lambert Wilson (Ursúa) and José Sancho (La Bandera). Saura mark time creating an oppressive atmosphere that surrounds with men about looking for anything. Do not miss the occasion to see this movie.Thousands of adventures to exploit in particular by the American industry.It is possible to imagine a big budget Spielberg.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed