One or the Other (1974) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Thriller in the academic world
SMK-311 August 1998
Bernd Ziegenhals is a former student who's fallen on hard times. When carrier-socialist Hohenberg, one of his former fellow students, offers him a research job (some literature work) he's by no means thrilled but takes the job as he needs the money and has nothing else to do anyway. This decision would change his life: when comparing different sources in the literature he discovers that Professor Kolczyk got his degree by cheating, by translating somebody else's work from English to German and presenting it as his own.

Starting from here the film goes through a sequence of mostly surprising twists and turns, beginning with Ziegenhals blackmailing the Professor. Kolczyk is no pushover though and knows how to fight back (the novel on which the film script is based was written by a professor of sociology under pseudonym).

The battle between the protagonists is set against their different social backgrounds: Kolczyk is all-established upper middle class, with a nice wife, a nice house and nice kids; Ziegenhals lives in a shared flat, and there's very little nice about his life - one of his friends, the prostitute Miezi gets murdered by her former pimp Proetzel when he's released from jail. What makes the film particularly interesting is that neither Kolczyk nor Ziegenhals is interested in an out-and-out confrontation since the main objective of both is to protect or escape their current life style.

This is an excellent movie: the suspense never falters and it is very difficult to predict the next moves of either Kolczyk or Ziegenhals (or the script) - also the ending comes as a real surprise. All this is helped by generally excellent performances from the cast, in particular the two leads Prochnow and Schwarzkopf; the cast is full of established German character actors who each could carry a film on their own and in such an ensemble it's a doddle for them.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Thrilling crime story
chandler-4719 January 2006
Based on a crime novel by Horst Bosetzky (-ky) this is one of Wolfgang Petersen's first cinema productions. The student Bernd Ziegenhals discovers that one of the professors at university has faked his doctoral thesis and blackmails him. The plot is thrilling because the professor does not stay passive, he tries to get rid of Ziegenhals. Who of them will survive at the end?

The movie is much better than the novel (which is very rare). The end is surprising and also different to the novel. I'm wondering if Petersen is thinking about a Hollywood remake of this film. The plot has a lot of potential and with better special effects than it was possible in 1974 it could be a winner.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A German approach on New Hollywood
Vinne13 April 2004
This is a great early film by director Wolfgang Petersen and in my opinion, it is the closest Germany ever got to the "New Hollywood Style" of that time. The atmosphere of the West-Berlin locations are captured perfectly in this raw and intelligent thriller, and the city looks different as in any other film it has been shown. Many of the actors and crew members were at the very beginning of their careers when they starred in this picture, especially the young Jürgen Prochnow and Otto Sanders give great performances. Too bad it's not available on DVD, it's definitely one of those films that aged very well and should get a proper anniversary release. 9/10
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
A typical mediocre 1970s film Warning: Spoilers
"Einer von uns beiden" or "One or the Other of Us" is a West German movie that runs for almost 100 minutes and came out over 40 years ago. The star here is probably the director, Wolfgang Petersen, who made this one while still in his 30s, about a decade before "Das Boot", his most known work and his star in that one is also in here: Jürgen Prochnow, even if it is arguable if he is the lead actor here too. At least he is not the one billed first in the cast. If you have seen some 1970s movie and I am really speaking more about American films here than German films, then you will realize that there are certainly many elements in here that you also find in the works of Gene Hackman from that time for example. "Einer von uns beiden" is based on a novel by Horst Otto Oskar Bosetzky and Manfred Purzer, still alive today (2016), is the one who adapted it. The movie received some awards attention at the German Film Awards: Peterson won for Best New Director and the cinematography won as well. Lead actor Klaus Schwarzkopf was "only" nominated for Lead Actor as the awards went to Gustav Rudolf Sellner for the Academy Award nominated "Der Fußgänger". But back to this one: Overall, I thought there were some good moments, but it just wasn't enough to keep me interested for 1 hour and 40 minutes and the story had some struggles in terms of realism, especially looking at the character's actions. And sadly, a problem that was frequent during that era, the issue of overacting, is also a factor here. I am not sure if you can blame the actor for doing it or the director for allowing it. That's why I believe that in the end the bad outweighed the good and I do not recommend the watch.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed