A Bullet for Rommel (1969) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Uneven Italian War Adventure
SgtSlaughter22 February 2003
A pretty familiar and simplistic action piece from Leon Klimovsky, with a decent cast and little else of value.

Jack Palance stars as an American commando officer, who must lead commandos on a strange mission behind-the-lines in France. None of the men know the complete plan, so they basically wander around from place to place confusing the enemy until a big, booming climax.

The film features an acceptable cast, with Jack Palance in the lead as a gutsy commander. Unfortunately, just like Michael Rennie in COMMANDO_ATTACK Palance is a 1 dimensional character with no personality. Some scenes, in which he curses at suboordinates sound incredibly corny and every time he gives a command he yells "Give 'em all ya got!" Mankiewicz has no writing talent, and Palance never comes to life. Andrea Bosic from BATTLEFORCE tries hard as one of the commandos, as does Gerard Tichy (LAST DAY OF THE WAR) as an Anti-Hitler German General. We've also got Mirko Ellis (BATTLE OF THE COMMANDOS) in a small and heroic role as an American commando. Wrap up the cast with Giuseppe Addobbati (THE BATTLE OF EL ALAMEIN) as an American officer and Alberto de Mendoza as a German double agent, who constantly switches sides.

The combat scenes are very well-filmed, with lots and lots of explosions, bullet ricochets, familiar M48 tanks and lots of extras falling down and dying. The weapons used here are Italian Beretta submachine-guns (like in BATTLE OF THE COMMANDOS) which does take away from what little realism there is.

Cinematography is actually pretty good, and the countryside looks a lot like France. The musical score by Armando Trovajoli is a pretty mournful sounding score, and doesn't fit the mood of the movie until the last 5 minutes or so.

I really don't like this film much despite all the good stuff it's got going for it. Mankiewicz and his writers didn't do a very good job with the script; there's a lot of boring dialog and not much else. It's pretty pro-war and fun until the last 10 minutes or so, which stresses the human cost and waste of life. There are a few interesting plot twists, though, which kept me awake.

I'm actually not sure what version of this film I saw. It's a dub from what I believe is a VHS from Saturn, due to the decent color transfer, background audio hiss and occasional dropouts. It's a transfer of identical quality to their release of DESERT COMMANDO.

All in all, this isn't a great film nor is it bad. It's got a good cast, fair action sequences, and decent production values but a pretty boring script and little originality.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Standard War movie or perhaps Substandard
YDontULeaveLibs20 May 2006
Warning: Spoilers
This movie is great for probably none of the reasons that the makers of the movie intended. The beginning has a documentary kind of feeling. Then it moves on to feeling like a spoof of war movies. It goes on to suspense. At this part I am watching now Palance says "Lets put the pieces of the puzzle together." So now it is a mystery like Scooby Doo. And now the build up to the final battle this is the best part of the movie. The movie is unintentionally funny with the seriousness the actors take on their roles vs the trite writing. But, the ending is disappointing turns into a sermon about the value of human life. The sermon may have had more impact had there been enough character development to leave one with a feeling of lose when a character was killed.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Spaghetti/Paella War film co-produced by Italy/Spain about a reckless commando assigned a dangerous mission behind enemy lines
ma-cortes26 December 2016
During World War II, a tough officer Major John Heston (Jack Palance) is assigned by Gen. Moore (Giuseppe Addobbati as John Douglas) to organize a commando raid into Germany . Heston leads a group of expert officers on a risked as well as strange assignment , these are the followings : Captain Agamemnon Geeves (Andrea Bosic) , Lt.Steve Bloom (John Gramack) , Capt.Stuart Latimore (Carlos Estrada) , Lt. Thomas Mulligan (Antonio Pica) , Lt.Robert Mills (Mirko Ellis) . The relentless and complex assignment is set against strong training , risked adventures and hazardous feats . The mission: search out Rommel (Manuel Collado and his wife played by Maruchi Fresno) and to destroy enemy , after the D-Day invasion . The volunteer commandos , misfits from the American army do not care how its done and will run over anyone who gets in their way .

Jack Palance as Major Heston assumes the character of commando leader in this ordinary wartime movie regularly directed by Leon Klimovsky . This moving film packs frantic thrills , perilous adventures , relentless feats , and buck-loads of explosive action and violence . The noisy action is uniformly well-made , especially deserving of mention the rip-roaring final scenes in which the motley group is really besieged , including some spectacular shootouts and bombing . The first half of the film allows the colorful cast of character actors to have their fun as they get their tails whipped into shape and develop shaky relationship with their leader . The final part is all action , as the brave commando wreak havoc and then run for their lives . Apart from the values of team spirit , cudgeled by Palance into his misfit group , the film is full of feats , suspense , and thrills . Rough Jack Palance is leader of the motley pack together thwart the Nazi schemes , he gives an overacting and puts faces and grimaces . Palance dominates this adventure war with his hysterical performance as a merciless officer with only one thirst : to carry out the dangerous and puzzling mission . Palance played several exotic/historical characters in ¨The Silver Chalice¨, ¨Attila¨ , ¨Rosmunda and Alboino¨, ¨The horsemen¨ , ¨Barrabas¨, ¨The Mongols¨ , among others . As well as the largely secondary cast formed by a lot of Spanish/Italian secondaries , all of them ordinary from Peplum and Western such as: Antonio Pica , Mirko Ellis , Carlos Estrada , Alberto De Mendoza , Gérard Tichy , Rosanna Yanni and with special mention for Jesus Puente as nasty German General . This one belongs to Klimovski's trilogy about WWII , including tarnishing Hollywood stars , such as ¨The legion of no return¨ with Tab Hunter , and ¨Command attack¨with Michael Rennie . Atmospheric and functional musical score by Armando Trovajoli , adding an attractive but repetitive leitmotif . Mediocre cinematography in Eastmancolor filmed by Vicente Minaya , a perfect remastering is extremely necessary . Being filmed on location in Casa de Campo, Madrid , Getafe airport , Getafe , Madrid, Navacerrada mountains , and Pelayos de la Presa , Madrid, Spain . This is a wartime typical vehicle and into the ¨warlike commando genre¨ , in USA style which also belong the American classics as : ¨Dirty Dozen (Robert Aldrich) ¨ Where eagles dare(Brian G. Hutton) and Kelly's heroes(Hutton), Tobruk (Arthur Hiller) , Devil's Brigade (Andrew V McLagen) and many others .

The motion picture was middlingly directed by Leon Klimovsky . This Argentina born but nationalized Spanish filmmaker was a craftsman who directed all kind genres , as Terror for Paul Naschy (Marshall of hell , Rebellion of dead one , Orgy of vampires , Werewolf shadow,Dr Jekill vs. the werewolf) , Warlike (June 44 attack force Normandy, A bullet for Rommel, Bridge over Elba) and Western (Badland drifter , Some dollars for Django , Torrejon city , Death knows no time, Two thousand dollars for Coyote). Rating: 5 ; regular but entertaining.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
I think this film is very funny
michael7916 July 2000
I taped most of this film from a late night show a few years ago but I wish it would come on again. It is a serious film that turns out sort of un-serious. The way all the German soldiers get shot the same way and have to do the obligatory summersault before "dying". Jacks German helmet was too big and with the coat a few sizes too small makes him look like one of the three stooges.One incident when Jack is shot by a machine-gun he catches just one bullet dead center of his arm - what incredible luck!yea right. I love this movie!
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
HELL'S BRIGADE (Leon Klimovsky, 1969) **1/2
Bunuel197619 February 2010
Among the numerous low-brow WWII adventures to emerge from Europe around this time, the film under review also proved one of Jack Palance's not infrequent across-the-water excursions; typically, the film comes with several titles – the misleading Spanish original translates to ZERO HOUR: OPERATION ROMMEL (even if the Field Marshall does figure prominently in the narrative, his role in the failed July plot to assassinate the Fuehrer and his eventual suicide, thus bringing to mind the similar but inferior UCCIDETE ROMMEL from the same year), the Italian one (its co-producing country) to the generic THE CRY OF GIANTS and, for English-speaking consumption, it ended up with the imitative moniker given above! Anyway, the movie presents a typical 'impossible mission' scenario with the lock-jawed star as the cynical leader of a specialized outfit parachuted behind enemy lines; the group even includes a German officer(!) and, when they purposefully crash the plane, are also joined by the pilot. What is unusual – but also rather silly in the long run, given its pointlessness – is that each member of the squad has a specific function to perform which, however, is known only to himself…so that each of them is constantly, albeit unnecessarily, looking over one another's back!; for obvious reasons, the former Nazi is especially suspected in this regard, even more so when his instructions dictate for him to return to the fold (to further complicate matters, he meets his sweetheart – played by Rosanna Yanni – just then, and she takes him for a traitor to their cause of fighting the Hitler dictatorship)! Eventually, it turns out that Palance and his men were intended to divert enemy attention from a strategic point to another location – so that the German forces are deployed to this other section of the battle zone, thus facilitating the Allies' entry; the military-minded Colonel in command initially objects to the move given their opposition only involves five men – but another officer embroiled with the Nazi hierarchy imposes his will, once the ruse is discovered, to his ultimate chagrin. The combination of expected ingredients – plenty of action (where the expertise at baseball of one of them comes in handy when throwing hand-grenades during the final enemy onslaught!) and hard-boiled dialogue (most amusingly, when Palance complains about the terrible quality of the cigarette he is smoking while a bullet is being removed from his arm sans anaesthetic) – and novelty aspects (the obstacles, eventually surmounted, to camaraderie already mentioned and the suspense inherent in the jigsaw-puzzle structure) make it a mildly enjoyable offering as these things go.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
"Spaghetti War Movie"
scheelj16 April 2012
Skip it – You've heard of "spaghetti westerns." Behold the "spaghetti war movie." Also known as "Hell's Brigade" or "The Battle Giants," the title is misleading because the mission has nothing to do with assassinating Rommel. During WWII, a small group of commandos disguise themselves as German soldiers and parachute behind enemy lines. The objective of the mission is unknown to the soldiers, but each of them is given their own specific task. They must put together the pieces of the puzzle while causing mayhem behind enemy lines. While the battle scenes near the end are entertaining, it's hard to overlook the rest of the movie, which is confusing, poorly made, and corny. 3.5 out of 5 action rating.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Has enough to make it watchable, but felt rather bland
TheLittleSongbird21 June 2015
Jack Palance was reason enough to see any film, and he was my reason for watching The Fall of the Giants. The film is not great and could have been much better too, but it is also not bad at all, certainly much better than Legion of the Damned(aka Battle of the Commandos), another war film starring Palance made at a similar time.

The Fall of the Giants looks good, while the photography is not mind-blowing it is hardly low-budget TV quality either, the sets are handsome and reasonably authentic in alternative to limited, the scenery with the countryside, woods and rivers is truly stunning and the editing is coherent and above average. Not all the costumes work though, with the helmets looking like over-sized pottery and Palance's uniform looked like it had shrunk a few sizes in the wash overnight. The music score is appropriately rousing and melancholic, and fits with the film quite well. The story is reasonably well-paced with some nice turns and remains interesting until the final 10 minutes, the battle scenes are appropriately tense(as is the build up to the final battle) and coherently edited and the direction gets the job done competently. The performances are good on the whole, with fine support from Andrea Bosic and John Grammack, Mirko Ellis in suitably heroic mode and Gerard Tichy brings authority to his General character.

As great an actor Palance was, this is not one of his best performances here. He gives his absolute all and he certainly commands the screen well, but it did feel like he was trying too hard(think his hard-nosed performance in Legion of the Damned except even less subtle) and it felt out-of-kilter at times with the rest of the film. The conclusion could have been powerful and moving, instead it went down the human sermon route and dealt with it very heavy-handedly, and that the characters are very one-dimensional, one-note and underdeveloped in the film(as well as drifting in and out) makes it less easy to really care for the ending or for them. Where The Fall of the Giants really falls down is the very pedestrian script that lacks any kind of pace or nuance and the dialogue is constantly corny and trite.

Overall, not bad with clearly some effort and professionalism gone into it, but rather bland. 5/10 Bethany Cox
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Above-Average World War II Actioneer in the "Where Eagles Dare" Tradition
zardoz-132 January 2010
Warning: Spoilers
"Attack Force Normandy" director León Klimovsky's "Hell's Brigade: The Final Assault" sends Jack Palance with a quartet of robust American officers masquerading as Wehrmacht soldiers behind enemy lines deep in the heart of Germany on a secret mission. This entertaining but far-fetched Spanish/Italian World War II thriller is ostensibly about a conspiracy to kill Hitler involving Field Marshal Erwin Rommel. As contrived as this formulaic saga is, the screenplay by "Companeros" scribes Massimo De Rita & Arduino Maiuri, "Battle of the Last Panzer" writer José Luis Merino, and Manuel Sebares of "Hell Commandos" deals with the dire necessity of following orders without question during war-time to achieve an objective. Indeed, few World War II movies emphasize this military cliché as strenuously as "Hell's Brigade" does to the point that nothing our heroes do appears improvised, no matter how impulsive their behavior. Klimovsky stages the bullet-riddled action with sufficient competence while "The Valachi Papers" composer Armando Trovajoli provides a charismatic orchestral score to accompany the heroics.

Anybody who can dismiss obvious errors in military equipment and uniform insignia may find this pugnacious, larger-than-life actioneer entertaining. The insubordinate sermon delivered by Palance at fade-out to his commanding general about the ideals worth dying for in war is pretentious but well-intentioned. Face-to-face with a newly decorated two-star general, Major John Heston observes, "There will always be different ideals, general, and I suppose men who will die for them. At least, until they (the military) stops giving medals and promotions in exchange for men's lives." Whereas many World War II combat films of the 1960s concentrated solely on one side, "Hell's Brigade" alternates between the Allies on their mission and the Germans as they try to thwart them. Basically, this movie qualifies as a traditional World War II opus. Not only do the Americans refrain from trying to kill their own superior officer, but also the Gestapo are shown as the greater of two evils. Klimovsky and his four scenarists depict the military-minded German officers with notable sympathy, and they present Rommel as a martyr sacrificed for a cause. Furthermore, Klimovsky orchestrates two significant set-pieces: a massacre aboard a German train as well as a full-blown battle sequence at the end.

When he briefs them, Major John Heston (Jack Palance of "Shane") informs the four officers selected for this mission because each possesses an "excellent memory" and they all speak German. According to Heston, the mission's objective is to contact the German military leaders who want to overthrow Adolf Hitler and bring the war to an end. "Before I go any further," Heston advises them, "let me stress that this is a particularly dangerous mission." Nevertheless, not even Heston knows the overall plan, just the general outline. He hands out sealed envelopes containing their separate orders. "Once you've read these instructions, you will be obliged to see the mission through to the end." Heston confesses that "if I were in your shoes, I'd refuse without hesitation. The commandos that he will supervise include Captain Agamemnon Geeves (Andrea Bosic of "The Greatest Battle"), Lieutenant Steve Bloom (John Gramack of "Kill a Dragon"), Captain Stuart Latimore (Carlos Estrada of "The Tyrant of Castile") and Lieutenant Thomas Mulligan (Antonio Pica of "Mission Phantom"). No sooner has Heston completed his briefing than we find our heroes aboard a C-47 transport plane flying over enemy country. The first thing that surprises Heston's men is the revelation that a German officer, Major Hermann Traniger (Alberto de Mendoza of "Gunman of Ave Maria"), is accompanying them as the sixth man on the mission. Initially, the Americans object to the presence of a Nazi, but Heston explains that Trangier is essential to the mission. Trangier will infiltrate the German Army where they are going to serve as their liaison. After Heston's men accept Trangier, they bail out. Before he jumps, Heston follows his orders and pushes a red button by the door that blows off the tail section of the C-47. The pilot, Lieutenant Robert Mills (Mirko Ellis of "Battle Force"), has to jump, too. No sooner has Mills landed than a German patrol captures him. Under interrogation, he cracks and reveals that contacting Rommel constitutes part of the mission. What Mills has no way of knowing is that General Moore, who devised the mission, meant for this to happen. Our heroes proceed to halt a train and liberate a number of high-ranking officers implicated in the Hitler bomb plot. During the assault on the train, Heston catches a bullet in the arm. Meanwhile, Trangier contacts Rommel with a microfilm message with instructions for leaving Germany and finding asylum in a neutral country. Heston and his men wipe out the heavily fortified Kesselberg Pass and halt a Panzer attack.

If you're a hard-core European World War II movie fanatic, you will loathe the VHS copy of this above-average actioneer. The Interglobal Home Video release presents the widescreen action (2.35.1) in full frame (1.33.1) so often you see only the space between the two individuals having a conversation. Occasionally, you can tell Klimovsky set-up two cameras for the massive final battle because the same stunt man performs an acrobatic forward flip. As usual, the M-48 tanks stand in for actual German tanks. Remember, virtually all of Hitler's war equipment was either destroyed or stuck in a museum so Klimovsky, like so many World War II movie makers has to resort to anachronistic equipment, but most casual viewers either won't care or won't know the difference. One thing that makes "Hell's Brigade" stand out is the number of tanks that were used. Since this combat epic was produced before the advent of computer generated special effects, you know that the filmmakers must have called on the use of some government's tanks because there is simply no way that this medium budget melodrama could afford this extravagance. Altogether, "Hell's Brigade: The Final Assault" is a good, but far from great, World War II adventure.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
ONE MAJOR PROBLEM
endlessrain26 August 2004
Competent war film for its time. The story is OK though pretty generic.

Palance puts in his usual performance of sneering, preening and making weird faces at the camera, rasping out the dialogue.

However... this movie has one serious flaw that should have been foreseen from the very beginning...

The major drawback is that the helmets all look like they are made of clay of something. The sight of Jack Palance running around a war zone with a massive piece of pottery on his head is one of the funniest sights i have ever seen. It ruins (or makes) the movie, depending on your perspective.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed