Hate for Hate (1967) Poster

(1967)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
`How does it feel knowing you only have seconds to live?'
iaido13 September 2001
Very solid and straightforward entry into the Spaghetti Western genre. Lacks some of the off kilter atmosphere and inventive action of a stylish Sergio Leone or Sergio Corbucci picture, but, despite this, still manages to entertain with decent story, characters, a good villain, and dingy locations. Notably co-written by Italian film stalwarts Bruno Corbucci and Fernando Di Leo, and directed by the well-rounded Domenico Paollela.

Scruffy, good-natured, and free spirited Miguel just wants to go to New York and be an artist, and makes his money by dealing with a one-legged, underworld figure named Coyote. Cooper is an older family man, ashamed of being an outlaw, storing his loot so he can move his wife daughter away from the life he has fallen into, and he has the misfortune of having a cutthroat partner named Moxon. Cooper and Miguel cross paths when Cooper and Moxon rob the bank in which Miguel has been keeping his New York money. After slaughtering the bank tellers, Moxon tries to double cross Cooper during their escape, only to be thrown off the wagon and down the rocky mountainside. Miguel stops Cooper, only wanting his NY money, but unfortunately this polite exchange pins Miguel to Cooper as his accomplice, and the two are captured. Miguel is cleared and set free, promising Cooper that he will look in on his wife and daughter. Cooper on the other hand is sentenced to life with hard labor, stuck chest deep in a filthy marsh and interrogated as to the whereabouts of his loot. Moxon, bloodied and mean, gathers himself from the hillside and goes back to his gang of thugs.

It is after this setup that the film kicks into gear, with the surviving Moxon stealing back the loot and taking Cooper's daughter and wife, Cooper contracting a fatal case of malaria and escaping from jail, and Miguel having to eke out a living again (he doesn't get his NY money back) and deal with Moxon's gang, who is going after Coyote and his associates. So, in typical fashion, paths cross again, and the revenge fueled Cooper and feisty Miguel go after the cold-hearted Moxon and his gang, battling it out in the usual dilapidated locales of most Spaghetti Westerns. Its a ‘good' film, by a capable director, with defined characters, maybe a little sparse or bland in the action department, cinematography/settings were good, as well as the music (although could do without the bouncy , annoying `La Cucaracha' melody in one repeated theme). A nice film all around. Well worth a look. 7/10.
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"You're a traitor, so I kill you once more".
classicsoncall29 July 2016
Warning: Spoilers
At times uneven, the story here bogs down a bit during the second half, but is generally a decent one if you're paying attention. The filmmakers had some problems with continuity issues however, a big one being the huge gash that appears on Moxon's (Mirko Ellis) face when he arrives at the pueblo where Cooper (John Ireland) was hiding out. It's bloody raw and ugly, but if you watch the scene when Cooper kicked him out of the runaway wagon, the cut on his cheek was nowhere as severe.

The other thing I got a kick out of was the jail cell fight that Cooper picks with Miguel (Antonio Sabato) which then causes them to join forces when some other inmate thugs start working over Miguel. When the fight is over, Miguel casually begins playing a harmonica that would presumably have to have been in his hand the whole time because he never reached elsewhere to retrieve it. So that seemed a bit contrived.

I guess there's room for one more issue the story puzzled me with. Cooper seemed to be on pretty good terms with his wife Maria (Gloria Milland), so even though he may have been away from home a good part of the time, I couldn't fathom why his daughter Juana (Nadia Marconi) wouldn't have known who he was. But given the premise, I guess it was no big deal that Cooper didn't want her to find out.

Say, did you notice that Miguel only killed opposing outlaws in multiples? Whenever he used his pistol he'd get two at a time until the final battle when he'd dispatch three guys at once in a couple of instances. Maybe even more amazing, he never ran out of bullets!

As for the ending, it's left open for interpretation as to the fate of Cooper. After he and Moxon shot each other, Moxon's wound was fatal but Cooper was still hanging on but on his knees waiting things out. I guess you'd have to toss a coin to decide if he died from his wounds or if malaria decided his fate after all. I guess he was a goner either way.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed