Herod the Great (1959) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
12 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Hokey story about a Biblical personage with brief biographic and historical remarks
ma-cortes5 January 2013
This Biblic Peplum deals about all the passion and power in the pagan court of history's mad and lustful king . There Herod (Edmund Purdom) , King of Judea , married to Miriam (Sylvia Lopez) and happens dramatic happenings . It is set in Jerusalen , after battle of Actium when is defeated Marcus Antonius and Cleopatra , being victorious Octavius Augustus (Massimo Giroti) . Herodes who supported Antonius is taken prisoner by the Romans . Convinced Herod is dead , his faithful official named Aaron (Alberto Lupo) , is nevertheless unable to keep his swearing to murder the Queen if something untoward happened to the ruler . Herod's pleas to Augustus are successful and he goes back to his famous palace . His son , Antipater or Herod Antipas (Corrado Pani) , tells Herod that Aaron has double-crossed him . Then , Herod turned a madman who killed his own family and a great many lieutenants ; later on , King Herod ordered the killing of the new born babies , taking place the known massacre of innocents and appearance the holy star of Belen where was born Jesus .

This epic Italian movie packs drama , thrills , marvelous scenarios and hokey historical events . Nice production design and enjoyable gowns , but little action . Mediocre interpretations headed by Edmund Purdom , an American actor who emigrated Italy and played several historical and Sword and Sandal movies such as Sinuhe the Egyptian , The prodigal , Salambo , Nefertiti, Regina Del Nilo ; and of course Sylvia Lopez , a gorgeous actress who early died at age 26 by cancer illness . Furthermore , the Italian sex-symbol Sandra Milo along with other actors usual of Peplum as Alberto Lupo , Corrado Pani , Renato Baldini , Enzo Fiermonti and Massimo Giroti , Terence Hill 's father . Evocative as well as colorful cinematography by prestigious cameraman Massimo Dallamano , also a filmmaker . Atmospheric musical score by Carlo Savina , Pepum and Spaghetti's ordinary . The motion picture was professionally directed by Viktor Tourjansky , though with no originality . He was a Russian film director who emigrated after the communist revolution of 1917, and worked in several countries , and mostly in Italy . Tourjansky directed period epic films, such as Le Triomphe Michel Strogoff 1961 , Prisoner of the Volga (1959), The Cossacks (1960), The pharaoh's woman (1960) , The Venus of Cheronea (1957) , some of which were considered among his better works. During the 1950s and 1960s he was wintering in Italy and worked there as producer and writer under the artistic name Arnaldo Genoino.

The picture is partially based on historical deeds , these are the followings : Herod , also known as Herod the Great (born 73 or 74 BC, died 4 BC in Jericho , was a Roman client king of Judea. His epithet of "the Great" is widely disputed as he is described as "a madman who murdered his own family and a great many rabbis. He is also known for his colossal building projects in Jerusalem and elsewhere, including his expansion of the Second Temple in Jerusalem (sometimes referred to as Herod's Temple) and the construction of the port at Caesarea Maritima. Important details of his biography are gleaned from the works of the 1st century AD Roman-Jewish historian Josephus Flavius. The Romans made Herod's son Herod Archelaus ethnarch of Judea, Samaria, and Idumea from 4 BC to 6 AD, referred to as the Tetrarchy of Judea. Archelaus was judged incompetent by the Roman emperor Augustus who then combined Samaria, Judea proper and Idumea into Iudaea province under rule of a prefect until 41. Herod's other son Herod Antipas was Tetrarch of Galilee from 4 BC–39 AD.
12 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Othello Of The East
bkoganbing2 January 2011
Warning: Spoilers
This cut rate biblical epic is about that most wicked of kings, Herod The Great most noted for the mass infanticide in Bethlehem shortly after the first Christmas. But this film presents a far different view of what led up to those tragic events.

Herod as played by Edmond Purdom borrows a bit from Othello. This is one jealous dude whose fits of madness are encouraged by the Iago he has fathered, son Antipas who as the Bible tells us eventually inherited the crown.

Herod is also a character in Antony and Cleopatra and he had the misfortune to pick a loser there when Antony and Cleopatra lost at Actium and commit suicide. Now Octavian is probably going to pick a Roman governor for Judea and Herod will be deposed. Herod goes out on a diplomatic mission to save his throne.

He does, but while he's away the rumor is spread because they really do think Octavian's going to do Herod in, it would seem the logical course. But instead they arrive at a power sharing arrangement for Judea. All the people who've dethroned Herod prematurely are in deep trouble. But his psyche is now ripe for the evil counsel of his kid Antipas.

Herod has an infant son as well and the mother has spirited him away from the palace. When he gets rumors that they made flight to Bethlehem and that famous star appears, Herod of course misinterprets the whole thing.

The film was not as bad as I thought it would be and certainly provides an interesting alternative for the biblical explanation of events that we are all familiar with.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Decent Version of the Story of Herod
Rainey-Dawn22 January 2017
The biblical story of the Herod, King of Judea. Herod is captured by the Pagan Romans and held prisoner. Herod's lieutenant, Aaron, believes that he is dead. Aaron had orders from Herod to kill the Queen when he dies, but Aaron could not do it and brought her into the desert to hid her. Herod pleas to Augustus enough that Herod was able to go back to his palace. When Herod arrives, he is told by his son, Antipater, that Aaron has betrayed him and the Queen is still alive. Now Herod must find his wife and face her pursuers.

It's an alright film. One of the better movies in the Warriors 50-pack by Mill Creek. Herod was a person that really lived and there is plenty of proof of that. So in it's way, the film is a History and Biographical film as well as being a Bible Story.

I will say it again, I do not rate these types of films based on how accurate to history they are or how true they are or not. I base my ratings on how well entertained I was by the film.

4.5/10
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
THE DESKED KING
liodavix26 September 2019
A lazy and failed Italian peplum of the fifties.

The film is inspired by the sadly famous king of Judea Herod the Great, considered a villain in the gospels for being responsible for the massacre of the innocent saints, although some historians question the truth of these events.

Regarding the film the figure of Herod, here is embodied by the Englishman Edmund Purdom, who gives presence to the character but who never manages to give true intensity to his interpretation. The same goes for the rest of the cast who fail to emerge in their characters by offering soulless and passionless performances.

Although it may seem so. This is not a biography of the mythical king, because he does not pay attention to his work as a builder and the prosperity that he brought to the Jewish people but that the film focuses only on his family dramas, there is hardly any action his always complicated relations with Octavio are touched superficially and it has become tedious and uninteresting for a historical figure that gave more of itself.

Their photography costumes and decorations recreated with some luxury are saved.

Otherwise a forgettable film.

Thank you.,
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
History lesson (not)
kosmasp11 August 2019
As with almost every Sword and Sandals movie, you get some historical thing or figure and than the movie runs with it. In this case it does not take it and runs completely away with it, which has been the case before. No it does stay in a timeline that is quite close to History.

Having said that, do not take anything that happens at face value. This is her to entertain and while the 60s proved to be filled even more with Sword and Sandals in Italy, this has the formula/bluepring down
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
HEROD THE GREAT (Viktor Tourjansky and Arnaldo Genoino, 1959) *1/2
Bunuel197619 January 2009
No sooner did I state in my review of THE PRODIGAL (1955) above that it was going to be my only tribute to the late Edmund Purdom, that a visit to the local DVD rental shop also provided me with the opportunity to watch this Italian biblical flick. Unfortunately, the end results were even less satisfactory than that earlier Hollywood epic! For one thing, Purdom makes for a decidedly wooden ruler of Judea who, at the film's start, is seen returning from a lost battle against Octavius Caesar(!) to find all of his elderly subjects (who, naturally, had stayed home) seemingly out for his blood! Even his son and mother-in-law openly hate and scorn him! Eventually, Herod regains his composure with the appearance of his wife – and how could it have been otherwise when she is portrayed by the red-headed, curvaceous beauty Sylvia Lopez? Tragically, in real life she would be dead of leukemia before the year was out but not before making Steve Reeves' head spin in her most significant role in HERCULES UNCHAINED (1959)! Out of the blue, then, the film's second half takes the form of a retread of Shakespeare's "Othello" with Purdom the jilted monarch, Lopez the compromised queen, Alberto Lupo as Herod's innocent right-hand man and Corrado Pani (as young Herod Antipas) as his Iago-ish brand new confidant! The strain is too much for Herod-Purdom to bear and, a little while after ordering the proverbial slaughtering of Judea's first born, he just keels over and dies at the foot of his throne! Ugh…which is a pity since a few months ago I had rather enjoyed Purdom's next collaboration with director Tourjansky, THE COSSACKS (1960) – which also shares at least three other distinguished participants (actor Massimo Girotti, screenwriter Damiano Damiani and cinematographer Massimo Dallamano) with this one.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Biblical tedium just for sado-masochists
Leofwine_draca30 July 2016
Warning: Spoilers
This stolid potboiler was released during the high point of historical Biblical cinema, with lots of big-bucks productions coming out at around the same time. However, don't be fooled; HEROD THE GREAT is an extraordinarily low budget production that has about one tenth of the budget of those other movies. The cheapness is apparent in the poor, set-bound locales and the rubbishy special effects, including the Star of Bethlehem as represented by what looks like a wobbly sparkler. However, what's worse is the script, which focuses on incessant love scenes and overblown melodrama than an actually decent plot. 90% of this film consists of dialogue between various characters and the Shakespearian plot never really captures the imagination like it should. So what we're left with is a painfully dull and derivative movie in which characters talk, argue, and eventually die.

Action fans expecting something like a peplum will be sorely disappointed by this movie's lack of spirit. A couple of bloodless stabbings are all that's on offer in the action stakes and even the ending, which should be overblown and dramatic, is dull; Purdom just falls down on the steps and dies. As for the acting, it ranges between wooden and hammy. Purdom is a real ham and goes gloriously over the top on occasion, but even so is more restrained than elsewhere. Sylvia Lopez also seems wooden and her fake red wig (one of many in the film) makes her seem unbelievable. A supporting cast of Italian regulars don't really get a look in, it has to be said. Best of all is the gorgeous Sandra Milo in a minor role; it's amazing that this stunning actress didn't get greater billing, because she's certainly the most interesting thing in the whole movie. Otherwise this is a film for sado-masochists only.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Herod the Great
CinemaSerf13 April 2023
This has all the makings of a great story - the legendary Herod the Great, a twist of Anthony and Cleopatra and some good, old fashioned, court intrigue... What we get, however, is a poorly constructed sword and sandals offering featuring some rather poor performances from Edmund Purdom in the title role and Sylvia Lopez as his Queen "Mariam". It's actually fairly accurate - historically speaking - but the execution is so haphazard and lacklustre that it soon becomes quite an effort to watch, and it's equivalent of the 'Dance of the 7 Veils" is a distinctly wooden effort. The staging and costumes are efficient, and had the cast and writing been just a little stronger then this could have been good... but it wasn't/isn't.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good Epic of Betrayal and Revenge
claudio_carvalho31 July 2005
When Marco Antonio is defeated by his enemies, his former allied King Herod of Judea (Edmund Purdom) travels to convince Augustus to support his government by the Romans. He makes his chief commander and friend Aaron (Alberto Lupo) swear that he would kill his beloved Queen Miriam (Sylvia Lopez) if he died. When Herod is arrested by the Romans, one of his men returns to Judea and lies, telling that he was killed by the Romans. However Aaron is not able to keep his promise and Miriam stays alive. When Herode returns to his palace, his son Antipater, poisons Herode with the lie that Aaron has betrayed him and had an affair with Miriam. The madness of Herode destroys his friends and his kingdom.

"Erode il grande" is a good epic of betrayal and revenge in a nest of snakes. The theatrical performance of Edmund Purdom is very exaggerated and quite ridiculous in the love scenes with Sylvia Lopez, but in the rest of the movie he works well. The character of Antipater seems to be inspired in Iago of Shakespeare's Othello. Unfortunately the DVD released in Brazil by the distributor London Films is horribly dubbed in English, and the quality of the image is awful. But this movie is a worthwhile entertainment if the viewer disregard the previously mentioned problems. My vote is seven.

Title (Brazil): "Herodes o Grande" ("Herode The Great")
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
...Meanwhile, on the other side of the Mediterranean...
mark.waltz8 August 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Ancient Rome had built up a huge power as the B.C. era came to an end. Egypt, under Cleopatra, fell under Octavian Caesar's power, and smaller nations trembled as well as the once great Judean nation. "God's chosen people" didn't seem so chosen under Herodian rule, and even the promise of the birth of their savior couldn't save them under imperialistic Rome.

But in spite of the fact that this is about King Herod during the time of the birth of Christ, this is not a biblical epic, just a low budget sword and sandal retelling of the life of the Judean king. The biblical story is only dealt with briefly. Like other sagas of ancient kingdoms, this deals mostly with the struggles of the king to maintain his power and destroy all those out to betray him, or those whom he thinks are out to betray him.

Edmund Purdom is the only actor worth mentioning in this cheaply made epic that is cheaply filmed, badly dubbed and often pathetically slow moving. Herod seems a just ruler as he goes to Rome and deal with the aftermath of war. His wife's manipulative mother (a former Hebrew king's daughter) prematurely announces her son in law's death so she can put her own young son on the throne. This leads Herod's wife open to another man's arms and Herod's vowing of revenge as he returns from Rome three times as ruthless as he was before. Herod's evil son from a first marriage causes all sorts of issues, leading to the decline in the king's rational.

Most of the pivotal roles are played by actors who do not at all appear to be middle eastern. While sets and costumes seem accurate, the film as a whole fails miserably. Elements of the plot seem to match the not yet opened Broadway musical "Camelot" with Herod certainly no King Arthur, his wife and the man whom Herod thinks she's cheating on with him no Guenevere and Lancelot, the mother-in-law no Morgan Le Fey and the evil son no Mordred. Nobody in this ancient Judea would sing, "Don't let it be forgot." Purdom chews up the set with delight in the strange conclusion. This is definitely the lion in winter of Herod's discontent.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Herod driving everyone mad but most of all himself
clanciai18 March 2019
It's one of those Italian Peplum productions, for once without any Steve Reeves, but Edmund Purdom as Herod is convincing enough, although maybe slightly too handsome for a Herod, like Massimo Girotti also is a bit too dashing for Augustus. The story is the grim drama of Herod killing off his own family - Augustus observed on one occasion that no one needed to threat Herod's family as he would soon have killed them all himself. It has the character of a melodrama, there is very little action and mainly only theatrical acting, but the actors are all good and attractive - like in all Peplum films the set designs are perfectly stylish. But that's all - no cinematography, nothing special, only drama and tears and paranoia, which Herod drives to extremes - which he also did in reality.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
No Action, But Fun Watching the Acting
jayraskin18 December 2009
The story is about King Herod and his love for his Queen Mariam.

It has been a while since I read Josephus and his account of Herod, but I will assume the movie follows Josephus' storyline to some degree. In the last ten minutes, a little subplot taken from the Gospels of Luke and Matthew is added. In it Herod orders the killing of a brat born in Bethlehem. Oddly, according to the movie, King Herod only ordered the killing of the new born babies because he was so distaught that Mariam did not love him anymore.

There are some nice sets and costumes, but nothing really spectacular here. There are no real battles or sword fights, so action fans should stay away. This is a small cast with only a few dozen extras. It has more of an intimate stage play rather than an epic quality feeling.

The real reason to watch is the acting. Edmund Purdom is actually quite good as Herod. You actually do feel sorry for Herod at moments. Sylvia Lopez is extraordinary as Mariam. This and "Hercules Unchained" are basically the only known widely released movies she was in during her short three year movie career. If she had not died at 28, she might have been one of the great stars of the 60's. She kind of reminds me of Diane Cilento. She's more sexy than beautiful and she really dominates the screen. One can easily see why she drives Herod crazy.

If you're interested in 1st century B.C.E. Judean history, the movie is worth a look. Also if you want to see a beautiful young actress who died at the door to stardom in 1959, you should check it out.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed