The Dalton Girls (1957) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Not Half-Bad If You're Not Expecting High Noon
dougdoepke6 September 2007
Actually this is not a half-bad Western if you're not expecting much, and certainly the title doesn't promise much in the way of artistry. What this B-flick has going for it are some well- staged scenes on the prairie and a couple of tough-minded chick scenes, especially the robbery episodes. The acting is uneven, to say the least. Merry Anders is fine as Holly, the leader, as is Lisa Davis as Rose, the second toughie. However, poor Sue George as Marigold should have auditioned for Leave It to Beaver. Maybe you won't have as much trouble as I did telling these "flowers" apart, but they do look alike and it can get confusing. Judging from the title, you'd probably expect more titillation than there is-- after all, this is the 1950's. Nonetheless, there is a legitimate feminist undercurrent even if much is compromised in the end. All in all, this minor production from a couple of old pro's (director Le Borg and producer Schenck) remains a rather interesting artifact as well as a fairly viable piece of period entertainment.
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Western costumes must have been having a sale.
mark.waltz19 November 2012
Warning: Spoilers
This '50's drive-in chick flick is a cheesy western with amateurish acting that takes all the bad girl exploitation films and adds on corsets while taking away the bee-hive hairdo's. An inappropriate use of dramatic music shows this for the clunky bomb it is. One of the girls sings a song about not trusting a man cause they'll betray you while a gun will stay with you until you die. "You kill like other women love men" one of the sisters tells another. That sums up the best dialog in this misfire where there is no real motivation for the girls robbing coaches and saloons other than the fact that men have exploited them. Not a camp classic, but enjoyable if you know what you're getting yourself into.
0 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Classy Exploitation Film
aimless-4628 December 2007
Like Howard Hughes' "The Outlaw" (1943), "The Dalton Girls" (1957) was a mixed genre film; a standard "B" western with very deliberate exploitation elements. Although both films attempted a tie-in to real western history, "The Dalton Girls" wisely soft-peddled this element; the only connection being that the four girls were sisters of the guys who started the Dalton Gang.

Although almost any "B" western fan will enjoy the film, it is a must see for those who get off on cowgirls in tight jeans and gun belts. That was the film's drawing card at the time of its release and even today it doesn't get any better than Merry Anders, Lisa Davis, and Penny Edwards robbing stagecoaches and banks. Edwards is my all-time favorite cowgirl and does all the difficult riding stunts in the film. There is even a scene where she hogties a teenage boy.

The film also features John Russell (who would soon star in his own television show, "Lawman") as an early anti-hero. He is an interesting mix of Richard Boone's "Paladin" character (tough but philosophical) and Bret Maverick (a calculating realist of a gambler). Sam Rolfe may have seen this film in pre-release and incorporated some of Russell's traits into the "Paladin" character he was creating. Oddly, the character's name is W.T. (Illinois) Grey but he claims New Orleans as his hometown.

"The Dalton Girl's" moves along nicely and then kind of clunks to a stop with an extremely lame and rushed ending.

The screenwriter (Maurice Tombragel) obviously had a lot of fun with this adaptation, and the story operates on two levels. There are some nice self-parody elements inserted throughout the story. The best is a scene where Lisa Davis is singing about how having a gun is better than having a man:

"Oh you can't trust a man, because a man will lie. But a gun stays beside you, until the day that you die. Oh a man is a cheater, with his trifling ways. But a gun's always faithful, because a gun never strays. Oh a man is unfaithful, he will lead you to strife. But a gun is my true love, yes a gun is my life".

Then again, what do I know? I'm only a child.
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Good Film
David_Brown29 October 2010
Warning: Spoilers
"The Dalton Girls" is NOT "Bad Girls", it is a totally different film than the 1994 Stowe, Barrymore, Masterson, MacDowell film. Basically the only things they have in common are: 1: There are four women involved, and spoilers ahead: 2: A bad guy was killed because he tried to abuse a woman, so he got killed. 3: Something I will save for last. I have to say, it is a much harsher film than "Bad Girls", because the worst of the "Bad Girls" Lilly (Barrymore), was not a cold blooded killer in the way that Rose, and even Holly are. Another factor that makes it harsher (MAJOR Spoilers ahead)is the fact that Rose and Marigold die, Holly surrenders (and you know will be hanged), and only Columbine escapes the fate of her sisters, because she will not kill unarmed men (Including "Illinois"), and saves them from getting murdered, so I guess for that reason, the town let "Illinois" take her away. By comparison, the "Bad Girls" all get away, with Cody (Stowe), Anita (Masterson), & Lilly going off to dig for gold, with Eileen (MacDowell), staying behind to get married and help run a ranch. "The Dalton Girls" is a very good film, and worth watching (Although it is not the modern classic "Bad Girls" is). The one character in "Bad Girls" you see a lot of in "The Dalton Girls" is Eileen. She has elements of three of the Daltons. 1: She has regrets like Holly did of her choices in life. 2: Instead of living an outlaw life, She wants to ranch and be married (Like Marigold). 3: She is the one who is willing, and eventually will separate from the others, as Columbine did. What is different, of course, is Eileen's fate is much better than any of the Daltons.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Female Outlaws in the Old West
hogwrassler14 February 2021
I caught The Dalton Girls late last night on The Westerns Channel. It was a unique concept of female outlaws in the old west and I stayed with it all the way to the end because I wanted to find out the fate of each of the four girls. The story was easy to follow and the action scenes and stunt work were all well handled. The four Dalton Girls, sisters of the now deceased Dalton Brothers, are driven to a life of crime when Holly, the oldest, kills their brothers' undertaker for trying to rape her. She smashes him in the head with a shovel. With her three sisters, they set about robbing banks and stagecoaches. These girls are as good with guns and horses as any man. Holly (Merry Anders) tries to protect the youngest, Marigold (Sue George), who seems to not fit in with a life on the run. Rose (Lisa Davis), is a cold blooded killer doing just what she wants. Columbine (Penny Edwards) is an efficient criminal, but hopes to find a way out some day. It's even part musical. Rose sings "Can't Trust a Man" accompanied by Columbine on the harmonica. As I watched, I noticed a slight British accent creeping into some of Lisa Davis' lines, and I checked her out on IMDb. Sure enough, she was born in England. Penny Edwards was hand picked by Dale Evans to replace her as Roy Rogers gal pal in some RR movies when Dale was expecting a baby. John Russell is really good as the gambler who loves Columbine and keeps turning up wherever the girls go. This is a good western, overall, and is kind of a forerunner of the 1994 movie, "Bad Girls." Western fans will enjoy watching "The Dalton Girls."
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Gorgeous Lady B-Western from Bel Air Productions
TheFearmakers24 May 2020
Bel Air Productions of THE DALTON GIRLS consists of four resilient and completely bad-ass sage-riding sisters of The Dalton Gang, all freshly dead... the men that is... and their gorgeous siblings are as follows...

Merry Anders as the mother figure, and darn good with a gun; Lisa Davis is the wildcard killer, and even better with a gun; Sue George is the quiet, baby-faced youngest; and Penny Edwards is... in a Western with four pretty sisters... the pretty one, as in, the most girly and classy and who the handsome leading man is after...

In-between the title gang robbing a stagecoach, a saloon and then a high-stakes hotel room poker game, square-jawed gambler John Russell desperately yearns to protect Penny Edwards' Columbine Dalton, who, along with the youngest (both recent graduates of a fancy finishing school) isn't all that crazy about life on the run, like the older two.

Edwards, no stranger to the dusty genre, makes a wonderful kind of pawn, vulnerable to the suspenseful action-packed violence with b-starlet Merry Anders providing a solid baseline...

But it's Lisa Davis as Alpha Female Rose that steals the picture, proving she's tough as any man... maybe even tougher. Ultimately, it's her fight to lose.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Just another "B" western, except the outlaws are babes.
youroldpaljim14 November 2001
After the Dalton boys are killed by the law, one of the Dalton girls is forced to kill a lecherous mortician who tries to rape her. Being branded a murderess, the sisters follow in their brothers tracks and take up a life of crime. One of the sisters falls for a handsome gambler whom they rob and then develops second thoughts about a life of crime.

THE DALTON GIRLS is one of the last gasps of the true Hollywood "B" western. This film is no different from a zillion other such films except that the outlaws are female. The box on the Fang video edition describes the film as a "J.D. chick western", and thats how the female leads play their roles; like they just stepped out of some biker flick. Aside from having the outlaws being females, there something to be said about John Russell as the slightly aloof and philosophical gambler Gray. Its little unusual to have the films hero to be a man who, while not a criminal, isn't exactly squeaky clean either. John Russell was a handsome actor with a very good speaking voice, but was also often somewhat stiff. Here he puts his stiffness, good looks and good speaking voice to his advantage. Otherwise, THE DALTON GIRLS is just another B western. Its not a film that is any good, but nothing about it is done really bad enough to make to someone hate it or provide unintentional laughs.
16 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
loved it
Venusvee24 March 2008
I have issues with watching old movies, particularly black and white films. The editing, the dialogue, the acting, the plot...etc. I have been trained by modern society too well, it sucks. And I feel bad about it, not enjoying old movies the way I should. Which brings me to the dalton girls. Loved it. It was ahead of its time in so many ways. The plot, the characters, even some of the dialogue. And the lead male was HOT, which is often not true in older movies and yes I am looking at you Humphrey Bogart and Fred Astaire. It was so fast paced compared to other movies at the time and fun and real. I only got annoyed once! So I am tired of hearing this "B-movie" attack on this movie. I am impressed. I wasn't even planning on watching this film. I just came home form drinking one night and found it on...and it takes a lot to grab my attention after i have been drinking. Cheers dalton ladies!
10 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Giddy Up Western About Gun-Toting Gals
zardoz-1322 October 2009
Warning: Spoilers
"Voodoo Island" director Reginald Le Borg's vastly underrated movie "The Dalton Girls" is a surprisingly entertaining distaff western about the notorious outlaw gang's offspring. Indeed, this oater looks like a forerunner of Jonathan Kaplan's "Bad Girls" (1994) with Madeleine Stowe, Mary Stuart Masterson, Andie MacDowell, and Drew Barrymore. Unlike "Bad Girls," "The Dalton Girls" features a cast of largely unknown actresses. The most recognizable name belongs to venerable western character actor John Russell. "El Alaméin" scenarist Herbert Purdom wrote the story while seasoned western scribe Maurice Tombragel penned the screenplay. Although there are no surprises in this modest but well-staged dust-raiser, the cast and the characters are endowed with a modicum of depth and the dialogue is sometimes quite striking. Anybody who appreciates a solid, interesting western will enjoy this 71-minute shoot'em up. The priority of the themes here is women versus men, women versus society, and women versus women. The girls quarrel about their predicament, but they have their hands full of unsavory gents. Producer Howard W. Koch went on to produce several Frank Sinatra epics, including "Sergeants 3," "Robin and the Four Hoods," "Four for Texas," and "None but the Brave." The action opens with the Dalton brothers getting cornered on the prairie and gunned down. If you look closely, their body positions change after they hit the dirt. Nevertheless, Mr. Slidell, the Mortician (Glenn Dixon of "Untamed Youth") puts their bodies on display in the back of his undertaking parlor for twenty-five cents. Later, when the two older sisters, Holly (Merry Anders of "Women of the Prehistoric Planet") and Columbine (Penny Edwards of "Missing Women"), visit the funeral home, Slidell talks about defraying the expenses of the funeral and tries to rape Holly. She clobbers him with a shovel, but she hits him hard enough that he dies. Earlier, a private detective name Hiram Parsh (Ed Hinton of "Jungle Moon Men") had stopped by to identify the bodies. Slidell refused to let him view the corpses until he paid his quarter because the undertaker didn't consider him in the same position as a public servant. Just so that we the audience know that Slidell is unsavory, Parsh drops his quarter in the dirt.

Six years elapse and the Dalton girls hold up a stagecoach. One of the passengers tries to get fresh with Columbine and she pulls her pistol on him. W.T. "Illinois" Grey (John Russell of "Pale Rider") takes an instant liking to Columbine. Grey is a well-dressed gambler and he isn't exactly a hero, but neither is he a villain. Columbine is taken by his attention. The two older sisters Holly and Rose (Lisa Davis of "Baby Face Nelson") are hard-bitten, especially Rose who shows no qualms about killing. Columbine accuses her Rose of killing the same way that some women love.

After the stagecoach robbery, they are looking for somewhere to go and Columbine remembers that Grey mentioned something about the gold strike in Dry Creek. They show up in Dry Creek and rob the bank of $6-thousand and coincidentally Grey catches them in the act because he is trying to collect a gambling debt from the bank manager Mr. Sewell (Malcolm Atterbury of "The Birds") who is somewhat shady. During the hold-up, Sewell grabs a gun in his desk drawer and Rose plugs him. She shoots Grey, but her bullet glances off the watch that the gambler wears and he survives the murder attempt. Columbine isn't happy about this turn of events. The sisters skedaddle and wind up in Tombstone. Grey trails them to Tombstone and a suspicious Parsh follows him.

In Tombstone, Grey corners Rose and Holly in a saloon where they are working as hostesses and threatens to reveal their identities unless they give him his six grand. They concoct a scheme to rob a poker game. You see, the bigger poke games are private and Sheriff St. Ives (stunt man Al Wyatt, Sr.) guards the hotel room where the men play. The Dalton sisters get the drop on St. Ives and rob the game, but they don't get far because Parsh opens fire on them.

One of the neat touches here is a song that Rose sings about how her six-gun is more dependable to her than a man. The lyrics go something like this . . . "Oh, you can't trust a man, cause a man will lie, but a gun stays beside you till the die you die." Director Le Borg does a good job of keeping the action moving along at full tilt so that there are no lulls in the action. The film appears to have been done on location, a factor that enhances its authenticity. The four sisters are differentiated in tone, dialogue, and character. "The Dalton Girls" may be a low-budget, B-western, but it never wears out its welcome and there is nothing unintentionally funny. Russell is usual stalwart self in a less than heroic role, considering that he starred as the title character in the television series "Lawman."
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Not Johnny Guitar as a feminist western but....
searchanddestroy-129 April 2021
This western belongs to the short list of westerns involving female gunslingers and duels between them. It is a lousy picture but excellent for me, very unusual for this kind of productions. There would have been more of them. The best example of what Grade B pictures could provide from time to time.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed