La rebelión de los colgados (1954) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Rumble in the Jungle.
brogmiller16 September 2021
B. Traven's novels have sold 25 million copies in thirty languages. He himself is an obscure, shadowy figure and by all accounts he went out of his way to remain so. There is not even a birth certificate and it has even been suggested that he was the illegitimate son of Kaiser Wilhelm.

What IS certain is that 'he had Mexico in his bones' and the sharp-eyed will recognise his name on the credits as the author of 'Treasure of the Sierra Madre'. His cycle of 'Mahogany' novels of which 'Rebellion of the hanged' is the fifth' also reveal him to be a fervent socialist intent on showing the appalling, slave-like conditions suffered by Mexican Indians in the mahogany logging camps during the rule of dictator Porfirio Díaz.

The film's poster declares 'Love! Lust! Violence!' There is not a great deal of love on display here it must be said but there is a modicum of lust supplied by the ravishing Amanda del Llano. There is certainly plenty of violence in the form of the cruelty dispensed by the two monstrous labour agents who are played with relish by Carlos López Moctezuma and Luis Aceves Castaneda. Their ultimate fates at the hands of their victims represent the punishment fitting the crime.

It is directed by Alfredo B. Crevenna and Emilio Fernández who is uncredited. Where one leaves off and the other begins is uncertain but one cannot fail to see the influence of the mighty Fernández here in terms of characterisation, dramatic tension and a tendency to 'overcook' it. Atmospheric cinematography and powereful score are supplied by his regular collaborators Gabriel Figuroa and Antonio Díaz Conde. Certainly no stranger to Fernández is Pedro Armendáriz who is immensely sympathetic as a Tzotzil Indian. Unusual to see Víctor Junco dressed as a peon rather than in his customary lounge suit.

Although a Silver Ariel was awarded to editor Gloria Schoemann one feels that there may have been some 'censorial' editing here. The material is as brutal as cinema at the time would have permitted and packs quite a punch as both film and social document.

B. Traven said that 'an author should have no other biography than his books'. In his case that is all we are ever likely to have.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Cruel Punishment
sonny_196315 January 2007
"Rebellion of the Hanged," alludes to workers who broke any rules being stripped to the waist and hung by their wrists high above the ground for countless hours on end. Some were even whipped while they were hanging Then they fought back.

This cruel punishment just made living and working in a Mexican mahogany plant that much worse. The workers were not certified slaves, but they may well have been, because quitting the job was impossible due to no way to get out of that part of the forest.

Pedro Armandariz is excellent as the father of a young boy, trying to support both of them. Ariana Welter is fine as a woman who arrived with him and the boy at the camp. In one sad scene, she tells the son that his father is working, when he really is hanging in pain.

This film is an indictment of conditions that existed at that time.
17 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Simple and extremely effective
planktonrules3 June 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Before I start discussing the merits of the film, I noticed one thing about the film. At first, the film appeared to be dubbed but then I though maybe it wasn't because the voices SEEMED to fit the lip movements. When I checked IMDb, it indicated that this was a Spanish language film and so it should be pointed out that those who dubbed the film did an amazing job. I almost always HATE dubbed films and always look for subtitled versions. However, here it in no way harmed the enjoyment of the film and I was impressed.

As for the rest of the movie, I was equally impressed. For a relatively modest budgeted film with a simple plot, it was super-effective and inspiring. The story is a film about social justice and the evil abuse of power. I could see this film being loved by communists and socialists, but frankly, anyone who is against evil and exploitation should enjoy this film and root for the little guys.

Pedro Armendáriz was not a well-known actor to American audiences, as most of his movies were made in Spanish (such as Buñuel's THE BRUTE). However, he made a few films in English and his most famous non-Spanish speaking role was in FROM Russia WITH LOVE. Here, he plays the lead and the film begins with him bringing his dying wife to town for medical help. The doctor is a pig and won't operate without money, so Pedro is forced to look to strangers for help. Not only does the money come too late to help Pedro's wife, who dies, but the "nice guy" who gave him the money turns out to be like a slave trader--only worse. He recruits poor and ignorant peasants to work in camps doing impossibly hard work. Plus, the workers are routinely tortured or even killed and no one seems to care.

Most of the film consists of horrid and very compelling vignettes of excessive brutality, though it is done in a way that is still watchable--not stomach-turning and probably acceptable for teens. Finally, after the men can take no more, they turn on their masters for a VERY rousing conclusion.

As I said, I could see how anti-capitalists like communists and socialists would love the movie, but so should just about everyone as the rebellion is in the very best tradition of George Washington and José de San Martín. An amazing film and a great civics lesson.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed