Doña Bárbara (1943) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Long Mexican soap opera marked by good characterizations and acting
jacobs-greenwood18 December 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Directed by Fernando de Fuentes, and based on the novel by Rómulo Gallegos, this Mexican film tells the story of the titled character, a woman who was raped in her late teens which hardens and strengthens her such that she becomes a ruthless, wealthy landowner who takes out her hostilities on the weaker male sex in her country. Barbara's "rule" includes bribing the officials to make the laws favorable to her interests, and her "reign" continues unchecked until another landowner, Santos Luzardo, returns to the region.

The film runs well over 2 hours and feels even longer; it plays like a soap opera featuring a storyline intertwined with several main characters, some of which seem unnecessary (I'm guessing the novel is quite long such that a serial, or series might have better served the material). Still, this is a highly regarded foreign film. NOTE: the English subtitles are filled with spelling and grammatical errors.

Dona Barbara (María Félix) was a beautiful young woman who was traveling alone by boat when a handsome young, penniless man joined its crew, working for his passage. When Dona shows a romantic interest in the newest crew member, she gives his other shipmates an idea they somehow hadn't thought of previously - that she's desirable. So, they shoot the young man and gang rape the woman. Years later, Barbara's name is known throughout the country as a woman who has used countless men to gain power over the region. She now owns most of its land & assets (e.g. cattle), even using illegal means when it suited her purpose, and buying the officials to look the other way or rule in her favor in disputes. However, "doctor" Santo Luzardo (Julián Soler), a former favored son and still current landowner from the region, has decided to return to look after his interests. Luzardo had accurately suspected that his foreman, Don Balbino (Felipe Montoya) had been assisting Barbara in looting his cattle et al. Initially, the other men in Luzardo's employ are not so sure that he's a worthy rival to Barbara, but he is able to assuage these concerns by demonstrating his superior horsemanship.

Meanwhile, we learn that Barbara had a daughter with Lorenzo Barquer (Andrés Soler), who is now like all the other men left in her wake, a broken, poor man who drinks to excess. She has also shown no interest in her daughter Marisela (María Elena Marqués). In fact, Barbara has stolen Marisela's land and left her ignorant and, in essence, to fend for herself, though she's been cared for by Juan Primito (Agustín Isunza), a servant of Barbara's. However, a local merchant, Don Guillermo (Charles Rooner), lusts after Lorenzo's daughter, and eventually "buys" her from him for a bottle of alcohol. Enter Luzardo, just in time, who finds the poor "child" Marisela dirty in the fields and "rescues" her. For her own protection, he takes her and her father in, to live in his home, where he begins to educate her in Pygmalion-like fashion. Her speech improves and, slowly, their relationship grows to more than teacher and pupil, though it remains platonic. Lorenzo also improves, somewhat, with sobriety.

In addition to helping Marisela and her father, Luzardo takes up the issue of his depleted cattle with the local officials. While the main "lawman" is absent, Luzardo uses his influence over his underling Mujiquita (Paco Astol), a former acquaintance, to subpoena Barbara and Balbino. Later, with the official present, and with a temporarily smitten Barbara's acquiescence, Luzardo is able to get what he needs legally to begin to restore his estate. However, when Barbara returns to her plantation, she performs an incantation and curses Luzardo using his picture, and placing it upside-down behind three candles. Later, after Luzardo and Barbara speak, she realizes that he is unlike the other men she's dealt with in the past, and becomes somewhat attracted to him. Though she then turns his picture back upright, she doesn't douse the candles' flames. In fact, when she learns that her daughter is a rival for Luzardo's affections, she allows certain other events (like the theft of some valuable feathers, 50 lbs. worth!) to proceed in hopes of hurting, if not ruining him financially.

I won't continue with the rest of the plot or subplots, which include the other aforementioned characters as well. However, I would like to point out that the characterizations, and the actors themselves, do perform credibly even if the story runs a little too long and lost my interest after a while.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Perhaps the best movie I have ever seen
andrescardenasg20 August 2005
I have just seen this movie for the 12-15th time and I still find something extraordinarily fascinating every time I watch it. This movie is based on a novel by Venezuela's Romulo Gallegos one of Latin America best writer. The movie is so profound, because you can see so many aspects of the human being in it. You can find hate, witchcraft, religion, love, impotency and repentance, mainly because of the ignorance of people. This movie develops in the great Venezuela Savannahs, where the law of the stronger prevailed. The dialogs, so strong and captivating, are possible due to Gallegos very strong command of the Spanish Language and the slang of the peasants of that region. As I have mentioned before for a couple of other movies, this one is best appreciated if you understand Spanish. I may see it again another dozen times, and I am sure I would still enjoy it, as I hope you may too. This movie is officially rated as the 75th in importance in the Mexican Cinematography, to which I TOTALLY DISAGREE. It should be in the top 10.
14 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A film with an epic sweep and rich characters
greglatraille5 December 2009
Warning: Spoilers
"Doña Bárbara" is a wonderful film. Indeed it approaches epic status with a story that pulls you in and never quite goes where you expect. Imagine Barbara Stanwick's character in "The Big Valley", a tough attractive woman who runs a vast ranch but unlike Barbara Stanwick, this "Doña Bárbara" played by the equally great María Félix is smoldering, sensual and yet ice cold and ruthless. You cannot take your eyes off her subtle and alluring performance. Julián Soler as Dr. Santos Luzardo is her stoic and heroic rival and he too is a fine characterization. María Elena Marqués as Marisela Barquero, (Doña Bárbara's neglected daughter) also gives a very fine performance. Marisela is a childlike, sassy woman whom Dr. Luzardo grows to love. María Elena Marqués also has a fine singing voice and yes, in the midst of drama, smoldering passion, alcoholic degradation, lust, magical spells, superstition and some gun play there is room for a lyrically sung ballade and a delightful community dance sequence. There is even some witty light comic repartee between Dr. Luzardo and his school friend turned civic official Mujiquita, played by Paco Astol. There are so many other richly drawn characters in this story including Charles Rooner as the lecherous and repulsive Don Guillermo who also serves as a sort of Greek Chorus through his dialog with several people as does the opening narration by Julián Soler as Dr. Luzardo. The plot need not be outlined here so as not to spoil it but if you're lucky enough to see this film and you love interwoven stories that build to a climax, with many vivid characters as well as insights into Latin culture, do see it. Above all is the great María Félix whose portrayal of the dreaded but beautiful "Doña Bárbara" leads you to a finale you may not expect.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The greatest-ever Latin Am. actress as the greatest-ever Latin Am. character!
carioca-615 April 2001
This is a film not to be missed. The title role is arguably the greatest female character in Latin American literature. And Maria Felix? ...Such a supreme screen goddess in Latin American cinema, I can't think of an English-speaking equivalent.

For a Mexican particularly, to see Dona Barbara brought to life by the legendary Maria Felix is like an Anglo having seen Sarah Bernhard in her best role, I suppose. Felix and her films are still very popular, even in distant Brazil, a Latin cousin to Mexico (we speak Portuguese). This film and other Felix films, along with those of the Classic Golden Period of Mexican Cinema (to which this movie belongs) are shown in restrospectives in Rio, Sao Paulo and Buenos Aires quite frequently.

DONA BARBARA is a Pan-Latin American story, and female character. She could be Mexican, Brazilian, Argentinian,...well the novel was written by Venezuela's greatest novelist, so....Venezuelan or Colombian too. And similarly, Felix is the all-Latin American actress, an unsurpassed talent standard, against whom all other great Latin actresses aspire to be compared against.

Look, the film is simply wonderful, even without the double treat of Felix and Dona Barbara. I saw a video copy of it at a Florida public library's video section, so there may be a copy near you. look for it. It is a true classic featuring two classics!
16 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
maria diosa
Bardotsalvador17 August 2010
This is a great movie Maria at the top of her beauty and power i don't think Romulo Gallego the author of the novel never image a more perfect Dona Barbara than Maria Felix she has everything the part required , this was her third movie , the one that will immortalized her for eternity , maria based in this part created her own legend , i saw the movie long ago and i love it , have to said back in my country Cuba they did the television version of dona barbara with a very great actress and beautiful Raquel Revuelta i will said even maria was more beautiful and more charismatic Raquel was a better actress but maria was incomparable,maria is the divina garza
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
A Hieratic Sphinx
davidtraversa-124 January 2013
A friend of mine is reading "Doña Bárbara", that masterpiece by the Venezuelan writer Rómulo Gallegos and all of a sudden he said "Let's see if the movie made by María Félix from this book in 1943 can be seen on You Tube!!", and right there it was!! Since its protagonist was La Doña, that mythical Mexican beauty from the forties and fifties called María Félix, we didn't think twice, seated down and watched it --well..., we STARTED to watch it...

Wow! what a terrible disappointment!! From the very beginning they distorted the story because young Bárbara was raped by these outlaws being fifteen years old (from here on Bárbara starts hating men --not that anyone could blame her after all) and begins planning her revenge, but by 1943 María Félix was far past her teen years (Thirty, and quite grown up Thirty they were...). And then the acting... overblown dialogs, totally out of place to represent low lives and primitive country people, spoken in an excellent, cultivated Spanish with an emphasis and pomposity only tolerated on a very large auditorium when reciting Shakespeare or when, years ago, children used to represent a short play at the end of the school year, thinking they were rivaling Hollywood stars... without the need for microphones.

The film is SO BAD that we spent only the time to watch only one and a half episodes (it's shown in 14 episodes) but that was more than enough to figure out what was in store for us if we continue to watch this movie, so we said in unison "Forget it!!" and stopped right there the intolerable torture.

Nobody will doubt María Félix beauty (truly AWESOME), but one can certainly doubt about her acting abilities, since she played only herself, the legendary "La Doña" in the Movie Magazines of all Latin America, constantly self conscious about her drop dead looks and as a matter of fact that was the reason for her fantastic success in the business at the time: A truly perfect face with only one expression for everything: Joy, Anger, Sadness, whatever!! her success was the Greta Garbo success with the difference that Garbo could act. Her face was the face of the Sphinx, chiseled in porphyry, perfect for an enamored camera that followed her almost always in constant close ups and from every angle --she could have been the best model in the world for Haute Couture pictures in the glossy expensive fashion magazines of the time, but to convey the story of a simple country girl in a movie... no siree!!

Do not waste your time with this bogey, unless you want to get oodles and oodles of María Félix close ups, just to gaze at her perfect looks (the copy in "You Tube" is excellent, sharpness of image and sound quality alike).
3 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
the greatest female lead performance in film history
duaneincali4 August 2021
Yes, that is a big claim. To say teh camera loved her is an understatement.

You should watch this movie just to say you saw her at her zenith. Those eyes. Wow.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed