Madam Satan (1930) Poster

(1930)

User Reviews

Review this title
52 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Debauchery on a dirigible with Greta Garbo as Catwoman
AlsExGal15 September 2018
This is Cecil B. DeMille's weirdest film, but it is not nearly as bad as film history would have you believe. It was his only musical comedy and it tanked at the box office, but I've always been fond of these early sound curios. Kay Johnson plays Angela Brooks, married to wealthy Bob Brooks (Reginald Denny) who spends his nights partying with his friend Jimmy (Roland Young). Bob "respects" his wife, but his passion goes to his mistress, Trixie (Lillian Roth).

When Angela finds out about Bob's mistress, she goes to have it out with her, and finds that Trixie could care less about being found out, and worse gives away all of her secrets about getting and keeping Bob, feeling that Angela wouldn't know how to use such tips anyways. . Later, Jimmy has a masked ball staged on a dirigible complete with bizarre musical numbers. It is visually interesting, but as with all of the music in this film, the numbers are completely forgettable. The only thing musically memorable is Lillian Roth doing a couple of numbers. If she hadn't had a tragic life right out of the gate there would have probably never been an Ethel Merman, because Roth would have had Merman's career. She has a spitfire presence and a booming sexy voice.

The men are bidding for dances with the women, with all attention and bidding going to Trixie until a stranger walks in - Madame Satan. She is supposed to be French but she sounds just like Greta Garbo and she is supposed to be dressed like Satan but she looks like Catwoman to me. In the meantime, the crew is getting concerned because a storm is brewing and threatening the dirigible.

Bob Brooks is a curious character. In spite of the fact that he is cheating on his wife he seems to have strong Puritanical standards for both his wife and his mistress. However, he doesn't mind abandoning Trixie for the promise of bigger better possibilities, even if Trixie is standing right there. Roland Young is always good as the friend with his dry one liners. Even though he has a small part in this film, he is the only one with a semblance of a film career just a few years later.

Recommended for the weirdness of it all, but I admit these early talkies are my weakness and YMMV.
14 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Mad Masquerade Party
lugonian27 April 2004
MADAM Satan (MGM, 1930), directed by Cecil B. DeMille, marked the famed director's second of three features under the MGM banner, and one of his most unusual, or in the most common terms, bizarre. In spite of it not becoming a box office success in its initial release, MADAM Satan needs to be seen a few times in order to get the full concept of the continuity. Once getting through some dull stretches taking place during its initial 50 minutes, the movie delivers during its final portion to this 115 minute production with its one of the most oddest costume parties and inane production numbers ever captured on film.

The plot, which could very well be THE GUARDSMAN (1931, with Alfred Lunt and Lynne Fontanne) or THE CHOCOLATE SOLDIER (1941, with Nelson Eddy and Rise Stevens, which in turn is based on "The Guardsman") in reverse, focuses on Angela (Kay Johnson), a boring but cultured New York City society woman married to the prominent but fun loving Bob Brooks (Reginald Denny). Her casual evening at home stirs some excitement after reading in a newspaper that she, along with Bob and his best friend, Jim Wade (Roland Young) were taken to night court for speeding. Wanting to learn more about what her husband has been doing, and who the woman masquerading as her husband's wife is, Angela's suspicions are soon realized when she finds a calling card in Bob's pocket signed by a Trixie. Feeling her marriage dissolved because of Bob's lack of interest in her, Angela decides to follow the advice of Martha, her maid (Elsa Peterson) to go out and recapture her own husband by fascinating him. During Jim Wade's elaborate costume party, which takes place in a gigantic airship, Angela enters the social scene disguised as the masked woman who calls herself "Madam Satan."

Categorized as a musical, the production numbers set during the masquerade party are of more interest than the songs that accompany them. With the music and lyrics credited to Clifford Grey, Herbert Stothart, Elsie Janis and Jack Grey, the songs featured include: "Live and Love Today" (sung by Elsa Peterson); "Low Down" (sung by Lillian Roth); "We're Going Somewhere" (sung by party guests as they enter dirigible); "The Cat Walk" (performed by guests); "Ballet Electrique" (performed by Theodore Kosloff as Electricity, surrounded by costumed dancers in an electrical ballet stimulating everything from spark plugs to lightning bolts); "What Am I Bid?/Auction Number" (recited by Roland Young); "Madame" (sung by Kay Johnson); "All I Know is You Are in My Arms" (sung and danced by Reginald Denny and Kay Johnson); "Low Down" (reprise by Lillian Roth, later sung by Kay Johnson); and "Madame" (reprise by Kay Johnson).

Not the usual Cecil B. DeMillion dollar spectacle for which he is most famous, but like his better known Biblical epics, this modern-day story has enough costumes to go around, especially the ones worn at the masquerade party. After repeated viewing, MADAM Satan comes across like a typical Norma Shearer and Robert Montgomery drawing room comedy or something directed by George Cukor. At other times it leaves to the imagination of an Ernst Lubitsch sex comedy, but nearly fails on all counts. What saves this from becoming a total disaster is the oddball costume party. Without seeing his name on the credits, it would be hard to imagine MADAM Satan directed by DeMille, best known for religious epics, but it should be known that DeMille did specialized in this sort of comedy in the silent era with those starring Gloria Swanson, some years before director Ernst Lubitsch set the standard.

MADAM Satan might have succeeded had the story been shortened and vocalizing dubbed for Kay Johnson. Because Johnson at times resembles or plays like a slightly mature Irene Dunne, a movie like MADAM SATIN would have called for the likeness of Dunne, both actress and singer, then under contract to RKO Radio. Lillian Roth's performance as the fun-loving other woman does spark some life into her character, which is no different from the roles she performed at her home lot of Paramount at the time. On the whole, the one who comes off best and memorably in MADAM Satan is Roland Young as Jim, who assumes some of the film's witty one liners (Tyler Brooke: "I've never repented a sin," Young: "I've never repeated one,") and funnier actions. First to try to pass off Trixie (Roth) as his wife to Angela, who knows her husband's friend is only making the pretense to cover up for her husband's infidelity. The pretense reaches an amusing climax when Jim has to undress and get in bed with "his wife," with Angela's constant intrusions. Following the airship disaster where all the party guests must parachute from the dirigible, all landing around Central Park ranging from inside a convertible with another couple smooching in the front seat to the reservoir. As for Young's character, he lands on a tree branch inside a lion's cage in the zoo. Below he watches the lions roaring up at him. He then observes a sign that reads when the next feeding time is for the lions will be. He then slowly looks at his watch. Regardless of slow pacing, the redeeming quality goes to Young, who even has the final closing rather than the leading players.

MADAM Satan was distributed on video cassette in the 1990s, and can be seen occasionally during the late night hours on Turner Classic Movies. Movies dealing with wives putting their unsuspecting husbands to the test are usually fun to see, but while MADAM Satan might be categorized as one of the weakest of the lot, it does propose some redeeming qualities that make this one of the most unusual production by either or both DeMille and MGM. (**)
21 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Outlandish genre-hopping entertainment
gridoon20246 January 2018
Warning: Spoilers
People sure knew how to throw a party in those days! "Madam Satan" may be the only bedroom farce / musical / disaster movie ever made. It's also one of those movies which justify Cecil B. DeMille's reputation as an envelope-pushing grand entertainer. The costumes & props must be seen to be believed - there is even a futuristic element to them. Three out of the four leads give modern performances; only Reginald Denny is a little bland. The film also has its share of saucy lines & situations. The one aspect which hasn't dated well is the singing - maybe because of the early sound recording, much of it comes across as indecipherable screeching. Loyal fans of "Married With Children" will remember an episode with almost the exact same plot! *** out of 4.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Jaw dropping. Noel Coward Meets the Ten Commandments. Closet Drama opens into Zeppelin Spectacle
dizozza31 July 2000
Difficult times for affluent married couple when wife interrupts her organ playing to put drunk husband to bed with his chum for the afternoon. To condemn their wasteful leisure time may lead viewers to consider the waste of our own, until suddenly the invitation to a masked ball on a zeppelin transpires into a black and white hallucination. No, it doesn't explode at its launch tower, but the zeppelin does break loose in a storm and crash, and before doing so, instructs us how to parachute out. The movie is unforgettable. Sorry for the obscure reference, but the Kate Bush "Babooshka" song summarizes the Noel Coward-like script. The wife's costume, her singing at the drop of the hat, her performance, and her general display of dignity alert me to the possibility of enjoying other deMille films. I used to consider his flat direction of dialogue scenes stultifying (like watching skulls dry) while falling off the chair at the sight of his special effects. No, the entire film is mystical and I'm interested in seeing more. 1930!
28 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Perhaps the weirdest Hollywood film of the 30s.
planktonrules18 July 2014
The strangest thing in this film might be the morality of the plot. Folks today seem to think that films of the 30s were all stodgy and prudish. Well, this might be true of movies made AFTER mid-1934 when a toughened Production Code was adopted by the studios. But, before that, films were perhaps even wilder than they are today. Stuff like nudity, adultery, abortion, homosexuality, premarital sex and even bestiality were to be found in many of the Hollywood films. In fact, the films were becoming so family-unfriendly, that people stopped attending pictures and the studios started to worry about not surviving the Depression. So, in an effort spurred on far more by economics than morality, Hollywood adopted this very draconian code. Now, in the 'cleaned up Hollywood', you had wholesomeness and virtue...and it became just a bit boring at times. Now I LOVE films of the 1934-1950 era--but occasionally the morality in them seems silly--married couples weren't allowed to be in bed together at the same time, evil was ALWAYS punished by the end of the film (wow...wouldn't it be nice if real life was that way!) and women definitely did NOT enjoy sex...at least not decent women! And, as for the indecent women, as I said, in the end, evil is ALWAYS punished! But none of these Post-Code rules apply to films like "Madam Satan".

This Cecil B. DeMille* film begins with a lovely wife, Angela (Kay Johnson) waiting and waiting for her no-good husband, Bob (Reginald Denny) to return home. However, the guy has been out whooping it up with his friend--drinking (this is during Prohibition, by the way) and chasing other women. Surprisingly, Angela is rather good-natured about it--and seems to accept the age-old notion that 'boys will be boys'. However, Bob is a real jerk. Not only isn't he apologetic but blames Angela for being too boring. In fact, he later announces that he's leaving, as his mistress is much more of a woman than Angela will ever be! At this point you'd assume Angela would be ready to kill or divorce this worm--this WOULD be the case in the Post-Code world. Instead, after getting over her initial hurt and shock, she's decided to cook up a plan to get him back! After all, in this era, men must be excused their little...peccadilloes (a nice word used at the time to cover a multitude of sins...but mostly adultery).

What exactly is the plan? Well, it all unfolds during an insane society costume party--the most bizarre party EVER thrown on this planet--and not just because of its locale but because of the costumes and song and dance numbers! A bunch of rich philanderers rent out a zeppelin (you know, one of those massive airships like the Hindenburg) and invite all their mistresses for a rip-roaring good time. Naturally Bob and his floozy are there. However, just before this woman is crowned the Belle of the Ball, in steps Madam Satan--a very mysterious masked woman of the world. And Madam Satan is NOT there to make new friends or go for a zeppelin ride...nope. She's there to screw Bob...and she's not very subtle about it! Using her thick foreign accent, she vamps Bob and announces 'who wants to go to Hell with Madam Satan?'. Well, obviously Bob does, and he pursues this mystery woman like a dog chasing after a pork chop! Eventually, Bob discovers who this mystery woman is that he so wants to....um...get to know better. But, before he can deal with this, the zeppelin breaks loose from its mooring mast and goes careening through the clouds! Then, the costumed party-goers and crew jump from the airship and parachute to the ground...with a few comical (and one mildly racist) scenes as the folks land.

Does this sound completely crazy? Of course. But the craziest part are the costumes and sets. It must have cost a fortune to make the film and this was at the worst part of the Depression!! Just think of the millions of folks out of work and a film about Madam Satan vamping a rich no-goodnick like Bob! Crazy...but almost impossible to stop watching! If you want to see it, you can get a copy from Amazon, Turner Classic Movies' website or perhaps they'll show it again on TCM. You DEFINITELY ain't seen nothing' yet with this one!!

*If you are an old film nut, you'll probably recognize DeMille as the guy who brought us a long series of overblown religious epics like "The Ten Commandments".
23 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Has to be seen to be believed
Igenlode Wordsmith28 May 2014
This is a totally bizarre amalgam of at least three different films: a wisecracking sex-comedy, an unsuccessful operetta, and a bedroom-hopping farce. Add into that mix 'disaster movie' and 'fashion parade', and you get a film that's worth seeing just for its jaw-dropping novelty value alone.

It's actually pretty good: most of the humour is intentional, and some of the rest of it may well be. (I'm not sure quite how seriously the film takes itself: I got the impression that the heroine is pretty much in the know about what is going on, for example, and is simply playing innocent when it suits her... either to get the information she's after, or merely in order to watch her misbehaving husband squirm.) Farce isn't my thing, but those scenes are pretty slickly done, while a lot of the risqué dialogue sparkles.

Sadly the film suffers from primitive sound recording techniques, to the extent that most of the lyrics of the musical sections are incomprehensible -- not too much of a problem for the stand-alone numbers, but a big issue for the ensemble songs that are supposed to drive the later part of the plot. A lot of the verbal punchlines to the visual jokes at the masquerade disappeared into the background fuzz, as well: for example, I still don't know what on earth Bob's costume was supposed to be, because I missed the announcement as he entered.

As a musical "Madam Satan" is not very successful: it's a story of missed opportunities (Cole Porter, Rudolf Friml, Oscar Hammerstein II, Sigmund Romberg and even Albert Ketelbey of "In a Monastery Garden" fame were all considered to write the musical numbers at one time or another, as were Jeanette MacDonald and Gloria Swanson for the lead). The operetta numbers are unmemorable -- the 'popular' numbers from Jack King and Elsie Janis have worn better in performance style, although you still won't find yourself whistling them as you leave.

There are lengthy ballet/costume sequences in the second half of the film that appear to be basically the equivalent of the gratuitous fashion parade colour reels that crop up in various 1930s films -- simply inserted into the story as an excuse to show off the spectacle. They are staggeringly extravagant, but to my taste the display dragged a bit after a while. (Watching all the revellers subsequently attempt to don parachute harnesses on top of these costumes, however, tends to confirm me in my suspicion that the film really doesn't take itself seriously!) And we learn, to my amazement at least, that on a dirigible the parachutes are not actually packed on the wearer's back but attached to casings in the hull itself -- no wonder the harnesses look weirdly skeletal. You can't simply jump free wearing a parachute: you have to be clipped on first...

The parachute sequence is another piece of disaster-comedy that has to be seen to be believed. On the whole I'd say that the film is at least 60% successful: MGM might have done better if they had ditched the musical elements altogether, since this is probably the weakest strand and the box office was saturated by musicals at this point, and gone flat out for shock value. It's certainly worth seeing for sheer bizarreness.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"I Want My Parachute"
bkoganbing7 June 2011
The second of three films that Cecil B. DeMille did for MGM and in which he made his sound debut was Madam Satan and a lot of reviewers have said this is a strange movie. Strange that it is a bit weird, but not so strange in that DeMille made many silent screen comedies that all kinds of interesting and decadent settings. A high society masquerade ball in a dirigible would be right in keeping with those films. But after Madam Satan he never made another like this.

The plot of Madam Satan is kind of like The Guardsman with the shoe on the other foot. Wife Kay Johnson has discovered that her husband Reginald Denny has been stepping out with flapper girl Lillian Roth. She determines to win him back so if hot and sexy is what moves Reggie, Kay can be just as hot and sexy as Lil.

Their friend society playboy Roland Young is throwing a big masquerade ball on a dirigible and Kay goes as the mysterious and masked Madam Satan. She definitely turns a lot of heads including Denny's. But during a thunderstorm, lightning strikes the big balloon and loosens it from its moorings.

After that Madam Satan becomes a harbinger of the disaster movies of the Seventies. This is DeMille doing what he does best, big and gaudy spectacle. It's the main reason to see Madam Satan today.

The film tanked big time at the box office. It might have done better just a year earlier before the Stock Market crash, but in September of 1930 when it was released audiences in the Depression just couldn't get worked up for a bunch of high society people in big trouble. Those that could afford a ticket price probably cheered as the great blimp went down.

Still Madam Satan remains an interesting if dated piece of cinema.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Classic example of a cult film
jeffsultanof21 September 2012
Warning: Spoilers
There are a few films that simply defy description. In the early days of sound, every movie seemed to be an experiment of some type. Some have held up quite well, but most are only of interest to historians and buffs. A few are simply unbelievable. Golden Dawn, for example, leaves audiences totally speechless (that Oscar Hammerstein II contributed to this disaster is fascinating).

For many years, the three MGM films that Cecil B. DeMille were rarely seen nor discussed. When they were finally unearthed, "Dynamite" turned out to be rather good, particularly since it had great performances by Charles Bickford and Kay Johnson. "The Squaw Man" has its champions, but not many; it was clearly a hand-me-down from a different era. It was DeMille's second MGM film that is remembered more than the other two. As other reviews state, it is one of the strangest movies made by any director. The fact that it was made by DeMille makes it truly a cult item.

First of all, what made DeMille think that a movie about infidelity among the rich would bring in audiences in the first wave of the depression? Clearly this was supposed to be a drawing-room comedy that had a lot of music and singing. The script is woefully unfunny and dated even for 1930, with everyone trying too hard (Roland Young and Reginald Denny are just plain embarrassing). Johnson was a good actress, but I can't imagine any actress of the time pulling off this role. Modern day audiences scream with laughter when the first song is sung by Johnson's maid, as it comes from out of nowhere, and then Johnson 'talks' the rest of the song. Lillian Roth does the best she can, and actually adds some energy to a rather staid first-half. This first sequence is long and ultimately boring, being neither funny nor ultimately interesting.

The second half is the party sequence on the zeppelin, something only DeMille could come up with. It's a pity that this was not released in color, as the costumes and overall set design are impressive even in black and white. This sequence is spectacular, surreal and beyond indulgent, and once again, depression audiences could not have taken comfort in the sheer waste of money that certainly shows on the screen. I would love to have seen Louis B. Mayer's face after seeing this movie.

This is certainly worth a look once.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
"She will ensnare you"
Steffi_P14 June 2009
There are some directors who failed and faltered in the sound revolution. There are others who made a success of the new form and were even revitalised by it. Cecil B. DeMille is perhaps in a league of his own, who with Madam Satan created a work suffering from all the awkwardness of the worst early talkies, and yet one gloriously weird and wonderful in a way that only his pictures could be.

It's true; Madam Satan is incredibly stilted and static in its construction. I'm not referring to the anchored camera – DeMille didn't really rely on camera movement anyway. But like many early talkies it places too much importance on dialogue, and is structured like a stage play with very long and very wordy scenes. The sound recording is appalling and sometimes we can hear dialogue when characters are in long shot, which seems very unnatural. Like most early musicals the numbers are spoiled by indecipherable operatic vocals.

But never fear! Madam Satan was scripted by the delightfully barmy Jeanie Macpherson. What's more we find DeMille, ever with his finger to the wind, putting his own grandiose and unashamedly smutty spin on the bedroom-comedy musical genre that was making such a splash at his old stomping ground, Paramount. The result is one of the most unintentionally surreal pictures I have ever seen. We begin with some Lubitsch-esque bed-hopping comedy scenes, sprinkled with a few songs. We then decamp to a fancy-dress party on board a Zeppelin (why not?) for an extended musical sequence, which looks like the result of Fritz Lang hiring Busby Berkeley to direct a scene in Metropolis. Just as the characters' passions start to run away with them, it suddenly turns into a disaster movie – a bit of a DeMille-Macpherson trademark, that.

Madam Satan is also special in that it is perhaps the only DeMille comedy which is actually rather funny. The occasionally witty dialogue was probably Gladys Unger's contribution to the screenplay, but what really makes it work is the excellent comic timing and rapport of Reginald Denny, Lillian Roth and Roland Young. In comparison to these three very satisfying cast members, leading lady Kay Johnson seems rather bland, and has "poor-man's Jeanette MacDonald" written all over her.

Most of the songs are by Herbert Stothart, who would soon rise to become MGM's in-house composer. Musically they are fairly forgettable, although it's interesting how they are used to define character and drive the plot forward in a way that later became standard but was by no means a given in the very earliest musicals. DeMille, always a very rhythmic director, shoots some great dance numbers, and shows great musical sensitivity for the "All I Know Is You're in My Arms" number, tracking along with the silhouetted dancers, and putting in a wonderful slow tilt when they are still, corresponding to the swell in the music. It's a shame this was his only musical.

Madam Satan has got to be one of the weirdest film experiences I have ever had, and after my first viewing I wasn't quite sure if perhaps I dreamt it. It was (sniff) the last significant contribution to a DeMille picture by Jeanie Macpherson, and while all his work after this was filled with adventure and spectacle, they were missing a certain something that only she could bring. Madam Satan is however an appropriately daffy swansong – a boozy, art-deco, all-talking, all-dancing concotion that is worth watching for its sheer oddness.
48 out of 50 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Psychotically weird - you cannot take your eyes off of it
kira02bit5 December 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Just caught this film on TCM and WOW! Anyone who thinks they did not make some bonkers entertainment in the 1930s needs to reassess. I thought it was going to be a standard MGM musical, but it genre skips throughout its run time.

Kay Johnson is perfectly cast as a classy society wife, who stoically tolerates the philandering and foolishness of her immature cad husband Reginald Denny, who has been carrying an adulterous affair with brassy brunette Lillian Roth (whose tragic life story can be seen as I'll Cry Tomorrow starring Susan Hayward). Johnson gives him plenty of time to come clean and apologize, but Denny is a jerk of the first order. Not only does he take his wife for granted and consistently stands her up, but then lays the blame for it all at her door by claiming she is too stodgy and cold for a man like him before storming out. Even Denny's buffoonish friend and co-hort Roland Young (pre-Topper) finds his treatment of Johnson outlandish.

Johnson decides to take matters into her own hands. She pretends to believe Denny's lies about Roth actually being Young's new wife and shows up on their doorstep and demands to stay the night, causing the floozy and the friend great consternation. Only exacerbated when Denny shows up to seek solace in Roth's arms.

Just when we think that the film is a marital comedy and some version of Private Lives, the film takes a sudden turn south of sanity in the second half. Young holds a lavish debauched masquerade party for rich philanderers and a gaggle of nubile young things aboard a zeppelin. The costumes are amazing. While there had been some standard song and dance numbers sprinkled throughout previously, we now get some of the strangest numbers I have ever seen. Including one where the guests make like the mechanized workings of the zeppelin.

There is a wacko auction of the women and right when Roth is set to take center stage, her limelight is stolen by the arrival of the mysterious masked Madam Satan (Johnson), sporting a barely there dress and a French accent. She struts and purrs and vamps - capturing the wandering eye of her faithless husband and playing him for a fool by demonstrating that the fire he sought was there all along, while Roth fumes from the sidelines.

The whole thing culminates in a violent storm that tears the zeppelin from its moorings and suddenly we are in a wacko disaster movie. The scantily clad women and and masked buffoons are forced to parachute from the disintegrating zeppelin to save their lives in a creepily prescient sequence that foreshadows the upcoming Hindenberg disaster.

Its weird, its tonally all over the place, but it is impossible to tear your eyes away from it. The film definitely has laughs and a few thrills. Johnson is actually quite marvelous moving her character from a lovely but tolerant dishrag to a feisty sex bomb. Young is a lot of fun as the friend who keeps trying to do the right thing and often coming out the worse for it. Roth sings well and has good comic timing.

Unfortunately the weak link in the cast is Denny. The character is written and played as a total unrepentant jerk and later a laughable hypocrite. We never get any kind of idea what occupation he holds since he only uses his work as an excuse to his wife so he can drink and cheat. He is not particularly charming or charismatic. While pleasant looking, he certainly does not exude the sex appeal to sell why either Johnson or Roth would find him worth so much effort.

While one must take in the view of the times, it becomes apparent early on that Johnson is too good for him. Her lot would actually improve by leaving him to Roth, who in turn would probably get tired of him quickly. He offers nothing to make one understand why these women are fighting over him, when he should be kicked to the curb.

That said, the attitude in other areas of the film is eye-opening for anyone who thinks the times were staid. Johnson is able to demonstrate that she can be both a demure society wife and a hot-blooded temptress. Also interesting is that Roth's character is as unrepentant in her own way as Denny and suffers no comeuppance for her behavior. Post-code films would have demanded she suffer, be brought down a peg or offed in the disaster portion of the film, but this film takes a different track altogether.

Definitely a wild ride. I would agree with some of the other reviewers that the second half really makes the film memorable. It may not be great art, but you darn well would be hard-pressed to forget it any time soon.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
An over-stuffed turkey with peacock feathers attached.
mark.waltz24 July 2015
Warning: Spoilers
The middle of the avenue rating is based upon my feeling that this deserves to be seen as a curious piece of bad taste of the early years of talking films, Cecil B. DeMille's attempt to do the kind of films he was famous for doing during the silent era. The first half of the film is a gruelish bore; Wife Kay Johnson attempts to keep her marriage intact even though husband Reginald Denny turning to the vampish Lillian Roth. Kay is basically a placid character, too sweet to hate and definitely too boring to have wifely feelings for. The film goes down the whole "A Fool There Was" frame of mind with Kay turning herself into the vampish Madam Satan to win Denny back from slutty Roth, showing up at the most outlandish party that any metropolis has seen. In fact, much of this sequence (A party aboard a zeppelin) looks like the silent film "Metropolis" and becomes one of the most outrageous examples of pretentious audaciousness, throwing in some antique looking musical numbers that had showed up in such early movie musicals as "Sunny Side Up" and "Just Imagine".

Having seen the Lunts do this much better in "The Guardsman" and Norma Shearer changing her own image in the less creaky "Let Us Be Gay", it is surprising that Louis B. Mayer didn't see that this was a retread of stuff already on the production schedule. It's the perfect example of a need for "less is more", that the garishness of the sets and costumes (most likely recycled from some of the movie musicals which MGM had already made, and much better) make this a pictorial reference to what bad taste in 1930 would look at. The whole plot really makes no sense when you put the two halves together as one, and it at times seems like two totally different films. When the zeppelin explodes threatening to kill everybody aboard, I rolled my eyes so far back I could almost see into the past. Fortunately, DeMille would tone things down slightly, making his historical epics at Paramount so much better than what came out of this. Had it not made me laugh at it so much I surely would consider this one of the greatest bombs ever to flatten out the Culver City lot. This is where Leo almost roared "the end"!
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
An over the top comedy, musical and disaster film!
Rich-9912 July 1999
"Madame Satan" is one of those movies that is not sure what it is but is having a grand time trying to figure it out. Part bedroom farce (where in pre code days couples sleep in the same bed), romantic comedy, musical and at its climax a disaster film. Its basic plot follows the misadventures of a married couple as they try to relight the spark in their marriage. The climax is a costume ball aboard a zeppelin (the musical production numbers here are pretty spectacular) that eventually ends in the zeppelin's crash in a storm. The effects are all done with miniatures and they really are quite impressive. The cast , especially Roland Young, are quite good though at times hesitant. You get the impression that in this early talkie the actors are not yet comfortable with sound but that is a minor quibble. All in all it is a fun over the top film that rarely has a dull moment.
30 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A Decent Effort
tjohn7576924 October 2013
a decent movie... some of the acting was a bit wooden. Reginald Denny as Bob was, well not very good. Not sure if he was there more for his voice and looks than his actual acting ability. The movie lagged a bit at the beginning as the story centered on Angela trying to spy on her husband Bob and his trysts with showgirl Trixie. There were some funny pieces and I did like some of Jimmy's one-liners. A bit strange in places. For instance what the heck was that whole dance number at the beginning of the ball scene? The masquerade scene as they introduced each character was very visual and the costumes on the each were amazing. And Kay Johnson looked stunning as Madam Satan. Though I could have done without her fake French accent It was interesting nonetheless , and I think overall a good effort. Though what did happen to Trixie at the end?
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Ridiculous Misfire
Derutterj-111 February 2008
A terrible, lavish, early talkie from Cecil B. DeMille, that I couldn't make heads or tails of until I saw his 1925 melodrama The Golden Bed. Madame Satan in reality was DeMille's last foray into domestic comedy-drama among the very rich, a theme he had been doing pretty consistently since 1918. Film buffs tend to overlook that genre—speaking for myself, it all seems too gauche and mediocre to take time evaluating—and look at the big epics. But there they are: gobs of money made titillating naïve Jazz Age audiences with supposed glimpses into the foibles and follies of spoiled wives, their mogul husbands, frivolous friends and treacherous roué-hangers-on. There is the fixation on overbuilt, ludicrous, luxury bathrooms and wild parties. Very hard to swallow for a contemporary viewer; this throwing onto the screen of high-living and consumer greed, redeemed by unctuous moralistic retribution, was a creature strictly of 1920s America.

Madame Satan was DeMille's attempt to extend this theme into the talkie period, but the extreme artificiality of this type of film only became intensified with the addition of sound. Normally I would say, as others have, to sit through the build-up, such as described above, to the thrilling disaster movie climax aboard the stricken party dirigible. But don't. If you can see the climax in a compilation film or fast forward to it at home, okay, but do not bother with any other part of Madame Satan at all. The talents of Denny, Johnson and Young, and the great MGM sets notwithstanding: it's just not worth it. You won't be able to get away from the silly, plodding, unfunny thud the first part of this movie makes as it shuffles through your mind.
7 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Tepid Affair to Remember
rsyung14 April 2004
I found Madam Satan a rather strange hybrid of melodrama and musical, with elements of sex farce thrown in for good measure. It is divided into two distinct halves: the first takes place at the home of Bob and Angela, and at Trixie's flat. Then, it's aboard a moored Zeppelin for the second half for the party and the bulk of the musical numbers. A few witty ripostes here and there, some occasionally charming musical numbers, but overall a rather tepid affair. I just don't think Reginald Denny and Kay Johnson have the onscreen charisma to do this story justice. Roland Young is always amusing with his befuddled manner, in a sort of warm up to his Topper movies, but with Denny and Johnson to play against, he becomes the most interesting character by default.

But the film is interesting in its moralizing about straying husbands and a wife's duty to spice up the marriage, considering DeMille's own unsatisfactory marriage and philandering ways. Setting the second half aboard a Zeppelin with its sinking ship analogies probably seemed very modern at the time, and it is interesting to note that even six years before the Hindenburg disaster, a Hollywood movie exploits the inherent danger to such a mode of transportation. Perhaps with a really sparkling script by a master screenwriter such as Robert Riskin, and more luminous leads, this could have been a major delight instead of a trifle.
20 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Bizarre...and not very good
preppy-38 April 2004
Bob (Reginald Deny) and Angela (Kay Johnson) are married...but not happily. Bob is cheating on his wife with Trixie (Lillian Roth). But Angela is determined to get him back. At a costume party held on a zeppelin (don't ask) she comes in disguise as Madam Satan to win him back.

The plot is conventional at first. It starts off as a very poor, unfunny comedy drama with Angela discovering Bob is cheating and confronting Trixie. This is the entire first hour--chock full on horrendous dialogue, bad acting (Roth SCREAMS every line) and some of the worst comedy ever captured on film.

I was ready to turn it off when the costume party started. It starts off with some VERY elaborate costumes (I wish this film had been made in color) and a strange musical number. Then Angela shows up as Satan and we get MORE wooden dialogue and silly lines between her Bob. It all ends with the zeppelin being hit by lightning and everybody having to parachute out.

Sounds fun--but it's not. There are musical numbers sprinkled throughout the film--and all of them are bad. And this party aboard a zeppelin??? Is that a joke or are we supposed to take it seriously? But, most of all, this movie is just plain dull.

The few good points are: a good performance by Johnson; Deny isn't bad either and he's tall, handsome and muscular; the costumes ARE incredible; the special effects aren't bad and this is one of the few films Lillian Roth made (too bad she's lousy).

Worth seeing for film buffs--but nobody else.
8 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
wacky DeMille film on a zeppelin
ksf-24 October 2018
Directed by the one and only C.B. DeMille, this one was prior to the film code being enforced, so we are allowed to view mature themes. When Angela gets sick of her husband Bob staying out all night, she sets a trap to teach him a lesson. Reginal Denny and Kay Johnson star in this early talkie from MGM. Ann Sothern and Ann Dvorak are listed as extras on imdb. Sound and picture are both pretty ok. Parts of the film go on way too long, such as when Angela tries to trap the guys as they tell their lies about staying out all night. and again later, when two un-married people pretend to be getting ready for bed. it really drags on. both those scenes should have been edited shorter. One fun thing is when she and her maid sing to each other, while discussing the men in their lives. That's one talented maid!! And a really cute song and dance number when Lillian Roth (plays the other woman...) and Eddie Prinz do a rehearsal of "Low Down". When husband and wife attend a costume ball in a zeppelin, Angela tests her husband by dressing up as a satanic character during the ball. An ironic moment, when they sing "We're Going Somewhere", and the very next song is "Where do We Go From Here?". Shows on Turner Classic. Good for an early talkie, and certainly a little piece of history from DeMille. and even some special effects during the dance numbers in the dirigible. but didn't need to be 116 minutes long.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Highly improbable
beanybeanwhite3 December 2021
It's almost two movies in one: the action before the airship, which pokes along and once onboard, when it goes a bit haywire.

The Madam Satan dress alone is worth the price of admission. With its flames and sequins and the "cut out" designs and its crazy spikes sleeves, it is just too much.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Three different movies mashed together
jellopuke17 March 2020
The first part is a bedroom farce, then it becomes a weird musical, before becoming a disaster movie. Mashed together it doesn't work as a whole at all and it's not only because of the early sound movie problems that all early 30's movies have. The only really must see part is the strange machinery dance number that's right out of a german expressionist movie.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Over the top and unique
gbill-7487719 December 2017
Warning: Spoilers
The first part of this movie is just awful, and I think everyone but the most forgiving of viewers will find themselves rolling their eyes, cringing, or maybe even snoozing. The acting is poor, the cadence of the dialogue awkward, and character motivations often nonsensical. All I can say is, stick with it. There is silliness throughout the movie, but it gets much more entertaining as it develops, and there are some pretty wild scenes that ultimately made me like it, somewhat to my surprise.

The premise of the movie is an age-old theme; a wife (Kay Johnson) does not like her husband's late nights boozing it up and philandering (he's played by Reginald Denny), while he doesn't like her coolness and lack of passion. "Don't you understand? Love can't be kept in cold storage. It's a battery that has to be recharged every day," he says, with clear sexual overtones. However, she's aware that he's having an affair, having found a note from his mistress (Lillian Roth) after he comes home drunk with a buddy (Roland Young). As a little indication of the silliness, the two men are sloppy to the point that they're showering with one another with their clothes on. Husband and wife argue and separate, even though it's clear they still love one another.

Lillian Roth really lights up the screen and gives the movie its first real spark with her short musical number, "Low Down", shaking her hips and twirling about with a top hat (Google this one for a treat). When Johnson confronts Roth at the end of a mostly insufferable scene where all four principals are in her apartment, Roth points out that men, including Johnson's husband, appreciate her spiciness and fun. "What do I give him? I laugh when he does. I drink when he does! I give him a pal with lips to kiss and shoulders to hug. I give him a dream made out of perfume and soft lights. I jazz all the dullness out of his soul for him!" she says, warbling with a voice that sounds like pure 1930. Johnson vows to "raise her temperature" to win her husband back, and storms out.

It's at this point that the movie gets good. Cut to a masquerade ball on a dirigible (of course!). The outfits (designed by Adrian) are wild, and the opening musical number is as well. Roth is getting a lot of attention from the men until Kay Johnson makes her dramatic appearance. Her transformation into 'Madame Satan' is excellent, and she really pulls off dressing up as a vixen, slinking around in a sexy outfit. Her husband finds himself attracted without knowing who she is, and things get crazy when the weather gets stormy. Suddenly we find ourselves in a disaster movie, and seven years before the Hindenburg.

Director Cecil B. DeMille botched the first half of the movie, but really makes up for it in the second, with lots of nice moments, drama mixed with comedy, and risqué dialogue. The male performances from Denny and Young are pretty poor, but Roth and Johnson (when she's Madame Satan) make up for it. I may be rounding up a bit, but weirdly, I wound up liking it, and would watch it again.
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"A heat wave is coming."
utgard147 April 2020
Well it's certainly a curiosity. The first forty-five minutes to an hour is pretty boring. Lots of handwringing melodrama and old-fashioned ideas about what a woman needs to do to keep her man and so on. The second hour is where the money is. DeMille eccentricity on full display with wild costumes and sets and an exciting climax involving a zeppelin crash. The songs are not great. The number where Madam Satan reveals herself is intriguing because of the costumes and stuff but her singing style (think of a bird trill) gave me the creeps. The best thing about this is that it's a nice-looking film.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
You can't imagine how bad the end of this movie is until you see it
richard-178728 September 2018
But even then, you may not be able to believe it's really as awful as what you are seeing.

The first 50 minutes of this movie is a standard 1930s melodrama: philandering husband cheats on wife, who discovers that there is "another woman" and confronts her. (If you've ever seen "The Women", you've seen this done much better.) It's best just skipped.

The rest of the movie takes place in a dirigible - yes, I'm not kidding - and goes from bizarre to whatever is past bizarre.

For most of the dirigible scene, Kay Johnson does a very good imitation/satire of Greta Garbo. Not just the accent, but the body movements and everything. You realize that Norma Shearer must have watched this movie before she made Idiot's Delight.

But then the dirigible breaks loose and starts to fall apart, and you suddenly realize that you are watching a 1930 predecessor to Poseiden Adventure - a very bad predecessor. People start jumping out of the dirigible with parachutes, and the dialogue, which had never been good, becomes awful.

It seems impossible to believe that this movie was released by a major studio, but it was. You have to see it to understand how awful it gets, but is it really worth your time to do that?
5 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
DeMille Rampant
Ron Oliver19 November 2004
A desperate wife disguises herself as the mysterious MADAME Satan in order to entice the attentions of her wayward husband.

In 1928, movie magnet Cecil B. DeMille, usually associated with Paramount Studios, signed a three-picture contract with mighty MGM. The most exuberant result of this new association--the others were DYNAMITE (1929) and THE SQUAW MAN (1931)--was this bizarre, florid, highly unusual and very entertaining musical-comedy-soap opera which almost defies categorization in any other way than to simply say it is a 'DeMille Picture.'

It was also the only musical he attempted (1930 was a year replete with singing stars enjoying--or abusing--the new sound technology) and perhaps that is a good thing, as the tunes here don't warble too well and are a bit of an embarrassment. Although the tale of marital infidelity which dominates the film's first half grows rather mawkish, DeMille awakes the audience in the second half by staging a naughty masquerade ball in a luxurious dirigible, no less, harbored high above New York City. Never one to let bad taste stand in his way, DeMille invites the viewer to wallow in Pre-Code purulence, before ending on a more moralistic note.

Kay Johnson, a very talented & lovely actress who is now sadly forgotten, gives a lively performance as the abandoned wife determined to win back her fickle spouse. She deftly weaves between drama & spoofery, making her dynamically diabolic appearance as the title character at the airship ball both mysterious and alluring. As her husband, Reginald Denny comes across as much more one-dimensional and unsympathetic, but then his role is supposed to register as rather bland when compared to that of Miss Johnson.

Owlish Roland Young is humorous, as always, this time playing Denny's best friend; his meek persona must hide a streak of wildness, however, to be able to host the truly bizarre zeppelin party. As Denny's young lover, Lillian Roth is all shrill, uncultured brashness--if this is what the director wanted, she hits the bulls-eye.

Movie mavens will recognize DeMille's own voice as the radio announcer at the end of the film.
24 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Precursor of Gherardi's costumes
valfedox21 May 2023
Visually interesting movie, with visions of modern costumes that must have inspired Piero Gherardi. Acting is good, dvd quality good, Roth is very bubbly in her role. The plot does not make much sense in the 21st century, but it is significant for 1930: empowerment of women and value of eroticism. A philandering husband who hints at the value of passion in marriage and the damage it causes when it flickers and dies, the undercurrent is sexual and well expressed in the technical and morality limits of the Era. It also shows how a rather plain wife could turn into a vamp with the appropriate costumes, script and make-up, hinting at the extreme power of photo plays to create images of personality that trascend the actress. Overall a fair movie by Cecil De Mille: recommended.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
trash
HandsomeBen13 May 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Entertaining movie, but the whole time i wanted to reach through the screen and shake the heck out of angela for having no respect for herself. You get with your husband who bounces from one woman to the next, the moment a better offer comes along, and that's suppose to be a happy ending?
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed