Dreams of the Rarebit Fiend: The Pet (1921) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Drawn By Hand by Winsor McCay, Inventor of Animated Drawing
wmorrow598 March 2007
Warning: Spoilers
He's not exactly in the household word category anymore, but to fans of comic strip art Winsor McCay is a legendary figure, a pioneer visionary who created amazing vistas for the Sunday papers. For film buffs, McCay was a key figure in the history of animation, the man who almost single-handedly devised and drew the first real cartoons. He devoted four years of work to his initial effort, Little Nemo (completed in 1911), and hand-colored the results. And although he employed an assistant McCay is said to have personally inked some ten-thousand drawings for his best-known film, Gertie the Dinosaur, completed in 1914. That's a level of dedication approaching madness, especially when you consider that McCay was simultaneously producing daily comic strips and full-page color works for the Sunday papers -- and works of top quality, too.

By the early 1920s, for reasons unknown, McCay seemed to lose interest in the production of animated cartoons. Perhaps he was just getting older and slowing down. Among the last known films he worked on were three episodes of a series based on his popular comic strip "Dreams of the Rarebit Fiend," a strip which had inspired director Edwin S. Porter to a produce a famous (and still extant) trick film back in 1906. Within the rigidly unchanging format of this series McCay could let his imagination run wild: at the beginning of every installment a gentleman would eat too much rarebit (or some other rich food) and then have a wildly surreal dream; the dreams could involve space travel, time travel, inanimate objects coming to life, or -- a favorite motif -- humans, animals or objects changing size, either becoming enormous or miniaturized. McCay was never much for dialog, but his draftsmanship was extraordinary and his work had a genuinely dream-like vividness.

This series entry, The Pet, begins on a deceptively slow and quiet note, once the middle-aged married couple at the center of events fall asleep. The rarebit-eating husband dreams that a strange little dog-like creature has appeared on their lawn and that his wife has adopted it. The creature varies somewhat in size and appearance from scene to scene; its eyes are blank and the only sound it utters is "Meow," but it looks more like a cross between a calf and a dog than anything feline. Dad is increasingly unhappy as the Pet invades the conjugal bed and glides about under the covers. He moves to the sofa. Meanwhile, the Pet grows at an alarming rate. The tone of the film changes sharply when, almost as an aside, the Pet devours the family cat and then eats everything on the breakfast table, including the plates and the coffee maker. Dad goes straight to a drug store to buy a barrel full of rat poison. The Pet, who is now as big as a horse, eats all the furniture in the house as well as a pile of coal, sucks water out of the garden hose and spews it on his hosts.

By this point it's clear that what we're watching is no cute little cartoon comedy: this is a nightmare, one that some pet owners can understand. McCay is playing on that fleeting fear many of us may have experienced at one time or another that a family pet has taken over our lives, or (in more extreme cases) is genuinely malevolent or even monstrous. Animals, like humans, can turn ornery despite the best treatment. McCay takes this scenario and spins it into an impossible yet strangely familiar horror story. The most disturbing scene in the film comes when the Pet eats the entire barrel of 'Rough on Rats' poison and goes all trembly, then breaks out in disgusting-looking boils. The boils fester, but the Pet survives his ordeal and only grows larger and more powerful. He lumbers away in a trance-like state, eats a garden wall, a tree, and a car, then advances on the downtown area, now as big as a battleship. In the end, it takes the mobilization of the air force to put a stop to the rampage.

The final scenes will remind movie buffs of The Lost World, the various adventures of King Kong and Godzilla, Tex Avery's King-Size Canary, and countless sci-fi flicks in which giant creatures attack cities, but it's worth pointing out that McCay was well ahead of them all. In its 20-minute running time The Pet looks like a condensed preview of these movies, but it has an eerie, nightmarish quality all its own. I only wish this film had marked the beginning of a new phase of Winsor McCay's cinematic career; instead, it was the end of the line for this quirky, brilliant and innovative film pioneer.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Very interesting from a number of perspectives...
AlsExGal24 October 2020
... not the least of which is looking at how a middle class couple lives in 1921.

The "rarebit fiend" is the husband who has eaten a Welsh rarebit - which is nothing more than cheese toast - and has a wild dream because of it.

In the dream, "the pet" wanders up to the couple's house, looking tired and hungry. The big hearted wife takes it in. It resembles a dog, but has blank eyes so you really see no expression of menace in its face. However, feeding it makes it grow, until it eventually attains a tremendous size and threatens the city. Planes and a zeppelin are dispatched to bring it down. It does sound a bit like King Kong in the end, doesn't it?

There is a great deal of detail in the drawings, so we can see that an urban couple in 1921 has an electric toaster (the pet eats it), and there are outdoor connections to running water and hoses attached. There is a great deal of detail shown in buildings and furnishings to the point where they look like photographs in some cases.

I found it odd that at one point , before the pet becomes completely outsized, that the husband goes to a pharmacy. He calls the pharmacist "Doc" and asks for an entire barrel of rat poison which is labeled "Rough On Rats". Doing something like that today would get you labeled a terrorist, and you would walk away with no rat poison. So you could buy rat poison in 1921, but it was illegal to be sold alcohol. Oh well, all times have their ridiculous situations.

This is a very interesting animation before Walt ever got involved in the business.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The Pet is another fascinating entry in Winsor McCay's Dreams of the Rarebit Fiend
tavm6 June 2007
Warning: Spoilers
The Pet is another entry in Winsor McCay's animated series Dreams of the Rarebit Fiend. In this one, a man has just eaten a rarebit of the title. His wife has warned him about having bad dreams for doing so to no avail. As he dreams, we see outside of the house a small animal that's hard to identify but-according to the word put on screen-says, "Meow." The woman picks him up and decides to keep him. She gives him a bath and feeds him milk on a saucer a little bigger than him. After he's done, however, he becomes a little bigger than the bowl which turns over on his entire body as he leans his head forward. He later eats a cat under the table and then an electric lamp on it (and doesn't even get electrocuted!). The husband then goes to the store to get a barrel of rat poison in order to kill this "pet". After the pet eats it, he develops some splotches on his body but they disappear quickly as he keeps growing. He eventually grows as tall as the tallest building in the city as more than dozens and dozens of planes appear and shoot him to pieces as the man finally wakes up...As always, McCay gives great detail in backgrounds that make you almost forget you're watching animation. Many humorous touches throughout as when the "pet" swallows a hose before spewing water through a neighbor's window at a neighbor! And that final sequence with all those pieces of the "pet" falling down. Wow! As with anything that McCay has done, The Pet is certainly essential viewing for animation fans.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Amusing & Imaginative 'Rarebit Fiend' Feature
Snow Leopard7 June 2005
This is an amusing and imaginative 'Rarebit Fiend' feature that makes good use out of one basic idea to provide material for a number of good moments. Most of it is simple elaboration on the basic premise, but the way that Winsor McCay steadily builds things up makes it work pretty well.

This time, the rarebit-induced dream concerns an unusual pet that quickly gets out of control. As its rampage gets worse and worse, some of the shots bring to mind similar sequences from numerous later movies, such as "King Kong" and "The Lost World", and this gives "The Pet" even extra interest.

In itself, it's pretty good as well. The animation is of McCay's usual high quality, and it works quite well for its era.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Quite awkward looking early animated movie but it's all good entertainment still.
Boba_Fett113813 November 2010
This is really obviously a movie from the early days of animation. It's of course completely done by hand all and even by just one person; Winsor McCay, who before venturing into animated movies was already a successful cartoonist.

The concept of this movie also comes from a successful newspaper cartoon done by him. This movie was the first out of three, which he based on his successful comic 'Dreams of a Rarebit Fiend'.

It really isn't a very smooth and stylized looking animated movie. The character movements are extremely awkward at times for instance and the sequences really don't always flow that well. Most sequences even feel overlong and it just doesn't always get to its point quick enough. Also the animation style itself, so its characters and such really aren't anything too impressive looking. The backgrounds on the other hand were quite good looking.

But as for the actual entertainment value of the movie, it's certainly a good enough movie to watch. It has an amusing concept, which get executed well, mostly in its second half.

The movie at its beginning cites Winsor McCay as the inventor of animated drawing but this simply isn't true and seems to be an early advertisement trick. it's true though that he was the first animator who's movies became a big commercial success as well and reached a wide audience with his movies.

Very early animated movie, that is still entertaining enough to watch now days.

7/10

http://bobafett1138.blogspot.com/
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Not so innovative, but very pretty and imaginative
planktonrules8 September 2006
While this cartoon isn't as innovative as some of Winsor McCay's earlier works (such as LITTLE NEMO and GERTIE THE DINOSAUR), this later McCay film is still quite impressive when seen today. Compared to other early animations, it is a real treat because the shading and backgrounds are so well made and show a lot of care. Plus, the story is really weird and it also packs a lot of charm. As a result, here in the 21st century, it STILL is pretty watchable and exciting to watch--at least for Cinephiles and history lovers (like me).

By the way, his "rarebit" films have all seemed to imply that eating cheese causes bad or at least weird dreams! I gotta check it out and see if he was right!
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Dangers of Cheese
boblipton17 August 2002
Based on McCay's cartoon strip, DREAMS OF THE RAREBIT FIEND, this concerns a tiny creature that eats everything and grows until it threatens the entire city. A seminal work, its influence shows up in Heinlein's novel THE STAR BEAST, Tex Avery's KING SIZE CANARY and in the final sequence of KING KONG! Bizarre and brilliant!
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Disturbing...........
QueenoftheGoons29 September 2023
This never used to bother me until i took a bus trip to Malabar farms in Ohio. Found out about some psycho chick who poisoned her family with rough on rats. Well in this short, the husband says his wife brought a new pet home for him to kill so the druggist sells him rough on rats. Suddenly this is quite disturbing and i'd rather not watch it ever again but i did for years back in the VCR days when we had a VHS tape called Thrills & chills that included this and Cobweb hotel and Jasper and the haunted house which is a good one too. This thing which can almost resemble a cow or a okapi though some thought it a dog. It eats until its king kong size in which they blow it up. Just a nightmare from a guy eating a well pretty much a grilled cheese. The silent "zoo" cartoons (rated X) aren't as disturbing as this.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Pet on the Loose
Michael_Elliott2 May 2012
Dreams of the Rarebit Fiend: The Pet (1921)

*** (out of 4)

Winsor McCay classic that makes you feel that the filmmakers of THE LOST WORLD and KING KONG might have been influenced by this. A husband brags about eating a delicious rarebit but this food always gives him weird dreams. In the dream, the wife takes in a cute animal and soon after it just keeps eating and eating while getting bigger and bigger. The thing eventually grows to the size where it begins to terrorize the city. McCay made three different "Dreams of the Rarebit Fiend" films in 1921 and this here is certainly the best of the bunch. One could argue the creative issues seeing as how all three were pretty much the same story with different dreams but this here is so creative that you can't help but fall for it. The entire film has a very bizarre atmosphere working for it and a lot of credit has to go to McCay for coming up with such a strange looking animal. It's part pig, part dog and part teddy bear but it's certainly something impossible to forget. I thought the animation was a major step up from his previous films and just check out the scene where the animals is eating what appears to be beans off the floor. Just pay attention to the way the pile goes down as the creature eats them. Fans of McCay will certainly want to check this one out but fans of the surreal and bizarre should enjoy it as well.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Early use of dream sequence the most memorable aspect (and the creature of course)
Horst_In_Translation31 July 2016
Warning: Spoilers
"The Pet" is a 12-minute cartoon from 1921, so this one is already 95 years old. It is an entry to American animation pioneer Winsor McCay's "Dreams of the Rarebit Fiend" series and it's possibly the best one. I was tempted for a while to give this one a 6 out of 10, but I will say shortly why I decided not to. Of course, this is a black-and-white silent film still. There are two stories in here. The frame includes a man and woman lying in bad and the man has eaten a rarebit (a toast full of baked cheese, I had to check that) before sleeping and we get to see his nightmare that resulted from the meal. His woman takes in a tiny pet and keeps feeding it until it becomes bigger. Bad news is it won't stop growing and at the very end it is about as big as a dinosaur and wreaks havoc in the city. I liked the way the creature looked I must say, but I also think that the story is so simple that it is almost not enough for over 10 minutes. I also did not like the way they got back to reality at the very end showing us the couple, but only very briefly. Nobody says something, nobody does something and the film is over. This is a very early example of a dream sequence in film, something that is used very frequently nowadays. All in all, it was a good cartoon for its time I guess, but I would only recommend it to film historians because there are indeed some flaws in here.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed