Let's start with the positives. Danny Aiello, Samuel Jackson, Rosie Perez, and Frank Vincent were all clear bright-spots in this film. Each of these actors put on a good performance and felt authentic in their role. With that being said, with the exception of Jackson, the other actors were likely behaving more than they were acting. Another positive was the camera work. There were some cool POV shots, a few cool tracking shots, and some excellent use of lighting and shadows. I thought that the ice cube scene in Tina's apartment was a particularly well shot scene. I was also a fan of the themes and messaging of this film. The themes and messages of this film were relevant when it came out, and are still relevant today. Unfortunately, there are many things about this film that I did not like, and they all detract and distract from the film's important messaging. For starters, the opening credit sequence is ridiculous. Rosie Perez dancing like Elaine Benes to Public Enemy would not be how I would want to start this film and set the tone. I probably wouldn't have thought twice about this opening if the the dancing happened within the story, but I think that the choice to break the fourth wall was a mistake. My next gripe with this film was the introduction of Spike Lee's sister. WTF was that?! I was so thrown off, I thought that was his girlfriend! Totally distracted from a cool character introduction of Mookie. My next issue has more to do with the script as a whole than any scene in particular. Why is everyone so cartoonish in this film? Everyone acts like a caricature and stereotype despite the serious and real world underlying subject matter. The acting often felt very "theater/play" like, which really killed any possibility of immersion. This film also suffers a lot from expositional dialogue. The worst example of this was when Mookie went home to take a shower. The conversation that took place only existed to inform the audience about upcoming plot lines. Why does Mookie turn on Sal at the end? It is implied that Sal and Mookie have known each other a long time and clearly get along. Sal frequently gives Mookie a pass for slacking off on the job. Mookie goes home during the middle of the day to take a shower, and Sal just laughs it off. Mookie talks on the company phone while orders are coming through, and when Sal's son makes note of it, Sal ignores it and reprimands his son instead. If you're going to have Mookie turn on Sal, have the resentment build from the start of the movie. Don't have a scene right before the riot where Sal tells Mookie that he sees him as another son. Don't have Mookie defend Sal and the business throughout the film. Is he really just doing it for a paycheck? He delivers pizzas, and according to Rosie Perez's character, he makes no money doing that. Mookie could easily get another job delivering for somewhere else. Having Mookie be the one to start the riot made no sense and felt like a lazy way to make Mookie the catalyst for the finale. Unfortunately, the overacting and sloppy writing really detract from what should be a great film that has such a poignant message.
1 out of 2 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends