In a 2018 interview with USA Today, Jim Caviezel said "I won't tell you how he's going to go about it. But I'll tell you this much, the film he's going to do is going to be the biggest film in history. It's that good." He also said, "There are things that I cannot say that will shock the audience..It's great. Stay tuned."
In January 2018, Caviezel was in agreements with Mel Gibson to reprise his role as Jesus in the sequel.
Calling it "a vast theological experience," Gibson said that the film delves into the meaning of the resurrection by juxtaposing the central event of Jesus' rising "with the many things going on around it and in other realms." It will make connections as a way "to enlighten what that means." He implied that part of the movie would be taking place in Hell and, while talking to Raymond Arroyo, said that it also may show flashbacks depicting the fall of the Angels. The film will explore the three-day period starting on Good Friday, the day of Jesus' death, and will look at why the disciples did not recognize Jesus on the way to Emmaus.
In September 2016, Mel Gibson expressed his interest in directing this film. He estimated that the release was still "probably three years off", stating that "it is a big project".